Here is an example of the pendants with the milk glass and metal combo on the shade. I asked and the light diffuser is removable so I could still use Edison Bulbs with this style. The shape of this light is similar to the shapes on the Kenzie. They all remind me of upturned wine goblets.

My hardware is oil-rubbed bronze. So dark that it is close to black. Is this shade too dark for over the black quartz countertop?

"Before" shot of our project....

I like those, too. My husband likes the flared style and I like the cage; but wondered if the shape should be similar to the Kenzie chandelier. The flare is a whole 'nother shape. This is one of those things that I struggle through.

I'd say both can work, the clear glass pendants or the pendant with the milk glass metal combo. As long as the metal colors are similar.The last one looks a little too rustic for your kitchen

I've got an eclectic look going. Somewhat modern but it will have plenty of vintage touches. Hip Grandma kitchen. :) I want it to remind me of my own grandmother but with stainless appliances. The caged lights would work for what I am after, too, since I tend to have beachy touches everywhere. I really am appreciating the opinions. I've worked through hundreds of decisions but am stuck with the last two. We just added some vintage-style hardware--cup-style pulls and coordinating handles. That really took the look more toward vintage, then when we started.