Software
Houzz Logo Print
davelayoj

Repot without root pruning this time of year?

10 years ago

First, I know it's not the recommended time of year, but in the last few weeks I've repoted 3 small ficus and a Schefflera from standard peat based mix into a 5:1:1 mix.

I bare rooted and removed all of the oil soil. However, I was gentle and didn't break or trim any roots.

Every plant that I moved from the hard compacted peat mix into the 5:1:1 is obviously doing better. None of them so much as dropped a single leaf and they have heathy new growth.

My question is two things: is there a NEED for root pruning? If the roots don't seem too out of control, why not just bare root as I did?

second, I just don't know if my large ficus wants to wait till June for a repot. I've tried everything Al has recommended and while it's not losing leaves, the new growth seems deformed and unusual looking. No pests.

The soil is a matted down l, soiled piece of peat that is really tough to water. When I do water, it stays damp for about 2-3 weeks. I have wicks installed to help drain, I hold the pot 45° when draining, etc.

will the large tree with a much larger root system respond as well as the young trees I repotted?

ive tried everything that's been recommended and nothing seems to work.

Thanks!

Comments (4)

  • 10 years ago

    Also, I meant for this to be in container gardening.

  • 10 years ago

    As Al probably remembers I hate root trimming so I'm going to chime in. Most of the need for root trimming is if the plant has circling roots or if you want to keep the plant in the same size pot it came in. I don't tend to do this, I also repot as soon as I bring a plant home. I don't root trim very often unless they are sickly. I am however very brutal when I pot up / repot a plant. I will shake all the soil out of the roots or even bang the roots on the ground a few times to loosen the soil, even use my foot to break into a large root bound mess, etc I'll then loosen any circling roots with my fingers and tease them out..I find this to be sufficient for most plants.

    I will admit that I am not a conventional houseplant gardener with my share of losses, I however have been growing them for a long time and have had more than my fair share of them, usually trying each plant at least 7 or 8 times before I'll say I can't grow it or I don't like it.

    I would ask Al about the ficus however. He knows what he is doing and while most people want results now, it's not always what is best for the plant.

  • 10 years ago

    I've worked in one garden center and two nurseries. The only thing we we ever root pruned was spider plants and bad roots of orchids.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The ficus benjamina I'm speaking of is currently in a 14" deep x 16" diameter pot. It'll be going into a 16" deep x 18" diameter pot.

    I wanted to use the same method that I used for my smaller ficus benjamina and my Schefflera. I removed the plant from the pot, massaged all of the old soil out, being careful not to break any roots. I then rinsed the roots fully clean and repotted with the 5:1:1. I thoroughly watered (it's crazy going from peat based to 5:1:1 as the new mix holds WAY less water), and I fertalized about two weeks later.

    Everything I repotted is doing much better than it was in the MG peat mix. That's why I'm wondering if it may be wise to do the same with my large tree. The soil is just not doing the tree any favors right now. That's the only thing holding it back. It gets a lot of light from the southern window and the five 250w 5500k grow lights overhead and it enjoys high humidity in its room.

    i do want fast results, but I'm aware what might seem like the best plan in my mind, is not the same for the tree. That said, I DO want to do what's in the trees best interest. That's why I used my small ficus as test subjects and why the larger tree has not been touched.

    Thanks for the replies!