Because the supports are part of the brick you will have to replace mantle. I would do a whitewashed wood mantle so it just blends in....but make it as chunky as possible. Because you don't have high ceilings it will visually help make the fireplace look taller.

Normally you don't have to have a mantle, but due to your support brackets I agree with what others said (above).

If you are opposed to a mantle, your other option is to have two hollow shelves made, which would sit on top of the brick brackets - with something decorative on top.

Thanks everyone! I do have a mantle but I guess I meant to say fireplace screen. Sorry for the confusion. The screen that keeps the logs secured inside the fireplace. Is it really necessary to have it? I've seen some pictures in houzz where a screen does not exist.

Are you talking about a screen that keeps bits of wood from popping out of the fireplace or a grate that holds the logs? Screens aren't really designed to keep the logs inside. More to keep debris inside.

If you are going to be burning real wood, it would be unsafe not to have a screen. Again, if using real wood, you need the grate to help the wood burn well. I suppose you could burn wood without a grate, but I imagine the fire would put itself out more quickly.

I wonder if the photos you saw were fireplaces that are purely for decorative purposes?

Without a screen or some kind of covering, I think your eye is drawn to the dark/dirty interior of your fireplace. A screen of some sort would cover that. Also you might want to consider something more insulating like glass doors if you live in a cold climate to prevent heat loss. If you plan to use this as a wood burning fireplace, you'll want a screen to keep sparks from flying out, and also andirons to place the logs on within the fireplace. Personally I prefer the original brick to the whitewashed, but I think you can add warmth by adding a nice wood mantel in a natural wood (not whitewashed) finish.

I kind of like how the fireplace looks without a surround. Feels bigger and more open.

We removed the glass and metal surround as it black and brass and it also has doors. We will probably cover it with the same flooring material or paint it in flat black to update it. Thanks everyone!

If you plan on using the fireplace you will need a screen. It will actually make the fireplace cavity look more attractive and be much safer. We recently had a client who opted to not have a screen and a log rolled out and damaged her brand new marble hearth. No fire but an expensive repair job to say the least.

If you decide to not use the fireplace set up logs and kindling on andirons to warm up the fireplace cavity.

How about a free standing screen? There are many design choices some which still give an open look.

Love the paint you used. I have a similar situation. What color did you use?

I used two small samples of the Sherwin Williams Soft Wool, satin, 50/50 paint+water.

Follow this tutorial: http://www.theyellowcapecod.com/2012/03/white-washed-brick-fireplacetutorial.html?m=1

I would try to frame around the supports for the mantle. The original mantle looked too high but check codes to see the recommended height and you may be able to lower it by covering the supports.

Thanks Rebecca

Great job on your DIY project Rebecca! However, it would be better if you install a fireplace screen for safety.

Thanks everyone! We are in the process of refinishing the screen surround this week to get it installed for safety and heating purposes. It's going back in ;)