Software
Houzz Logo Print
captainbecks

I don't have baseboards

10 years ago
I am replacing my carpet with plank vinyl. I was going to get quarter round that matches the floor. It was much more pricier than I was expecting so I wanted to explore my options before deciding. My husband suggested prestained baseboards, but that then adds the challenge of matching the existing trim to it. Getting unstained baseboards and staining them at the same time would also be expensive and still not quite match. If it were just the windows, I wouldn't care as much, but the doors would be right next to the baseboards...

The floor will be grey (product attached but it looks much different in person) and the trim will be dark walnut.

Comments (10)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Definitely recommend the baseboard approach, especially if the flooring will be installed in a room where there are none existing. This should eliminate the need for the shoe molding.

    It terms of expense, whether painting or staining baseboards your price will be similar and staining on site will give you the closest color match to your existing wood doors / trim. If you are on a budget, then sourcing a pre-stained baseboard from a Home Depot / Lowes / Lumber Liquidators type store will be your least expensive option. Though it may not be an exact match, you should be able to find something reasonably close.

    Nice choice on the plank flooring by the way...it has become a very popular choice for our clients installing in basements and family rooms.

    Best wishes,

    Greg

    Project Developer with Hammer Design Build Remodel

  • 10 years ago

    You don't need to buy real wood if it's to be painted - only if the grain would show through. There is RDF (faux wood) that's far less expensive.

  • 10 years ago
    Forgot to mention I haven't bought furnishings yet. The wardrobe will be in a different room (which will have the same floor and trim but totally different colors and lighting). The chest and table on left are staying. The other table and chairs are borrowed. Also, the middle wall will be knocked down. I am getting shades that come down from the top. Basically - I'm working on every other way to lighten the room because I am dead set on not painting the wood.
  • 10 years ago
    Is shoe molding bad? What kind of modding world you recommend instead? I'm new to baseboard, never really paid attention to them before. I have a lot to research.

    When staining the existing trim, I'm hoping to keep as much grain showing as possible. Would RDF look odd next to that?
  • 10 years ago
    I don't know how to tag on here, if that's even possible, but I would have at least addressed my replies. Each paragraph is directed to commenters in chronological order, the first reply also being general.
  • 10 years ago
    Anyone have any input after I clarified some things (furnishing will be different, lighting will be better, I do want wood grain, painting the trim white is not an option)?

    I haven't figured out what is wrong with shoe moulding. The quarter round to match the floor is expensive, but if at least matches. To install baseboards and have the painters stain it when they varnish the trim will probably also be expensive. So I'm really stuck.
  • 10 years ago

    Shoe molding or quarter round are generally not used by themselves. They are used against other things like cabinets or a real baseboard. Most of the time they cover a gap between the flooring and other thing (i.e., flooring or baseboard). If you just use shoe or quarter round, it will look insubstantial and incomplete.

    Your current trim is relatively simple and not ornate. You might be able to get by with a 1" x "2 (or 4") in the same species of wood as your current trim instead of a fancier baseboard. You might also check out habitat for humanity stores in your area and discount lumber stores in your area for affordable options.

    With that said, staining baseboards and adding a polyurethane finish is super easy. I would probably do that myself.

  • 10 years ago
    Would it be crazy to start with white and have the painters paint the baseboards the wall color instead of the trim color? It would probably cost less, and not draw the eye down as much as dark walnut wood?
  • 10 years ago

    no, that is a specific look which is evolving, but you need at least a 1x2 plus a quarter round. does not have to be wood.