Software
Houzz Logo Print
hisown

Soaking as you go - worth it?

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

I know that MamaP soaks as she goes. Do others? Do you get a better outcome? I don't use any additives except sometimes STPP and always Citric Acid Powder (but the CA is just in the rinse, so that would not be in the soaking solution anyway.) Correction: I do throw in some hydrogen peroxide with the white loads.

Due to extremely cranky, sensitive skin I can use only Charlie's or sometimes Nellie's detergent - nothing on the strong side and especially nothing with fragrance

Would my loads benefit from soaking? I usually manually restart my machine at least once as the wash cycle is only about 11 minutes long. Should I let the clothing soak in between?

I await your words of wisdom.

Comments (67)

  • 11 years ago

    I was talking about sparkys mixture of dawn dish soap and hydrogen peroxide for stains..

  • 11 years ago

    Sparky,

    Now I am a little confused. My husband's shirts are mostly knits, and almost all are colors. Lots are navy and black. Won't peroxide bleach the colors out? Or does mixing it in with the Dawn eliminate the bleaching effect?

    I'll buy some Blue Dawn, but I'm not going to try this until I hear back that the peroxide will not bleach the color out of the shirts.

  • 11 years ago

    To be honest I have never had to use it on a dark color. If it were me and the clothes are dark, I would just rub Dawn on the spots and let that sit a min or two then wash. I have used just the plain Dawn when I didn't have the other mixed or was out of peroxide and it does well also.

    I can't imagine the 3% peroxide bleaching anything no longer than it is on there but to be safe just try the Dawn on the darks.

  • 11 years ago

    Sparky I'm not sure if the 3% will cause any bleaching either, just what I read somewhere, but soon as I get a chance I will test it on some very dark rags, ill do cotton and cotton/ poly that should give us an answer.lol.

  • 11 years ago

    Well, I could not leave my house today due to a family issue I had to attend to, so I did not get any Dawn yet. I had a couple of stained shirts, one to wash, one to re-wash. I was afraid to try the peroxide, but I put some Method dish soap (it's all I had) on them and some of the Charlie's cleaner I mentioned above. I then scrubbed them a little with a toothbrush. The result was disappointing. The stains on one shirt are much lighter but not quite gone, and on the other shirt the bigger stain is still very visible. The Stain Stick does at least as well.

    I'll be glad to hear Mama's experiment results on the greasy, dark colored rags with the Dawn and peroxide. If I can get to a store tomorrow I'll buy some Dawn; then I could experiment myself on some deliberate stains I could make on some denim and other dark fabric scraps. Probably butter, whipped cream and some olive oil will be enough for testing purposes.

  • 11 years ago

    Hisown, sorry to go off topic a second, but I love Method dish soap the Clementine, yum. Lol

  • 11 years ago

    Of course Queenie wanted in the pic lol

  • 11 years ago

    I don't think the Method has the punch the Dawn has though. I have tried some Method dish soap, not this flavor, I forget which and it was nice. I like Cascade and Kenmore Elite best LOL.

  • 11 years ago

    MamaP,

    That's the Method one I like for handwashing dishes too!

    (It's just not too hot for clothing stains.)

  • 11 years ago

    Here's, once again, the review by America's Test Kitchen.


  • 11 years ago

    Hisown, for a few years now I have been pretreating oil and greese stains with a fels naptha soap bar. It works amazingly well. You wet the shirt, lather it up with the fels naptha and rub the shirt together. You can scrub the spots with an old toothbrush also. Then let the shirt sit at least an hour just like that. Sometimes I even let it sit overnight like that. I then rinse it out in the bathroom sink before throwing it in the wash also because of sensitive skin issues. This method has always worked like a charm for me. The longer you let the fels work, the better. It works on all kinds of stains as well, even protein stains. You can buy a bar for 97 cents at Wal-Mart in the stain remover section. I keep it in a square Rubbermaid container. I let the bar dry after I use it then close the lid. Keeps the bar great that way.

    Good luck, let me know it you try this remedy and like it.

  • 11 years ago

    I mixed up some Dawn and peroxide last night and put on a pair of shorts that are navy and green stripe. Left it for an hour, then rinsed off the place I put it on and there was no fading, but they are still wet. You can tell the navy looks the same as it does on the part I didn't treat. If you try this, you still need to do a "sample" so you will be sure before you do it on something that matters.

  • 11 years ago

    Yep I use the Fels, I wet the fabric not the soap bar and rub it in..its the best stain remover I've ever used. One bar will last forever. I don't pretreat very often but when I do I use the fels most of the time..

  • 11 years ago

    This bar is a bit butchered up, I cut some off and disolved in boiling water and made a gel stain remover..lol..I'm al


    ways playing

  • 11 years ago

    Has anyone else tried the OXICLEAN for pretreatment and then a long soak and wash?

    I have just recently started using OXICLEAN instead of SHOUT in the same treatment manner, including a long soak, and had easier, quicker, better results.

    I've tried DAWN also.

    My Hubby works in the Printing Industry. He gets Ink, Oil, and lots of unidentifiable stains on both jeans and nicer dress clothes.

    Even if his clothes don't come from work, I never wash mine and his TOGETHER. We separate when it comes to the washer! LoL

    Any soak and stain removable advice would be appreciated.






  • 11 years ago

    Well, I tried the Dawn and Peroxide mixture, but my results were not great. I made a BIG oil stain on a piece of blue denim, using light mineral oil. I sprayed it very liberally with the Dawn mixture, on both sides of the fabric and let it sit for about five minutes, then washed with other colored clothing.

    The stain was more than half gone, but not much more. Next day I washed it again, doing the same thing. This time the stain is virtually gone, and on a pair of jeans would be acceptable, but on a work shirt I'd need to do it again.

    I am so bummed!!

    I know I have very hard water here, but I do things to overcome that. I know I have skin that reacts with allergy to way too many things. I know Charlie's Soap is fine for normal dirt and odors, but not very good for stains. I've read all the stuff and saw the video on Oxyclean, but I am afraid of it. I used it years ago, but I was having so much skin trouble I don't know if that was part of the problem or not.

    We're not talking about minor skin irritation. I'm talking about bleeding shins (now who in the world gets that but me?) and rashes so bad and so itchy that I could not put my arms down at my sides because the skin on my inner arms was oozing some sort of liquid onto my clothing, etc.

    RATS!!

  • 11 years ago

    Look at the video above - Oxi Clean was the winner, especially when used as a soaking agent.

  • 11 years ago

    The laundry bar shown above Fels Naptha is the best stain remover I've ever used, wet the fabric rub the bar on the stain and wash..what laundry detergent do you use?? That can make a huge difference. Stains need a detergent with enzymes. Enzymes break down the stains in fabric so they can be washed away...I recommend tide powder, it has lots of enzymes. Soaking in powder tide and powder biz has worked with amazing results for me.my hubs is retired but works patt time in a auto parts store his clothes always come home with grease spots and ink stains around the shirt pocket...I don't pretreat, I wash with a good powdered detergent and powdered biz and I always soak, sometimes a 30 minute soak sometimes overnight. The oxi your using is also ok. But to actuslly answer your question, ( sometimes I go off topic, ok I do it s lot ) instead of pretreating why dony you try soaking..much easier..it works for me...just make sure the stains are out before you dry the garment....oops I just seen the oil stains your hubs gets...liquid detergent works better on oil..whst detergent do you use?


  • 11 years ago

    Okay, I'm calmed down now.

    MamaP,

    You have talked about using just the active ingredient that is in Oxyclean. Have you used it yet? Is it fabulous on stains? (I say 'fabulous' deliberately, on the theory that if it is fabulous with stronger detergent, maybe it would work reasonably well with the mild stuff I have to use.) My thought is that maybe if I bought just the 'pure' stuff, without whatever additives Oxyclean no doubt adds, I could at least try using it with less risk than using it plus the additives.

    To anyone,

    I looked at the Persil in WalMart designed for folks with cranky skin, but it contains fragrance. What were they thinking? I'd love to try this, but fragrance is one of the key irritants in laundry products. Has anyone with allergy problems used this successfully? I found the other commercial detergents with no fragrance still no good for my skin. Persil is new to me, but sounds likely to cause problems.

    I used to wash my husband's clothing in 'regular' detergents and mine in the milder stuff, but still had reactions. The dermatologist told me I can't use the stuff in my machines at all, as I was reacting to the teeny weeny bit left behind in the machines, probably the dryer as that never rinses. I thought that sounded crazy, but I did what he said, and sure enough, my skin finally cleared up.

    Well, maybe I just have to go back to accepting that I need to wash my husband's shirts that get stained two or three times to finally get the stupid stains out.

    I'll still watch for other ideas, but maybe I'm beaten. Again, rats.

  • 11 years ago

    mamapinky,

    Are you saying above that you don't pretreat stains at all - just soak?

  • 11 years ago

    Or do you pretreat with Fels Naptha first?

  • 11 years ago

    I just now found some Fels Naptha in my laundry room, from back when I made my own laundry detergent. I'll try that on Monday's laundry. Hubby is cooking some things today, so there for sure will be some greasy stains to tackle by then.

    First time I'll try it with just water sprayed on the stains, then working it over with the bar.

    If that's doesn't work well, I'll spray first with the Dawn/Peroxide mixture, then work in the bar. Maybe that will do it.

    I do get frustrated, but I am persistent!

  • 11 years ago

    Hisown, once in a blue moon I pretreat, I used to all the time but I realized I didn't need to when using soaks with a enzyme detergent. .and darn it I wanted to post a pic of my sons white socks before washing but forgot...yes in my opinion the pure sodium percarbonate is FABULOUS...I used to use Biz but I use powdered detergent which has sodium carbonate (washing soda) in it, than add biz or oxiwash which is mostly sodium carbonate. This stuff is ok in detergent, but when adding a booster that contains it is overload. Sodium carbonate is hard to rinse out when its used in excess and causes stiff or scratchy fabrics..so I went straight for the pure sodium percarbonate. Not to mention if im buying oxi, i want oxi not 50%+ fillers..Hmmm I'm not sure if it removes all stains or if it is my enzyme detergent removing the stains, but I'll tell you it whitens like you wouldn't believe, I usually use tide with bleach or foca along with 1 oz sodium percarbonate and hot water and I always let my whites soak overnight..WHITE. I can't remember if you've tried powder All free or powder Tide free but they both have enzymes. If you already buy oxiclean I'm assuming for the oxi bleach than I'd try sodium percarbonate. .I recommend you buy it from amazon, I think I paid around 15 $ for 20 pounds..and it causes no sudsing and has no perfumes. I think it would work great with Charlies and Nellies...I hesitate to mention this but...have you considered trying phosphates...its sold on amazon type in STPP.. it is perfume and dye free and will boost the power of charlies like crazy..actually in my opinion it works better than any booster that is out there..let me know if your interested in info on STPP. By the way STPP will solve your hard water washing.

    Ok the Persil Sensitive, I have it and hate it. It cleans very well but I can't stand the scent. I would say with your skin issues stear clear of it. Remember its *sensitive* not *free and clear* ya I don't get the sensitive part because its pretty strong and I'm not too sensitive with scents, for instance I'm told Euro Persil Mega color perls is very strong but I love the scent of it. Feel free to ask about the STPP or anything else...

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks MamaP,

    I have been using STPP for about a week now. I can't say I notice any difference so far, but I have only been using a tablespoon, as my machine is a front loader. Maybe I need to double that. Then again, my clothes are getting clean, I'm just having trouble with those lousy stains.

    Inspired by you, I soaked the last white load I did for an hour, and the socks did seem a little brighter.

    So, Sodium Percarbonate is the active part of Oxyclean. If I don't have serious success with using the Fels Naptha bar on stains I might order some of that too. But I watched the Oxyclean video mentioned up above, and separately presoaking his shirts in a bucket sounds like a pain. I'd much rather just treat the stains, then let the whole load soak, then finish washing.

    Do you soak colored loads containing stained garments? Does the Sodium Percarbonate work better on stains that way? Would Fels Naptha work better on stains that way?

    If you or anyone responds tomorrow, I won't be in town, so my non-response will just mean I'm not home, not that I am ungrateful for the help. Thanks.


  • 11 years ago

    I Do soak colored loads that are stained, but don't use oxi on any coloreds or darks, I know its touted as being * The Color Safe Bleach* but long soaks in it or using it on colors will begin to fade them. Fels should work very well on its own but it will not remove wine or any purple juice stains.

  • 11 years ago

    If you do the peroxide/Dawn again, soak longer than 5 minutes. Let them sit an hour or so.

  • 11 years ago

    Hisown...I was thinking about your issues, stains yet very sensitive skin issues...well we all know enzymes remove stains but there are no enzymes in the detergent you use due to skin issues..I've heard of a product called Biokleen Bac-Out stain remover, I think its formulated with enzymes and I think its all natural and recommended for sensitive skin..I will try to research it a bit sometime today.

    As far as your STPP if you can open the lid of your washer, add the stpp first with no detergents or additives, feel the water, if it feels slippery you've added enough stpp, if it doesn't feel slippery add a bit more and feel it again, let the washer go a few minutes in between additions to get it mixed up..

  • 11 years ago

    I used the Fels Naptha bar on a shirt today, and soaked for over an hour, but it did not work well either. Next time I'll add the Dawn/Peroxide mix as the wetting agent and see if I get better results that way.

    I really don't get it. These things work for everyone else. Is it the very hard water? Do I need to use double the detergent? I have already doubled the STPP.

    I'll report in once I have added the Dawn/Peroxide to the Fels Naptha, probably tomorrow. Surely something will eventually work. I'll keep at it.

  • 11 years ago

    Put the Dawn and Peroxide on and rub it in with a toothbrush. You wash in warm water? Soaking couldn't hurt but the STPP should take care of your hard water. I know Pink likes the Fels but for me I have never had any luck with it--no better than using regular hand soap of some brand and rubbing in. Octagon soap was better for me but things are different in different water. They stopped making Octagon now though. Can you use Pure/Free or whatever they call it Wisk? That should work or Tide Free.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Sparky,

    So Fels didn't work for you either. That makes me feel a little better. I'm going to use the Fels and the Dawn/Peroxide together tomorrow, working them both in very well with a brush, then letting it sit a long while, then soaking part way through the wash. If that's no good, I think I'll dump them both and go back to Stain Stick plus Charlie's Outdoor Cleaner. That combo worked as well as anything else I have tried so far, and is easier to apply.

    I can't use Wisk or Tide, even in the supposedly 'free' versions. I react badly to them.

    And yes, I wash most clothing in warm water. I don't use cold at all, (don't trust it) and I use hot with whites or loads that are only towels and/or sheets.

  • 11 years ago

    Can you use anything like Shout? They have an advanced stain remover for set in stains, comes in a squeezable bottle with a scrubber top. That got out set in blood stains out of a quilt of mine as well as some other nasty stains in other clothes.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Are you using warm water to get out grease stains? Nothing short of hot will shift them. what kind of stain stick are you refering to? Grease and oil and are tough to remove, but not impposiable. But you will need hot water. Do the perfumes in dawn dish liquid not bother you? This is your hubs clothes right? You may have to either wash his seperate from yours in a good liquid laundry detergent, or soak his in the stuff in a bucket with very hot water. This is what I would do ..use an empty tub..or large buckets..put the garments in...cover with very hot water..add a generous dose of TOL liquid detergent (liquid removes greasy oils best) let soak..change water add new detergent every 6 hours...you can continue doing this as long as needed..but nothing short of a TOL detergent and hot wster is going to shift that grease.

  • 11 years ago

    I want to add, if the garments have been dried, its going to be tougher.

  • 11 years ago

    I think I read where hisown said the dermatologist said not to use one thing on other clothes and then use the other (Charlies I think) because of transfer from washing to washing. Might try running washer with vinegar between loads to clear out previous product?

  • 11 years ago

    Ya I was also thinking of cleaning the washer between..I'm not sure how they can tolorate the perfumes in dawn.

  • 11 years ago

    Pink: LOL I can't believe you said that. Dawn doesn't smell loud. It is the plain blue kind plus mixed with the peroxide dilutes it--there is hardly a smell. Now Persil will knock the roof off the house and Gain. I wouldnt wash my dogs stuff in Gain(if I had a dog ha). Dermatologist told one time that Gain was by far the worst detergent for allergies there was and I believe that--Persil being 2nd for me. I was sick for days before I figured out it was the Persil. Not being hateful, just stating how it works for me just as maybe Dawn does you the same way. What dish soap you use? I have tried the Method but it just doesn't soap up a lot I don't think.

  • 11 years ago

    LOl sparky..dawn may not have much scent but it still has perfumes to some degree...sparky I use the dishwasher but I never put pots and pans in it..lol sparky you ask..remember that..

    Dawn original

    Dawn free and clear

    Joy original

    Palmolive original, and pink gentle,

    Method

    JR Watkins..lemon

    H. E. B

    Palmolive with a touch of aloe

    Palmolive with oxi

    Gain

    Ajax

    And a bunch of boutique ones from TJ Maxx

    Lmao...best one for greasy dishes..Dawn hands down...best smelling JR Watkins lemon yum

    As for Gain laundry detergent. .I have a bunch I never use, except at times the gain with oxi, the others I can't stand the scent.

  • 11 years ago

    Sparky you would never believe the bath bars I have...lol

  • 11 years ago

    Sparky I can't resist..I found this soap at an auction. .lol..resd the package on the second pic

  • 11 years ago

  • 11 years ago

    Hisown..sorry I got off topic a moment..lol..I could not resist

    Ok did you check into the Biokleen bac out?? Its formulated for sensitive skin. Back to business here..how about if you soak hubs shirts in a good liquid detergent. .in hot hot water. Than wash with charlies. Lol he won't wear an apron how about a shirt apron..you could have him wear the already stained ones when he's cooking. Keep a few in the kitchen so he can change into the *shirt apron* lol. I'm sorry it must be tough when you have skin this sensitive and all the good stuff is off limits. But I would check into the biokleen bac out..I've heard good about it

  • 11 years ago

    Going by the original post..I will adf this..my son left his old beach towel on the line yesterday..omg its filthy, I suspect he wiped dirty greasy hands on it and planned throwing it away..I did a prewash this morning, with sears ( green box) than started a soak 135 deg.f...1/4 cup Tide professional and my lovely STPP its soaked about 2 hours, now its on rinse, but the results are going to be dramitic..here's the before pic..stay tuned for final results

  • 11 years ago

    Spotless..and forgot I added 1/2 oz sodium percarbonate

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have never tried the Watkins. I tried Caldrea in citron ginger and it smells pretty good. I too use the dishwasher and I do put in the pans/pots--not iron of course. Never bought the Gain dish detergent but do use Palmolive sometimes--the regular green--tons of suds. I cant imagine using those Gain pacs for the dishwasher that Cascade has. How could you drink out of a glass afterward cause there is no way that gets rinsed out of there I don't believe. Let us know how the black towel turns out LOL. Does look like greasy hands.

    Just posted--then saw the towel--spotless.!!! The Pink Soak...

  • 11 years ago

    Sparky I use cascade complete powder no gain in my cascade, I just bought a box of great value powder..I haven't seen it in awhile I thought it was discontinued, I'm trying it now with 1 teaspoon stpp.. so I hope it works. I don't put pots and pans in because there's never enough room, anyway and this machines like 20 years old lol, yep it was moms.

  • 11 years ago

  • 11 years ago

    It should work better than the new ones--at least it uses water. Mine is 13 yrs old. Bearings went bad in the motor from a slow pump leak. Couldn't find a new one I liked. New ones, the racks seem smaller and flimsy so I just spent $200 and had a new motor/pump put in this one and glad I did. Quieter than it was and cleans great but it did that before. $200 cheaper than $800-1000.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes sparky, I will hang onto this d/w as long as I can..I have an old Lady K, needs a bit of work, nothing major that I know of, one of these days ill pick it up do some white epoxy on a bit of rust on the inside where the drain is, throw a plug on and a hose and check it out...outside.hopefully it works, I like it and it has the round roto rack.

    I know the new dishwashers all have restricted amounts of water, I couldn't stand that.

  • 11 years ago

    I wish they still mad e the round rack models. Mine is a Kenmore Elite.

  • 11 years ago

    My first dw had the round top rack, harvest gold Kenmore. On the Cleaning tip forum there is a discussion on smelly dishes with I believe the newer dw's. So if you have a good not so new one better hang on to it. Sorry but it takes more than 3 or 4 gallons of water to get dishes clean.