Software
Houzz Logo Print
primdawg

Matching kitchen and bath countertops?

I keep seeing on the design and home shows where people are touring homes and comment and love that the bathroom and kitchen countertops are the same material.

I don't get that being a bonus. Personally I don't want to think my kitchen looks like a bathroom.

We are getting ready to start a new build and I will be picking out finishes and had no intention of them matching. Especially since I hate shiny granite I will being putting something else in my kitchen. I may do honed granite but right now I'm still looking and researching.

Am I making a mistake not doing matching? This house will be our last home(probably) so by the time it's up for resale I'm thinking it will need to be updated anyway.

Comments (14)

  • 10 years ago

    When we were building, I thought of them as separate. In the bathrooms I went with cabinets that went best with the furniture in each bedroom, but all counters are honed limestone. Faucets are the same, but their finish also depended on the room. For the kitchen, we have antique pine island but honed granite on either side of the range and the pine hutch. The same honed granite was used in the laundry room. I wanted the house to flow from room to room. Be more alike than different, so no stark contrast in finish choices. The house can stand on its own, while the furnishings enhance.

  • 10 years ago

    I always thought of that as a builder's basic budget choice, unless it happens to be a totally gorgeous material that you can't get enough of.

    You want the rooms to feel like they are in the same house (although I'm not sure that's always the case!), but matchy matchy? Ew!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I think of the kitchen and bathrooms as separate, so different but complementary finishes in my home. In my next house I might use the same countertop in the kitchen and a bathroom, but don't think it's necessary.

  • 10 years ago

    I think it's a by product of buying your counter tops by the slab instead of the square foot. You have lots of slab left, it really hurts to trash it and buy another slab for a bathroom counter top.

    The kitchen uses the most counter. Usually fabricators will have lots of left over slabs that will produce enough for a bath room counter. Unless, you are looking for marble. That's hard to find in scraps.

    In one of my past homes, I used the same counter in the kitchen as the master bath. But for the other baths, I used scraps. I thought it looked pretty good.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    It hadn't even occurred to me that anyone would want to do that, although I see nothing wrong with using up the scraps to fashion a bathroom countertop. Why waste an expensive, beautiful and durable material? But to do it deliberately does not seem like a very creative idea when you have hundreds of different options to choose from.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I have heard it spun as providing continuity, flow, etc. and I have heard it spun as cheap builder grade. You pick.

  • 10 years ago

    Of course, if you can see inside the bathroom from the kitchen, they should probably be the same.

    You do see it both ways, and when it's a really nice material, it's a good thing. And when it's a serviceable but not-that-interesting choice, it looks uninspired. I don't think there's a right answer; it just depends on how each room looks. I think people on home and design shows say things just to have something to say. Like me!

  • 10 years ago

    When we built our home, I wanted things to complement and as others have said, the rooms to flow. However, I did not want the same countertop in bathrooms as the kitchen.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    We just built a home and used the same material in both the kitchen and the bathrooms. Part of that was using up the slabs but part of it was just going with what I liked the best (plain white Quartz.). Even though the counters are the same throughout, each bathroom is still quite different as they have distinctly different color schemes, tile, etc.. And they are far from "builder basic."

  • 10 years ago

    I agree that it's most likely a factor of using up a slab that you're buying. I had the same granite in the kitchen and master bath in the previous house.

    While both are marble, my kitchen and master bath counters are different.


  • 10 years ago

    I think it depends on the application. I have toured homes where not only is the same granite used in the kitchen and the bathrooms, but it is used as a bench in the mudroom and in the laundry room as well. Depending on the style of granite, that can feel like overload.

    If it is more simple (like the plain, white quartz namarie mentions), I think it translates better than one with a pattern.

    Since you are building this house and hope to have it your forever home, I think you should go with what your gut wants. Maybe consider each room separately, but keep the same granite as one of the possibilities.


  • 10 years ago

    Certainly doesn't have to match, but if you like it and if you have the remnant from the slab of granite from the kitchen counters, you can certainly use it. GF has a PR that is across the hall from the kitchen and has decided to use the same granite and cabinetry in there too. A fine choice. But had she chosen something different, that'd be ok too. In my house, no matching. But I did use the rest of the marble slab from the fireplace surround in other areas of the house.