Software
Houzz Logo Print
bznbaker

Hot Water Recirc pump new construction

10 years ago

Our current house has a Loooong wait for Hot Water.

So I'm proposing a recirc pump for the new build.

How far away from the heater would justify a dedicated HW return line for this? I don't want to feed it back via the cold. That makes the cold warm.

Say the shower is 20' from the tank, would that be far enough to justify a return for that?

Comments (17)

  • 10 years ago

    "Say the shower is 20' from the tank, would that be far enough to justify a return for that?"

    I wouldn't consider 20' to be far enough to justify potential problems created by conventional recirculation. If expense is not a consideration,I might consider a more powerful than normal re-cir pump that can be manualy activated moments before useing shower. Push button switch w/ tattle tail lamp turn's pump on for two minutes then turn's off. If you decide to go with a conventional recirculation,talk with your GC about installing thicker wall/wear resistant tube on hot and return lines. About 20 years is the point were hot water lines begain wearing through in multifamily residential buildings.

  • 10 years ago

    We are thinking 10 years in this house before we retire to southern climes. Far bathroom is probably 75' from HW heater. However we have low tolerance for waiting for water. Is it possible to have multiple bathrooms on recirc pump systems. Running an extra pipe back to the HW heater is a low cost during new construction.

  • 10 years ago

    Yup have em make a HW loop for all the rooms. Insulate that loop well.

    bznbaker thanked Vith
  • 10 years ago

    I don't really understand Klem1's comment about potential problems with a HW recirculation system. The main water lines in my house are 35-55 years old (copper L tubing) and have never had a leak (at least not in the 25 years that I've lived here). What type of additional stress would a recirculation pump put on the lines?

    I live in an L-shaped ranch and the bathroom by the bedrooms is about 65-75 ft. from the water heater (the last 30 or so are through an unheated crawl space). The former owners dealt with the hot water issue by putting a small electric water heater under the sinks. This hasn't worked very well at all. For starters, the heaters rust through occasionally and have had to be replaced twice in the last 25 years. Aside from this, every so often they overheat and send out scalding water. I'm not sure what causes this (as it's happened with each of the 3 heaters I've had), but I assume it has something to do with sending hot instead of cold water into the heater. It might also be due to the fact that there's a lot of iron in my water and the problem wasn't completely corrected until recently.

    My solution has been to shut off the HW heater and twice a day run the hot water long enough to heat up the water there (I run it in the bathtub first to make sure that only hot water is going into the heater). The insulation in the HW heater generally keeps the water hot enough for the intermittent use there during the day. My plumber has suggested a recirculation system, but I haven't pursued it as I'm sure it will be very expensive. A manual recirc system doesn't make much sense to me, as I could just as easily turn on the bathtub faucet until the water gets hot.

    Is there anything else that I should consider?

    bznbaker thanked greasetrap
  • 10 years ago

    I think these recirc systems are needless complexity, and junk. I would doubt .01% of the homes have these.

    Have two water heaters, one at each end of the home, each serves one half of the home.


  • 10 years ago

    Geoffrey, two water heaters is certainly an option in a new build, but seems even more complex to me in an existing home. First, space has to be found to put the water heater. I assume electric and oil-fired probably aren't good options for a remote heater, which probably leaves you with a gas instant hot water model. Wouldn't this require you to run a gas line and have ventilation and exhaust for the heater? The idea of having 2 water heaters is attractive to me in the event that one fails, but it would also entail 2 sets of maintenance costs.

    Some people here don't seem to like recirculating systems, but I'd like to understand why. Do they have a tendency to break down often? Two different plumbers have recommended it to me for my house (long run through an unheated crawl space), so it would be helpful to learn more to understand the downside of such a setup.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Downside is inefficiency. If not insulated well, it is basically an active radiant heat loop at all times. Can also cause increased utility bill.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree with Vith. Recirculating that hot water is going to make your water heater work more.

    I have a large / long home - it takes just a little planning. Taking a shower - turn on the water, get your towel, shampoo, bath mat, etc - by the time you do that you'll have hot water.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks. I agree with both of your points. If I were to put in a recirc system without insulating the pipes, I would essentially be heating my crawl space. I've also been letting the water run until it turns hot for the last 25 years, and it's not that great an inconvenience, given the likely cost of an alternative system. At this point I'm just thinking ahead to what I might do if we were to renovate the bedroom area in the future (which would involve adding another bathroom & laundry area). That would be the logical time to think about doing something different.

  • 10 years ago

    Of course running the water until it gets hot wastes treated water and if on a septic system is an extra load on the system. But what the heck, water is very cheap! Recirc pumps usually have a timer that allows settings for a couple times per day. Because we're retired we don't have a set schedule, I use X-10 devices that allow me to run the pump as needed (washing machine, dishwasher, showers). The down side is that one has to identify how long it takes to get to the major points of use so the pump can be turned on before hot water is needed. X-10 is relatively cheap but does have a few reliability issues. There are other remote control options available (Z-wave, Insteon, etc)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Water is very precious resource in drought-stricken CA.. so we don't want to literally flush clean water down the drain. We are planning on installing a HW recirculation system that is activated on demand. the system we're thinking is to have one continuous HW loop on the farthest and most affected bathrooms and have a pump that is activated by a switch with a timer that will run for about 25-30min and then stop. so when you are ready to take a shower, when you first walk into the bathroom you turn on the pump (set to run on a timer) and while you're getting ready to get into the shower, enough of the hot water will be circulated in the line that when you turn on the faucet/shower, there will be very little cold water to be purged before hot water starts to come out. so the circulation pump is not on all the time, and only on demand... this basically eliminates wasting 5-10gal of water while waiting for the hot water to start coming out and instead of the water going down the drain and into the sewer, it goes right back into the HW heater to be reheated... which essentially is the same as replenishing it with with the source cold water.. same thing would have happened if you don't have recirc system... so not much energy wasted there.

    our system energy wasting would be the electricity to run the pump for 30min or so when we are heating up the line (and the cost to install the long return line that mates with the supply line, appropriate backflow check valve on the supply line and the pump/switch system itself). so it shouldn't be too bad. We dont' intend to run the pump all day, so..

    we probably ought to think about grey water system, but couldn't really get our act together to plan for that this time..


  • 10 years ago

    I have a well and septic, and the system my plumber recommended is user programmable to run at certain intervals at different times of the day. For example, you could program it to run every 15 minutes from 6AM - 9AM, every hour after that, every 15 minutes from 10-12 PM, and then not run again until 6AM the next morning. Basically he said once it starts running, the system monitors the temperature of the returning water and stops once the returning water reaches a certain temperature.

    It's hard for me to judge whether this system would be more or less efficient than letting the taps run until the water turns hot. Water itself is free for me and it goes right back into the ground, so running the tap doesn't waste any water. Electricity is kind of expensive, and the well pump uses a lot more electricity than a small recirculator pump would. Oil to heat the water is cheap at the moment, but could become more expensive again. Except for the dead of winter, the water coming back into the hot water tank from the recirc system would be at a higher temperature than water coming from the ground (thereby requiring less energy to reheat). Although I haven't actually got a quote, I don't think it makes sense to retrofit such a system to my current house. If I were to do a major renovation though, then I might consider it.

  • 10 years ago

    To Imar02:

    You may want to ground truth your times once you are in the house. Out hot water line runs from the garage heater to the other end of the house-- about 60 feet. The return line runs to the heater.. Both are insulated. It takes one minute for hot water to reach the master bath (only a few feat from the heater) and washing machine. In 6 minutes it reaches the kitchen and it reaches the back bath in 8 minutes. I timed all these so I would know how long to run the pump. So if I need to run the dishwasher I run the pump for 6 minutes using the X-10 devices and keep it on for 60 minutes. If it is a matter of just taking a shower or washing dishes in the sink, I can turn off the pump and the point of use will still have hot water available. Your times will vary depending on the hot water line configuration and the size of the pump but I doubt it will need 30 minutes to reach the farthest bathroom.

  • 10 years ago

    Our current house it takes minutes to get hot water to the kitchen faucet. We're wasting gallons and gallons of water waiting. And there is the convenience factor. I hate WATING. Sure, I could walk into the kitchen, turn on the faucet, go do something else, then go back and start cooking/cleaning pots. But who wants to?

    It seems the key is insulating the pipes so heat is not wasted in the crawl space. We will do that in the new house as well as recirc pump. A smartly programmed timer as well.

    The new house has a loooong run to the far bathroom. No place (utility room/basement) for another heater. Another heater just for that bathroom seems excessive anyway. Especially when I will mostly be washing hands. And I don't want to wait 8 minutes to wash my hands.

    So I think I will measure each run and see where a recirc line makes sense. However in my master bath and kitchen, I'm not waiting for hot water any more.






  • 10 years ago

    To reiterate what I suggested in my first response,there are circulator pumps and then there are recirculator pumps. Aside from quility,there's different volume and pressure capibilities. My system was origionally installed with recirculation,I later added a timer then even later I changed pump and wired it for manually control. I use a pump capiable of pushing hot water almost one foot per secound. The pump only operate's when the button switch near each point of use is touched. My switches are timed to stay on for 90 secounds each time the button is touched. Such pump should not be run continously because it will wear pipes through. One poster failed to understand that any recirulating system wears water pipes out. Kitchen sink has a two gallon point of use heater for instant hot water in addition to recirculation. You might consider 120 volt pou heaters that are simple to install in kitchen and master bath..

  • 10 years ago

    For insulating the pipes, look into the good rubber insulation they use for AC lines. More expensive, but much better. http://www.homedepot.com/p/Armaflex-1-2-in-x-6-ft-Rubber-Self-Seal-Pipe-Wrap-Insulation-HST05812/100550644