Software
Houzz Logo Print
wei_zhou12

A concern about grafting persimmons

10 years ago

I have two Fuyu persimmons trees in my yard. Most of the fruits harvested from the two trees have no seeds.

Now I am thinking of grafting some other varieties (like Saijo) onto the Fuyu trees. By doing this, I guess I would then get fruits with seeds, because the two different varieties would cross-pollinate each other. Is my understanding correct?

For those of you growing more than one persimmons varieties, do most of the fruits have seeds?

Comments (13)

  • 10 years ago

    That sounds correct to me.

  • 10 years ago

    Whether you would end up with seeded fruit very much depends upon which varieties you grafted onto the Fuyu. If the variety you grafted sets staminate flowers then the fruits are likely to have some seeds. Some varieties commonly set male blossoms, some occasionally do and others never do. I would not expect you to have seeded fruit if you grafted Saijo onto Fuyu.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you very much, tjasko and creekweb! Now I feel very comfortable to graft Saijo onto Fuyu, knowing that I would not get seedy fruits.

  • 10 years ago

    You can differentiate the male flower from a female flower. Male flower is a cluster of three flowers and female flower is a single flower.

    Tony

  • 10 years ago

    Saijo produces male flowers. That was the example the original poster used. If you graft Saijo, and it produces male flowers that pollenize the Fuyu female flowers, the Fuyu fruit will have seeds.

  • 10 years ago

    I have grown Saijo in my persimmon orchard since 2002 and have never seen a male flower or a seed in thousands of persimmons. If there were any seed production at all in a Saijo/Fuyu multi-grafted tree, it would be the result of pollination from male flowers from the Fuyu, which occasionally grow on some variants. If this slight possibility is a cause for concern, you can instead graft onto the Fuyu a variety like Hiratanenashi which yields seedless fruit even if pollinated.

  • 10 years ago

    Tony and creekweb, thank you both for your further clarification!

  • 10 years ago

    Interesting creekweb, Thanks for the correction. I based my post on what I've read, not personally experienced. Where are you located? It is difficult to find information on which Kaki produce male flowers and under what circumstances.


  • 10 years ago

    Murkwell, where did you read that Saijo has male flowers? There is some limited information on which persimmons grow male flowers in sections on cultivars in some of the publications by agricultural schools, state departments of agriculture, CRFG publications and some books such as Lee Reich's Uncommon Fruits. Anecdotal information on this subject is also more reliable than on other more complex issues. I grow persimmons near NYC.

  • 10 years ago

    I tried to graft a saijo onto my fuyu using a saddle graft; it did not take. What type of graft do you recommend for this operation?

  • 10 years ago

    I bark grafted a Tam Kam and Ichi on my Nikita's Giftt hybrid persimmon. They both took. Top work with large diameter branches seem to take well.

    Tony

  • 10 years ago

    I only had success grafting persimmon when I held my scions until the daytime temperatures were in the 80's. Here, near Portland, OR that was in June. I mostly did whip and tongue, maybe a couple of bark grafts.

    I put Chocolate and Coffeecake onto Virginiana rootstock that was established in the ground. Also onto Fuyugaki.

    Creekweb, I'm embarrassed to say that I'm having a difficult time recreating the quick Google search that convinced me that Saijo makes male flowers. Its a notion that I'd had in my head for some time. All I can find now are hit summaries with the words "Saijo" and "male flowers" positioned misleadingly.