I like the straight across one for its simplicity, that, and it's less fussy. Assuming they're entirely at fault, and you still prefer the straight across one, I'd have them replace it. If you like the curve, and they'll give you a discount on top of that, well, that could be good, too.

I like the curve too-it softens the look.

I agree with Carrie.

Love the curve. It raises/draws the eye up the the beautiful pot filler feature.

I'd keep it.

Also agree with Carrie. I wanted and got a straight hood, and would have been disappointed with anything different than my expectations. But if you can live with it, you should certainly be given something for accepting their mistake.

It really depends on whether or not you're a curve person or a straight line person. I am a straight line person. I like strong, straight lines - I like their statement, I like their no-nonsense, I like their message of strength. We live in a post and beam house for a reason. Because of the lines.

I don't care for curves. Now, two things - which kind of person are you, and if you are prepared to accept the curve, is that ok with your house.

When our crown molding was installed it was the wrong one - it had a swoop curve to it, I did make them take it out. No amount of discount was going to fix this.

See I'm kinda weird I guess... I like certain curves but in general I'm a straight line person. I love turned legs on farmhouse tables. I love corbels with a simple curve. Overall though I don't like curves or angles (no angled walls, etc).

I'm a straight line person too. I prefer the straight one but it really is just personal preference. Another reason I don't like the curved one because it is predictable which is why they probably made the mistake. Most people probably ask for the curved. That being said I do like some curves like the round light fixture, curves on cup pulls etc.

I like the curve. Curves are usually my preference. AnnKH said my thoughts well. Even so, it's your kitchen get what you want and it sounds like you want the straight line. Just be sure it'll make you smile every time you see it ;)

I like the curve, it is very welcoming and draws the eye in. You already have a lot of straight lines.

In these pics, I prefer the curve. Once your crown molding (to the ceiling) is installed, I'm pretty sure I'll prefer the straight hood.

I like the contrast between the straight lines & the curve hood. I find the straight to be to boxy looking. Anyone you go with will be beautiful.

I like the curve. It seems to break up all the straight lines and andes interest.

I almost always prefer straight lines. But, in this case, seeing the side by side comparison, I actually prefer the curved hood. The straight hood looks too boxy and out of sorts with the curves in the corbels.

Have the innards of the vent been installed? I remember a different poster who was not happy with how her vent showed in a curved hood. She ended up with a curve, but had it modified, iirc. So that's something to consider if the vent itself hasn't been installed yet, will it show too much for your liking with the curved hood?

Aside from that, I like the straight line, but both are nice. If you still prefer the straight line, I would have them redo it. No point looking at it for the next decade thinking, it would've looked better if they had done what I told them to.

I like the curve...it softens all the hard lines and softens the look...makes it more welcoming and homey somehow. But that's me, only you can decide if you will hate it every time you look at it.

You know... I am a fan of straight lines but I have to say I prefer the curved. It looks more interesting. I think maybe its a good mistake? If you hate it then, you can always redo it. I really do like the curve though... especially in your kitchen which looks beautiful!

There is a recent post where someone ended up with a curved finish board topping the bookcase under her island. She'd wanted straight. In the end she spent over $1,000 to change it because it bothered her so much.

In her case I could definitely have lived with the curve on that finish board in its location. But in your case where the unwanted curve is on the hood I'd feel differently because it's a focal point of your kitchen and drives the look you wanted and ordered. If you still want it, you should have them change it.

I priced out one of those straight hoods to mirror the mantel we have over the fireplace in view of our kitchen. It was an expensive feature and I decided to pass. I would have been upset if I'd sprung for it and ended up with a curved hood.

If it suits your overall vision, I will say that from the pics you posted I like both the curved & straight hood with your cabinets.

Thanks so much everyone! Really appreciate the feedback! We went to see it again last night (we're not living in the house yet). I thought seeing it in person again would help make up my mind, and nope, still confused. Here are the full pictures so you can see a little better the context it's in. The counter tops are TCE4005 which is a carrera-lookalike quartz with warmer tones in it. The floors are Chelsea Plank Wolf Creek hickory (very rustic looking with knots, etc). Backsplash will most likely be Creamy Crackle subway tile or just plain creamy subway tile. Kinda throwing around the idea of a beadboard backsplash in the same colour as the cabinets as well (BM Cloud White).

..... and now looking at these pics, I like the curve! I flip flop SO MUCH!

Sometimes having everything the same is boring and nothing stands out as a focal point because it all looks the same. I think that curve just accentuates that beautiful range hood and makes it stand out amidst all the straight lines. Your kitchen will be absolutely gorgeous whichever you choose but I think the curve enhances it.

>>>"I wanted a more modern country kitchen, more casual, etc, and I find that the curve makes it feel more formal."<<<

I think the straight is more in keeping with this sentiment. A less formal look might be more cohesive with your "rustic looking with knots" floor. Had you considered removing the corbels?

Looks lovely.

I usually prefer straight lines as well but I really like the curve. It's a tough decision. Good luck!

Leaning towards the curved top even more with the knots in the floors.

It's going to be SPECTACULAR!

Thanks everyone! I went with the curve. After looking at both pictures for hours (literally) I find the straight one kinda blends more into the cabinets. The whole idea was that it would be the focal point of the room. The curve really drew my eye in more. Curve it is! :D Feels good to have the decision made!

I am a straight line person and I do prefer the straight. I believe I could live with the curve in this case. Is there going to be an island? That could impact my decision.

Yes my husband will be building a custom island for me, it's going to have turned legs, a book shelf on either end, and a plain back (probably with some beadboard panels). Most likely will be painted in a black or gray with some distressing, and a butcher block countertop. He's also building me a small farmhouse table to butt up against the island (I'm opposed to bar stools lol)

Yeah! Happy to know you were able to make a considered choice. I think you're going to have a stunning kitchen. The pieces your DH is making sound lovely. Hope you'll share results when it's completed.

I think your kitchen is awesome and you would not be wrong with either hood. But, I like the curved choice. Congrats - another decision down for you!

Oh, island with turned legs? Now I'm not looking back at the straight hood!

Curved is going to echo a subtle theme and it's all going to be harmonious.

I'm so happy this was serendipitous for you!

I'm glad you made that choice! I much preferred the curve, and I agree with everyone who said it made the hood stand out better and work better as the focal point.