Software
Houzz Logo Print
2nubble2

Marble vs granite?

10 years ago
Your work is absolutely stunning--I love how you work so well with the space provided making each renovation unique. I do love the look of the calcutta gold marble, but we have young kids and I fear they will ruin it. Do you believe granite is less porous and easier to maintain? I've been searching for a granite with similar appearance qualities to the calc gold marble. Thoughts? Thank you.
Breaking Beautiful White Kitchen · More Info

Comments (5)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Hi and thank you so much for your compliment! It really means a lot! :)

    This kitchen does have Calacatta Gold marble and I will not lie to you; real marble and kitchens are a dicey call. You do get the beauty of the natural veining, however, as you already are aware, it is an extremely porous material and it stains and etches very easily. When you add children into the mix (who God love them don't mean to spill that Capri Sun all over the counter) and it's a disaster in the making because no matter how much you try and are diligent, its gonna happen at some point in time and it's typically sooner than any of us would like. When I'm designing kitchens for young families, I do try and recommend countertop materials that will perform optimally for the use and traffic its receiving. There are not a lot of granites that will get the 'look' of marble and hence why they have fallen out of favor somewhat with the big shift we have seen over the last few years to lighter and brighter kitchens versus the dark, earthy palettes that were coveted some time ago which embraced the rich and unpredictable splashes of pattern and color that granite is known for. I often try and steer people to a Quartzite (another naturally occurring stone) or a man-made quartz product, both of which allow for a lighter surface without the vigorous upkeep and anxiety marble has associated with it.

    When thinking about what to use also consider the way the stones are formed. Granite is an igneous rock, which means it was formed from the hardening of lava in its molten state. Marble and quartzite are metamorphic rocks that have been formed by extreme temperatures (heat) or other pressure in nature; the difference between the two being that marble is derived from limestone whereas quartzite originates from sandstone and is one of the hardest materials and is impervious to water and/or acid, making it a nice alternative to marble while getting a similar look. The closest in color to a Carrera or Calacatta Gold is White Macaubus Quartzite.

    Quartz on the other hand is a man-made product and is basically created by mixing quartz (a naturally occurring mineral) with polymers, resins and dyes to create an engineered stone countertop. It is also extremely durable, glossy like marble and resists staining and is essentially non-porous, making it a very reliable workhorse in the kitchen.

    I am attaching some links of product I feel is the closest to 'real' as it gets and will alleviate your stress level in the kitchen so you can worry about cooking and not stress over who is where and doing what!

    Cambria's choices

    http://www.cambriausa.com/en/Designs/design-palette/Brittanicca

    http://www.cambriausa.com/en/Designs/design-palette/Ella/

    http://www.cambriausa.com/en/Designs/design-palette/Torquay/

    Caesarstone's choices:

    http://www.caesarstoneus.com/en/The-Catalog/Pages/5111%20Statuario%20Nuvo.aspx

    http://www.caesarstoneus.com/en/The-Catalog/Pages/5131%20Calacatta%20Nuvo.aspx

    http://www.caesarstoneus.com/en/The-Catalog/Pages/5141%20Frosty%20Carrina.aspx

    LG Stone:

    http://www.lgviaterausa.com/products/135/188

    http://www.lgviaterausa.com/products/135/187

    I hope this helps in your countertop quest!


    Best,


    Libby

    2nubble2 thanked House of L
  • 10 years ago

    Thank you Libby for such detailed, helpful information.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm just seeing this now--unsure how I missed it in my email! Thank you very much, Libby, for the very interesting detailed information and additional resources. This will prove extremely helpful!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Of course! Glad to be of help to you!

  • 9 years ago

    What an amazing response from an experienced designer! Thank you!