Software
Houzz Logo Print
jayme_smith88

Best Detergent for Front Loader with Septic System

11 years ago

I'm so confused- I've been using Tide Free & Gentle liquid with my HE front loader. I'd like to use Tide powder but I'm reading that powder is not good for septic systems and that I should be using something like Seventh Generation. I was told that if you use a plant based detergent, you have to wash everything on hot to get things clean. What is true? Is powder still bad for septic tanks?

Comments (14)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    From what I've read, liquid detergent is recommended for a septic system & recommends the below detergents.

    In my opinion, you might not have a septic system issue using Tide free & gentle because a FL washer uses so much less detergent. Mine uses 1 or 2 tablespoons depending.

    Possibly that small amount or infrequent washing (also recommended online) have worked in your favor.

    I don't have a septic system, nor know the cost of repair if it backs up or doesn't function properly. Almost need a cost/benefit analysis on this one.

    If it was me in that situation, I wouldn't use powder. I'd stick to the recommended list.

    (Because I have bad luck when I don't follow rules, karma always finds me).

    --------

    • Amway S-A-8
    • Arm & Hammer
    • Boraxo
    • Cheer
    • Dash
    • Equator
    • Fresh Start
    • Oxydol
    • Seventh Generation
    Jayme Smith thanked Pawprint
  • 11 years ago

    Our last home had a septic system and I used powder and the occasional liquid. Liquids have polymers that are intended not to break down but used reasonably I don't think either would be an issue. The things we did not use were bleach or excessive antibacterial items be it in laundry, dishwasher or other products.

    Jayme Smith thanked sandy1616
  • 11 years ago

    We have the septic system with the sprinklers and the man who pumps said to be careful with powder. The powder (Tide) was apparently not dissolving all the way with another customer of his with the same type of system as we have. He didn't say don't use powder at all but not to use it all the time. I think the type of system you have probably has a lot to do with it ( leach field or sprinklers).

  • 11 years ago

    I am on city water, but my mother has a 50-year old septic system my jack-leg father installed, and it has needed to be pumped only once in my memory. Until today, I never heard you had to use a special laundry product for septic. Mom uses whatever she can get with a coupon, but she tends toward powder. She does use clorox occasionally, but very few anti-bac products. She uses only one kind of TP -- something that is rated for septic. And once every couple of months, she throws some old yeast or a half-cup of Rid-X down the 'loo. Everything works fine, but certainly YMMV. If I were on septic, I guess I would heed the list most of the time, but use what I needed to get the hard stains clean.

  • 11 years ago

    A septic is like a compost pile. If it won't break down, don't put it in there. The big thing is not to kill the enzymes and bacteria that decompose everything. I'll have to google sprinkler septic. No idea how that works.

  • 11 years ago

    When we were considering a house on septic, I was warned we wouldn't be able to use bleach, antibacterials or toilet bowl cleaners. As I went down the grocery store aisles I started reading labels that said 'safe for septic'. I was amazed at how many products ARE septic safe but laundry would require a complete overhaul for me. Not only is it recommended to do some laundry everyday, so the septic isn't overloaded, but using earth-friendly cleaners in eco-conscious machines is needed. We didn't buy that house as it worked out but we learned more about the impact of green-living. So we started switching out the harsh chemicals and haven't looked back since. My allergies have improved and I'm having less headaches. I still keep the bleach on hand but have phased out my homes chemical-dependency.

  • 11 years ago

    As I said in another post, we have the septic with sprinklers. I have always used bleach for whites but not in huge amounts since there is only the 2 of us. Anyway, I quit using bleach about 6 months ago and have seen a huge difference. You have to use chlorine tablets to sanitize the water that is removed via a sprinkler system and since I quit the liquid bleach, we have noticed that we are not adding as many tablets. Why that is I really don't know, but that's the way it has worked out. BTW, the tabs were $82 per 10 pound bucket. But as you said moroseaz, I keep a small bottle of bleach on hand just in case.

  • 11 years ago

    My aerobic septic system with discharge sprinklers is 10+ years old and is on a (county-required) maintenance contract. Inspection done every 4 months. I've always primarily used powders. The service company has told me my system is one of the cleanest they see.

  • 11 years ago

    We had total septic failure 4 years ago and had to replace. Once you see how basic the system is you become very aware.

    The plumber's comment about the defunct tank, which cracked and leaked, is that there was a lot of dried soap in there. Having watched them install the new system I am very careful. I should probably be more careful and only use things like Vaska vs the Persil I sometimes use.

    The saving grace is that I use very small amounts, however since our water is very soft. I also use Rid X once a month to keep the system healthy. I never use chlorine bleach as that's an issue for septic systems and I don't use antibacterial anything. Alcohol does a better job anyway and evaporates. I use half a Method dishwasher tab for most loads and only an occasional Finish quantum because those contain some bleach.

    Not sure there is a "best" product. Depending on size and usage, septic systems need to be professionally pumped out every so many years -- there's a chart for that online. For our house it's every 7 years. If it's built properly and maintained, it should be problem free.

  • 11 years ago

    Mizzlizzie I had to look up the word "jackleg!" Ha ha ha. Although if your father was able to make a septic system - even poorly - I have to say i am impressed.

  • 11 years ago

    LOL, kitasei. Dad did everything half-assed, and in his own good time, but he and Mom raised four kids and never had a mortgage. Sometimes I laugh at the weird crap he did around thehouse -- cased doors in strangely cut lumber, mismatched, salvaged hardwoods in each room -- but it's still standing solid as a rock and now has "patina." LOL. When the county inspector came to inspect the system, Dad told him he and his .357 had already inspected it, and that he needed to get off his lawn. Never saw the dude again. Yeah, Dad was crazy.

  • 10 years ago

    Septic tank safe detergent should not contain phosphates and also have
    low levels of surfactants. The brand must also show the soap is
    biodegradable. The expansion of algae encourages.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    My plumber says that phosphates will not hurt the septic system. I have been on our septic since 1990, and my inlaws for 15 years before that. The only trouble we've had has been to clear the intake line of tree roots. The tank was opened 2 years ago to do this and the plumber said it was fine. I don't use bleach or other harsh chemicals. I use mostly water with surface cleaning. For years people have been using phosphated cleaning products, until not too long ago. I don't use any Rid-X either, used to years ago but stopped years ago. Our tank has never been pumped.