Software
Houzz Logo Print
misscarolyn

Pottery Barn Hotel medicine cabinet is not white white....

10 years ago

I bought the PB Hotel recessed medicine cabinet way ahead of time and just installed the wainscoting, which is to be painted white. Upon opening the box, the medicine cabinet "white" is more of a creamy white, but not white white, like my Daltile #0100 subway tiles in tub enclosure, and the pedestal sink. Do I paint cabinet and wainscoting a brighter white? Or should I exchange for a gray cabinet (there is gray in my rustic porcelain "wood" floors and in shower niche. Worried the PB gray might not match the gray in the niche tiles. I can put pics on tomorrow. What would you do? I'm kind of afraid to paint the nice expensive medicine cabinet and possibly mess it up. Or is it okay to mix the whites??

Comments (15)

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I would have no fear of painting the med cabinet. Simply prime and paint the exposed white. Or EXCHANGE for a stainless, or no frame, or chrome frame to tie into your faucet on pedestal, diverters etc. You don't have to match a "painted" surface.

  • 10 years ago
    Got it! I would have love a beveled curvy sort of mirror hanging from a ribbon or rope, but need max storage. I'm going to think about painting the medicine cabinet.
  • 10 years ago
    I also wonder if anyone knows if there is a brand and paint color that might match the PB medicine cabinet....anyone? I've got time, lol
  • 10 years ago

    i wish i had read your post before buying this "white" cabinet. seriously, PB, i am beyond ticked off at this moment... they represent this cabinet as white, and it shows bright white on their website. it's FAR from bright white, and will look like junk against white subway tile.


  • 9 years ago
    I, too, just purchased a medicine cabinet from PB and it was advertised as white, but it is off-white. I'm going to have to paint it because it looks goofy against white trim.
  • 7 years ago

    Same situation here. Did not realize the PB medicine cabinet would be off-white and now wondering if I should paint to match the trim. Did anyone successfully paint over their PB medicine cabinet. If so, would you be able to post some pictures?


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    If you haven't painted, I would return or just buy something that works and use this in you're basement. If you are confident in painting skills, pick the same white as your trim, sand with 120 then 220 and vacuum and prime. Then wait 14 days and sand again. Then paint with SW PC or BM adv. then wait 14 days sand again and paint. use the store recommended brush and practice or you will be embarrassed.

  • 7 years ago

    Did nobody see the real thing first?

  • 7 years ago

    tatts, No, nobody saw the real thing first. If we had the real thing at our homes we would have known that it was not the same white as pictured....do you not order items online?


    Everyone else, I painted my wainscoting to match the cabinet and it all looks great! :)

  • 7 years ago

    Carolyn: No. I do not order items online like that. I order virtually nothing online. Months and months go by without ordering anything. And when I do it's certainly not something that I would want to look at, touch, try out/on, like a medicine cabinet, clothes or any significant purchase.

    I'd rather get out in the real world, where I can touch it, feel it, put it in the car and bring it home.

    My last order was for speaker wire and connectors for my surround sound system. The connectors were unavailable locally.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    For the love of heaven. No matter what you ordered, or where it's going, you open and inspect. If you will be unable to do that, you make only selections you have seen in person. Even then............you inspect at arrival to make certain what you got is what you wanted. Unfair? So is life. That's the deal.

    You order a sweater? It' s pink, but NOT the pink you wanted or how that pink looked online? You return it and check that little box...." did not meet expectation.....or color not as pictured" Jeesh>

  • 7 years ago
    When I peered in the end of the box on arrival, it appeared to be the correct color. At the time I was ready to install, it was too late to return. Thus my question, which is no longer an issue for me, luckily! it is evident that more than one person has realized the same problem. perhaps a different color 'name' would have helped in these situations? Anyway, good luck to everyone! I hope all of your projects come out beautifully!!
  • 6 years ago

    Sherwin Williams alone has 150 shades of white. It's something to consider when purchasing a painted piece.


  • 5 years ago

    I know this thread is old, but thought you might like to know that Pottery Barn DOES change their colors without changing the paint name. Their "antique white" has been at least 2 very different shades of white in the past. It is frustrating for customers who visit the store to view the pieces and then discover that they are not the same color when they order them and open them. I have two desks, purchased 8 years apart, the same exact line and both called "antique white" and they do not match at all. One is bright white. The other is pale beige. When I contacted them to figure it out, their customer service noted that the paint formula was changed, but unfortunately the paint name and the display pieces in the stores had not. What you saw in a catalog photo or in the store could very likely have been a previous paint formula. My desk is STILL sold on their website, with photos from the old bright-white paint formula, but what they sell does not match it at all and you would never know until you had it delivered. Super annoying.