Software
Houzz Logo Print
begonia2015

Old soil in summer pots/containers?...

11 years ago

Please forgive what you will probably find to be an insulting question - but I did a forum search and was not really able to find a good answer.

I do some gardening in a few containers and I still don't know what to with the old soil in the container.

After the annuals are done, winter comes and goes, and it's time to plant in the container again in the spring...I have mostly started with fresh, store-bought soil every year.

I simply dumped the old soil in a corner of my back yard that borders a little thicket that separates our yard from the neighbors (pic below, see the background) and replaced with new from the store.

I didn't know what else to do with the old soil; but now that I got a couple of larger containers/pots and there seems to be a little pile of old soil accumulating in that backyard spot...I am starting to wish that I did not have to change the old soil every year.

I understood that the old soil gets depleted and must be replaced with fresh...but what happens when you have a big container? The replacing can get expensive.

Can't I re-use the old soil from the corner of my backyard if I amend it with fertilizer?

I am thinking that in the meantime, that dumped soil may have gotten mixed with some leaves/mulches or other organic matter from the outdoors, and it may have been re-enriched again. Am I wrong?

I don't know anything about compost and I am afraid that any attempt in that direction would end up as a smelly affair that would disturb sensitive suburban neighbors. :-)

Any advice would be appreciated as to what I should do with the soil when a container like this...

...(and others) will be done for the year.

I would also appreciate some help with how to refresh the soil for those containers I plan to overwinter. For example, I have a large, 20 inch diameter container with a canna lily in it which I plan to drag in the garage when the cold hits.

If I don't change the soil in the container next spring (which I don't plan on doing because there's so much of it and I just planted the canna)... how should I refresh it/replenish so the canna will thrive in the new season?

Thank you so much!



Comments (6)

  • 11 years ago

    i haven't added any new soil to my containers for at least 10 yrs. and things are fine. as long as you fertilize why bother?

  • 11 years ago

    When I've had to discard old soil, I've tossed it in with compost and it 'integrates' well in short order.

  • 11 years ago

    It depends on what sort of potting soil you are using. A high quality, durable potting soil does not need to be replaced every year. But a cheaper, less durable mix - as most commercial bagged mixes are - does degrade and can do so quite rapidly, making it unsuitable for successful growing in future seasons.

    I grow very heavily in containers, including semi-permanent plantings like trees and shrubs and I certainly do not replace that soil annually. But I do use a very textural and durable soil mix like 5-1-1 and gritty mixes discussed in detailed length on the Container Gardening forum. Even this type of soil mix doesn't last forever and should be replaced/refreshed periodically.

    If you are using a fine particled, highly organic (and therefore decomposable) mix like Miracle Gro or its equivalents, then at the very least you will want add at least half the volume with fresh soil mix. And dump the entire pot out to get all the soil out before you remix with the fresh stuff. The bottom of the pot is where the worst soil conditions will be. Personally, if using this sort of soil mix I would NOT reuse year after year. It only gets worse over time, not better, despite whatever amendments you might add.

    And also personally, I would not reuse previously dumped soil. No telling what else has migrated into it and you do not want to introduce insect or disease issues into your containers. Nor do you want to introduce more organic, decomposable material (like leaves, etc.) as that just further complicates aeration and drainage issues most bagged potting soil inherently has. Just spread the dumped soil throughout your garden. It doesn't need to remain in an isolated pile and can help to improve regular garden soil.

    And don't worry about the nutrient content of the potting mix - it's purpose is to support and enhance root growth via porosity, aeration and fast drainage. All the nutrients should be supplied by you in the form of routine fertilization. Container growing is much different from inground or even raised bed growing and needs to be approached differently from common inground gardening practices.

    I'd suggest you visit the Container Gardening forum for further direction and insights.

  • 11 years ago

    I second the composting idea.

    IF you are uncomfortable with composting (not sure why a gardener would be) maybe a new trash can to dump/mix/blend old potting soil it would be more to your liking?

    I would use the stuff dumped in the corner too but keep in mind there are likely weed seeds in it by now.

  • 11 years ago

    One of my neighbors moved away and left me all of her pots =) ! But most of the flowers had died. I emptied these all into a big bin, watered, stirred them up and re-planted (mostly flowers in pots/containers) All the flowers did great!

    I had some left over and added it to the compost pile. Nancy

  • 11 years ago

    Potting soil doesn't really get 'depleted'. Well, it does lose nutrients, but you can always add granular fert. or water with soluble. The two main problems I've run into are diseases (tomato blight) and breakdown of the woody shreds causing compactability and poor drainage. I live in a hot humid wet area where fungi are a real issue. You might not have to worry about it. I use some of last year's soil, blended with compost and the coarsest potting mix I can find (which improves drainage). If I'm worried about blight I use that for the bottom half of the pot and cover with fresh potting mix, so there is no chance of splashing onto the leaves.

    Old soil is not only good in the compost, you can dig it directly into garden soil or in perennial beds, spread it on the surface and mulch over the top. It will improve the soil texture just like compost would.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio