I like the Sedona Canyon. The light tones in the shingles matches your brick!

Both look really nice. Toss a coin!

I love those new Owens Corning roofing shingles. They add good color and texture to an otherwise plain house. They're like a beautiful tweed jacket, the way the colors mix.

Thank all, I went with Sedona Canyon. @kpappal. I did put a dark grey shingle in the Owens Corning designer app. I was not a fan of the dark grey. However, I do want to replace the shutters. I thought they looked too small as well. On a trip down to NOLA I saw lots of houses with thick wood shutters. I am wondering how that would look on this house. I think I would have to replace the outdoor fixtures as well.

Good choice! Glad you stayed away from grey. Your brick is very cool! I agree as well that the shutters don't work with the windows.Tthey should be eliminated completely from the picture window but could easily be sized correctly for the other two. Oil rubbed bronze fixtures would show up well against your brick and coordinate nicely with your new roof. You might consider toning down the garage by painting it a few shades lighter than your brick so it blends in more as well as painting your downspout a color close to the brick to keep it from standing out too much. Hope this helps!