Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_931347

My roses are inconsistent. Help!!!

10 years ago

I've had issues with my roses for about 3 years now. One rose does really well and the others look pretty shameful. What am I doing wrong? Some plants have smallish leaves. I remembered them being large like the rose that is doing well. Lack of water? The one in the middle that is doing well has a sprinkler head that is right by the base. Thanks in advance.

This picture was taken in February 2016. Since then the roses look a little better

Same plant taken April 4 2016. The pictures that follow were all taken on the same day


Comments (19)

  • 10 years ago

    I'm not an authority JF, I hope someone that knows more than me will comment. What I do know, i have heard over and over that roses don't like to get their feet wet. That is such a difficult balance to achieve when some are literally a water hog.

    My biggest challenge is getting the organic dirt, compost , fertilizer right to their liking. It has been my experience the roses hated the bagged regular Miracle Grow but loved the Organic Miracle Grow. I tried to make it fluffy and not too compact. Last year I bought dirt from ACE hardware, the quality didn't seem as good as years before, but I'm trying to keep it fairly simple and make gradual adjustments using as natural supplies as possible. Tuesday I am going shopping for the roses groceries; someone on the forum recommends the product Rose Tone. Haven't tried it yet.

    It is frustrating the roses cant talk and just tell you what to do, stay hopefull.






  • 10 years ago

    Looking again at the photo, are they in all day sun? They might feel the same way we do with heat exhaustion.

  • 10 years ago

    More water and a nice compost mulch may help.

  • 10 years ago

    If you have a dry sandy soil then you should also add a soil wetting agent.

  • 10 years ago

    What zone are you in and what kind of roses are they?

  • 10 years ago

    You answered your own question. The larger rose is getting more water. How much water are the others getting? Start there.

  • 10 years ago

    Could you please post a close up photo of the first rose. Something looks just a little unusual on that one. But I can't enlarge the photo enough to see it.

  • 10 years ago

    It could also be that they are trying to regrow on winter damaged canes. So your location is important.

  • 10 years ago

    Here is a closer photo of the first rose.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for all the great feedback. This is my first post and I'm really impressed. I am in Los Angeles and I'm not sure what kind of roses they are. The landscaper put them in over 12 years ago. I wanted to confirm with the experts before changing watering schedules. I will change the nozzles to higher precipitation rates to see if that helps. We are in a serious drought so I'm trying to be as judicious as possible. I think the issue started when I switched heads several years ago.


    I have also have black spot/rust and I thought about changing to a soaker or drip hose. Do you think I should cut the canes that have rust on them now? My issue is the landscaper put the roses and grass on the same zone and it'll be tough to get the right balance.

  • 10 years ago

    How much water should roses get?

  • 10 years ago

    I can't advise on water issue in your zone. But just in case has any weed killer been used on the nearby grass.

  • 10 years ago

    Every rose grows differently just like every kid does. And location is very important. Yes, even in the same bed! Start giving the others more water and see if that helps.

  • 10 years ago

    I am wondering if that first rose is understock growth, looking at its sprawling habit... as Patty said, it looks odd. Cut out any dead canes as well. Fertilize, Rose Tone is good. Water.

  • 10 years ago

    No weed killer has been used on the nearby grass. I cut out the dead canes and trimmed the black spot areas out and I've fertilized as well. I'm crossing my fingers for a successful summer. I know I have to be patient.


    The understock growth theory is plausible after reviewing a youtube video on the subject. All the new shoots have way smaller leaves than they used to have. The main stock is still there so I'll see if watering more vigorously will help. Thanks again!


  • 10 years ago

    Wow, after looking more closely at the base of the roses and recognizing the smaller leaves it looks like the grafted plant might of been overtaken by the understock. Here are photos of the bases. The flowers haven't bloomed yet but they appear red. Dr Huey rose stock? I'm learning so much through this forum

    Rose 1. This is the plant Patty suspected was sprawling. The green canes are coming from below the mulch. The thick canes above the ground are brown and look dead and don't have shoots coming off of them.


    Rose 2. This once has shoots coming from the canes above the base but the leaves are small. I think this one might still have the grafted shoots alive


    Rose 3. This one also has shoots coming from the canes above the base but the leaves are small.

  • 10 years ago

    Would you happen to know if these are own roots or grafted. Must say you are a very patient rose grower to last three season with a rose problem. As far as water goes the only way to tell if they are getting enough is to check each roses soil.

    It is also possible that the thiner canes are trying to grow from a crown that is dying. So it gets just enough energy to grow but not enough to grow properly. They may need to be replaced. One odd thing that can cause this is root gall thou it's probably not the case.