Software
Houzz Logo Print
kwb1999

Would you keep these upper cabinets?

10 years ago

We are in the midst of a kitchen remodel and trying to save a buck without losing "charm." Our architect has drawn our kitchen with some very high, glass fronted upper cabinets. While I love this look in photos, these cabinets rarely will be used. We are debating putting in a soffit above the first set of upper cabinets instead. Our ceilings are 10', and the first set of upper cabinets would be around 42-48", making the soffit 18-24" tall.

Do you think nixing the upper cabinets is a good budget compromise, or do you think having a large soffit will look weird?

Oh, and the hood will be a canopy-style, which can be extended to disappear into the soffit--not the hood shown here. :)

Thanks for any thoughts.


Comments (9)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I don't like the look of soffits and think a lot of people here agree (from what I've read). You say "high end" cabinets- did you decide on high end? A lot of money can be saved by not going with high end wood and fancy panel designs.

    We found that we did not spend a lot more money on glass than we would have with wood fronts. Then again, our designer is a very honest, wonderful man who didn't gouge us on anything.

    I love the look of some glass, and would encourage you to think about putting some lighting in the top glass fronts.

  • 10 years ago

    I would LOVE having the upper cabinets vs. soffits b/c is where I would store the rarely used but treasured plates, tureens, etc. In my kitchen it would enable me to remove cabinets flanking the window above sink and allow me to install a much larger window, which is my dream. IMO, higher cabinets to the ceiling makes the kitchen less "cabinetryish", if that makes sense. Oh..but we are talking about your kitchen, If you don't need the extra storage, I would evaluate in paper the cost of soffit vs. cabinets and from from there. Your plans look very nice.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you, bossyvossy and mimipaddv. I really appreciate your insight. As I look at pictures, I find myself appreciating the glass fronts more and more.

    I don't think our cabinets will qualify as "high end." :) In fact, we had been considering IKEA and custom fronts, but I am not sure those will work given our timeline and the size options for IKEA.

    Right now, I am leaning toward Omega Dynasty cabinets. Our KD thinks she can get us something very nice for less than 20K. She also mentioned that we could use Merit cabinets if we needed to bring the costs down; she said she prefers Dynasty and thinks it's built better but that Merit is also very nice. I have quotes from Kraftmaid (which came in higher than I expect from Dynasty; is that normal?), and Siteline (21.5K) and Greenfield (25K). Reviews on Dynasty seem to be good, so I can't see a reason to spend more.

    Best of luck with your bigger window, bossyvossy!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I would keep the upper cabinets. You can never have too much storage. They look better than a soffit especially with 10 foot ceilings. I've heard nothing but good things regarding Omega cabinets on this forum.

  • 10 years ago

    If you can swing it budget-wise, keep them :)

  • 10 years ago

    Nix in the soffit because it brings your ceiling down and make your kitchen look smaller. I jumped through hoops to get rid of my 12" soffit.

  • 10 years ago

    We saved money going with Shaker cabinets, and we really love the look. Going with raised panels was a lot more money, but we don't feel like we compromised.

    More money in the budget for other things ;-)

    I love your design.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree keep them. The 'uppers on uppers' is a really neat old style.

    One thing that might be possible is that the two doors are attached together on one set of hinges, mounted on one cabinet box, giving the illusion of double cabinets up there but it's built like one cab.

  • 10 years ago

    "rarely be used" ...the wall looks very full with cabinets for your stated observation. I would clear by a few inches the cabinets from the sides of hood and edge of window trim. Perhaps reduce to one single door cabinet on each side-18-21 in wide....leave some breathing room. They can build a ledge atop the cabinets...or voided door cubby hole cabinets with matching interior to take up the space on top. Display pottery/bowls etc. Do plan to remove the soffit, but you can pare it back, still have a good looking wall, maybe even nicer looking with less full or saturated configuration. Focus on some beautiful tile-it's just as important and will create the feel, as much, if not more than the cabinetry.