Software
Houzz Logo Print
blriffle

I have Honey Oak kitchen cabinets - get new or keep

10 years ago

I have all new appliances and now need to select a new counter top. My cabinets are very nice and in good shape even though 20 years old. Basically look new. Is Honey Oak outdated?

Comments (30)

  • 10 years ago

    It appears YOU like your cabinets, why would you change them?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    outdated in my opinion.

    some people have huge aversions to painting out wood, but i have seen people get very nice results getting oak doors sprayed.

    some of the texture of the oak still comes through and makes it look a little richer than typical mdf cabinet doors.

  • 10 years ago

    Here is a picture of the kitchen. I want quarts for the countertops, new sink, new flooring and adding an island. I have been looking at painting cabinets and at new cabinets. Other option is to just keep what i have since solid wood (clean, restore, add knobs, new hardware, slideout features). If i do that will they still look out dated.

  • 10 years ago

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    it would to me, but the best thing about design is that it's for YOU (as pointed out by chiflipper).

    if you're not doing it for resale and you've gotten past the point of trying to impress others, i would do what looks and feels good to you.

  • 10 years ago

    Instead of painting, what about staining them darker?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    There is an in-between solution I would look into: refacing the cabinets you have. Take off the doors and drawer fronts, and get new. The design on the doors is part of what is dated -- you are right they are totally functional. If you replace them with Shaker-style (approx 2-inch trim all around the doors and smaller on the drawers) and get some attractive new hardware -- they will look brand new, but at less than half the price. Use your local cabinet-makers where you live, and you will have "custom" work and support local business.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    With all the other updates you're making, I think you should keep them unless a) your budget allows for new ones AND b) you're personally wanting a change. I wouldn't change them just because someone says they're "outdated." Once all your other updates are done, it will freshen them up anyway!

  • 10 years ago

    The only part of your cabinets that is dated is the arched insets in the upper doors. Sometimes it's possible to turn them around, but another option would be to reface just the uppers in a square style that loosely matches the lowers (or matches your island). And/or you could have glass put into one or more of them, to mix things up. That's a budget solution that lets you make the most of what you have.

  • 10 years ago

    I am in camp *Reface*.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Artisan Kitchen Remodel · More Info
    (I don't know what happened to my original post 17 minutes ago so I'm reposting). I have the same dilemma. I've replaced the floor, appliances with SS, and removed wallpaper. Still need granite or quartz countertops and a backsplash. I think getting new floors, countertop, knobs, backsplash and removing the wallpaper will update your space nicely. I found this picture on Houzz where they left the honey oak cabinets. Besides, I read an article saying that oak is making a comeback. Designers, is that true?

  • 10 years ago

    I agree with refacing them to something darker. With the updates you are wanting to make plus a complimentary backsplash, I think it would look great!

  • 10 years ago

    Keep!

  • 10 years ago

    @vsj12 Wood cabinets in general - and in lighter tones are making a comeback. I saw mid tone wood cabinets at the Parade Homes this year - though white, gray and very dark wood still dominated. Fixer Upper used wood cabinets on their show last Thursday.

    http://www.hgtv.com/shows/fixer-upper/fixer-upper-a-family-home-resurrected-in-rural-texas-pictures

    I do not know what wood was used in the kitchen, but white oak was used in the bathroom.

    I have oak cabinets too, and I love the sturdiness - but they are not going to look brand new because of the style and color. I did recently refinish them. I think of mine as vintage:) (see my idea book) I like the wood and the good thing about wood making a comeback is that people will stop talking it down, which being a beautiful, sturdy, natural product, it never deserved.

    I am ordering new quartz counters this week and will also add a farmhouse sink and backsplash. I don't want or expect my kitchen to look new, just be my individual style.

  • 10 years ago

    jhmarie, what color quartz counters did you purchase? I'm also keeping my oak cabinets but want backsplash and quartz or granite to complement them. Yes, I saw the Fixer-upper show on Thursday. Thanks

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    @vsj12 - funny you should ask. I just got back from starting the process of ordering them. First, there are many different quartz and granite countertops that would look good with wood cabinets. The stores will give you samples to take home and look at - some charge a fee for the sample, and most will refund it when you bring it back. I chose Flaked Pearl by Riverstone sold through Menards which is also LG White Pearl. It is presently on sale, but that sale ends Saturday - but it frequently goes on sale. The difficulty with going through Menards is I had to find my own installer. If you go to a Kitchen and Bath store, the price of installation will be included. I am not doing the island - that stays butcher block. The quote on the counters is about $2000 for 31 sq. ft. The installer, who is all doing my sink installation as well, gave me an estimate of $800 to $1300. He is adjusting my kitchen base cabinet for the farmhouse sink, installing the faucet and the countertop. The Kohler Whitehaven short apron sink is a cast iron farmhouse sink that can be installed on to standard cabinetry with just a few modifications. The sink is $960 in white.

    Flaked Pearl


    Whitehaven short apron sink

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Please post a new picture when the job is done. I am looking into Quartz or qranite similar to the one in the picture I posted. The professionals at the store are telling me to put Venetian gold or Giallo Ornamental with my honey oak cabinets for a traditional look. They said the white Quartz will make it look contemporary. My whole house is traditional so I don't know if I should do white now.

  • 10 years ago

    @vjs12 - in the olden days they used to put marble tops on wood wash stands. So, many of the "marble like" quartz would probably look fine - some are a little warmer than others. I did look for one that had some bits of beige - warmed it up a little. I do not think that a whitish quartz would be contemporary as it is just neutral. I think your decor will set the tone. Do take your time and look at more than one place - probably you will get different advice every place you go. Take a door with you too t hold up to samples and if they let you take a sample home look at it in different light and at different times of the day. I also asked my more artistic friends opinions.

    Also, do a google image search of "oak cabinets" to get ideas. You can search Houzz too, though they do not have as many oak cabinets - but you can also search "wood cabinets" to get ideas.

    I will post pic when I am done - It may be 6 weeks or so. There is an error on my first template and I need to get that perfect before I OK the countertop, so I am not rushing.


    Ziemlich Honey Oak Kitchen Cabinets · More Info

    google images:



  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Please don't paint the beautiful honey oak cabinets.

    Please don't get one of those black splotch countertops -- they're ugly and difficult to match w/o going to the dark side.

    Do consider painting the island base to add your favorite color to the room.

    Update? What did you decide?

  • 10 years ago
    You have the same problem I have and it was mentioned here as well. The arch on the upper cabinets. Even if you paint them out the arch is still there and "tattles" that you painted the cabinets. If you look at any painted cabinets none seem to have the arch.

    Also I struggle with the question posed by a couple of people. Why do I want to change them? If they were purple and no normal person would ever line them then it would make sense. But just because they're not the current style. That's where I am having a problem.
  • 10 years ago

    I ended up getting all new cabinets - cherry. I had been in the house for 26 years and wanted a change. Now working on selecting a backsplash

  • 9 years ago
    what color of wall paint would look nice with honey oak cabinets
  • 9 years ago

    Cream, creamy beige, blues and green go well with oak. I have creamy beige in my kitchen and other main floor rooms - just enough beige to set off the white trim. Some other rooms are light blue and I just finished painting the basement Valspar Schoolboy blue. I like blues a lot, but for me they tend not to look right in the main floor rooms, so I've stuck to blue in bedrooms and bathrooms. Also, blue in the basement, but we needed some color in that area.

    Grays tend not to work unless it is a blue or green with a gray undertone.

    My kitchen:

    http://www.houzz.com/ideabooks/57579129/thumbs/my-pics-work-in-progress


  • 9 years ago

    Who in their right mind would replace hardwood cabinetry with cheap fiberboard? That's like replacing hardwood flooring with linoleum or granite counters with laminated ones. The cherry looks great, though. The in thing is to get a subway tile backsplash.

  • 9 years ago

    I have what everyone calls "outdated" golden oak cabinets and trim in our 5th wheel. We bought it just 1 year ago and fell in love with it, floor plan, golden oak and all! We never stopped to think how outdated it looked until some members of the family pointed it out. The cabinets are top notch, grain matched and very well made. I know it shouldn't matter what others think, but it does kind of hurt my feelings. I was wondering, short of extensive sanding, is there any way one can make them look like white birch with some kind of lighter stain? We really don't want to darken them, even though we know we could. We feel it would make our RV feel closed in and smaller.

    Are we crazy not to stain them darker?

  • 9 years ago
    @Carole, you may want to start your own thread regarding the cabinets in your camper. This thread is old and has been resolved by the original poster. I too am interested in the responses you get as we are considering purchasing a camper and the 1st thing I will do is have everything painted, including the cabinets and walls.
  • 9 years ago

    I left mine as they are - I am not influenced much by what others think and in the Midwest I find much less concern about being on trend. I went with a somewhat vintage look which makes the stain color less important. Pics in my "my pics" idea book.

    No matter what you do, in 10 years, it will be "outdated" again. Go with the look you enjoy.

  • 8 years ago

    I love teal paint with the honey oak cabinets looks darker in the picture but it is a beautiful color to go Honey. I use Benjamin Moore Lucerne Paint color

  • 4 years ago

    @Carole Elliott, I know yiur comment is 4 years old and you probably won’t see this, but just in case, I love your cabinets! very beautiful, and I especially like the glass fronts.