Software
Houzz Logo Print
wimngirl

Need help choosing windows

10 years ago

I am looking at replacing the windows in my house. I currently have crank out windows in my house that was built in 1992. When I moved in 2001, the windows which are wood on the inside were already starting to have mold, softness and loosing the finish. When I added on about 7 years ago, We put in Anderson crank out windows. They are wood on the inside. We have not had any issues with them. My husband would like to replace the older windows with double hung windows. He is able to do the work himself, so it is just a matter of finding the right window for our area. We have so far looked at big box stores and reviewed Anderson, Crestline, and Jeld Wen. We haven't looked at Marvin or Pella. We would like wood on the inside to stain so that we can match the woodwork. I have been reading all the reviews above. I feel more confused than I was when I started. We live in Eastern Wisconsin. I would like an opinion on:

1. Best window for the do it yourself-er (in other words, we can purchase the window without being a contractor).

2. Windows that are wood on the inside, double hung, prefer to be able to tilt in to clean.

3. Double or triple panes? What kind of gas between the panes? We have hot, humid summers and bitter cold winters. We have snow, ice, sleet, rain, heavy rain, and significant winds. We really have everything except hurricanes.

4. Which type of windows within the brand would you recommend?

Thanks for any comments.

Comments (3)

  • 10 years ago
    I installed Pella Architect Series Double Hung Divided light Windows. I'm pretty sure that you can buy them without being a contractor.

    I purchased mime through DirectBuy.

    the reason that I went with pella architect series is due to the custom sized windows that my house required. Also, I wanted stain grade wood.

    they are dual glazed and filled with argon gas. I have had mine in for 8 years now and have not had any issues.

    I found that Pella provide excellent support and as a novice, I appreciated their help.

    I assume that you will need new windows and do not plan to use replacement windows.

    I did not look at the other major brands that you mentioned very long as soon as I discovered that they did not make custom sizes. I also found that I liked the look of their divided panes better than the other brands.

    I live in southern CA near the Pacific Ocean and the weather is very temperate. Thus, I cant say how they are about holding up in a cold climate like yours in Wisconsin.



    I
  • 10 years ago

    All the brands you mentioned (Andersen, etc) at big box stores are a line made for those stores. They will not be the same quality you would purchase from a lumber yard. We had the exact Pella windows Kelly has installed in 2000 on East Coast in MA. I chose them because I wanted true divided lights to keep the authenticity of the Cape Cos style home. They are aluminum clad with wood interiors. They have been great. But now I work at a lumber yard that sells Andersen. I remodeled my kitchen 2 years ago and replaced the Pella with an Andersen, have Andersen storm doors and just replaced a slider with Andersen. Bought all Andersen's through the lumber yard and am quite happy with them.

  • 10 years ago
    We chose Amsco Windows on the advice of our general contractor for our new home a year ago. After one winter I can say they were decent in terms of thermal protection and are easy to clean as you mentioned was important to you. One notable exception to our satisfaction is the 4 panel sliding glass door that opens to our deck. For the money, this sliding door is underwhelming. The action is not smooth and the screens are the worst I have ever seen (including some apartments I have lived in). The manufacturer has not been responsive in handling our concerns. If I had it to do over again I might have gone with Amsco for the windows but purchased the sliding glass door from someone else.