Software
Houzz Logo Print
dyhgarden

Choosing a landscape installation service

10 years ago

I've gotten quotes from two businesses.

One business is what I'd call "true professional" and their quote, including 3 illicium and 1 loreoptelum tree form, is $5897. They provided a very detailed quote with measurements, etc.

The other business is a non-profit for rehab and they mow my yard only. They quoted $2200, no trees and their quote isn't as detailed -- pretty general per project.


1) Constructing an "island" garden bed in the front yard (remove grass, bring garden soil and amendments, mulch) so that I can then design and plant it myself. Clean up (remove nandina) and mulch another bed.

$1130 from the business

$1100 from non-profit

2) Prepare an area for 800 sf of sod grass in the backyard to repair from construction damage for my renovation/addition.

$3500 from business, including a 5' swatch of "garden bed" around the centipede sod ($1700 itemized).

$875 from non-profit, no garden bed. (I worry about preparation beneath sod as it isn't as detailed as business quote)

3) Clean-up existing half acre (I had a herd of goats eat down the ivy so that the vines are now exposed for cutting off the trees and pulling from the ground). Everyone quoted before seeing the clean-up by the goat herd ($600 for 20 goats for 24 hours).

$700 from business

$20 per hour per man


I'd love to support the non-profit, but I worry that this could turn into a "penny-wise, pound foolish" situation.

Your advice?

Thanks

Comments (9)

  • 10 years ago

    The pro firm has references. The non-profit has different people at different times, so there are very mixed reviews, depending on when/what was being done.

  • 10 years ago

    If the installation is 'non-technical' - no hardscaping involved, no sprinkler/irrigation system or lighting installed, no change in grading or any drainage issues and there was supervision of the rest of the activity - clean out, soil prep, planting etc.- then I might be inclined to go with the non-profit. Otherwise, I'd go with the pros.

    DYH thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 10 years ago

    Gardengal -- there is no hardscaping or other technical work. My new house was built in 1939 and I added a first floor master suite, kitchen and entry vestibule. When the footings were dug for the addition, the grading was done afterwards.

    I'm an experienced gardener, so I'll supervise and instruct. I've built French drains and dry streams at my previous home, and there's nothing like that to be done here.

    Thanks for your input.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Sounds like mostly labor. Just because people who mow lawns doesn't necessarily mean they are skilled at other things. But on the other hand, a professional who runs a business is in it to make money vs. a "non-profit". Since you have experience and seem quite detailed, I suggest you act as your own contractor and supervise them. Buy all the materials yourself and just pay them by the hour, but also have a not to exceed so they are not tempted to try to stretch the number of hours. The other redeeming point is that you already sort of know them vs. someone new. If you want a more detailed quote in writing just tell them what to specify.

    Hiring unlicensed people for contracting gives you no recourse if something goes awry. On the other hand, people who knowingly hire unlicensed people that should be licensed for the type of work often end up in the penny wise pound foolish category.

    DYH thanked JSL Landscape Design
  • 10 years ago

    The non-profit is licensed, but their labor are going through rehab. The non-profit is heavily supported by the city and many residents use their lawn mowing services, landscaping services (separate from the mowing), and moving services. I've seen yards completely renovated on my same street and the work looked good.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Line items 1 and 2 require a bit of knowledge to do properly. #3 sounds like grunt work. I can't tell if it's for cost savings or for helping your fellow man that you're trying to make the non-profit make sense (or both, no shame in that) but if you were my client I'd say hire a pro for 1 and 2, bring in the non-profit for #3. That virtually eliminates uncertainty of outcome and still lets you help the folks with the non-profit.

    DYH thanked Revolutionary Gardens
  • 10 years ago

    LOL!! I don't see where either #1 or #2 require much skill above that of manual labor. This is something many homeowners do on their own with little to no previous experience. And since the OP has some stated experience and will be there to supervise and direct, I seriously doubt this is anything that "requires" professional attention (I would not advise MY clients that they need to call in the pros for this type of work!).

    To me, it sounds like the non-profit is fully able to execute this 'installation' - really just little more than site prep - with proper direction/supervision, even unskilled labor such as they are. It is of course your choice, but opting for them seems like a reasonable economic approach as well as supporting a worthy cause. Personally, I wouldn't think twice about it.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    @gardengal maybe I'm just jaded from having supervised volunteers, high school kids, and new hires, but while I agree that 1 and 2 aren't rocket surgery they can also be executed badly without knowledgeable supervision.