Software
Houzz Logo Print
treetoronto3

Magnolia ID?

10 years ago

Hello! Two years ago I planted a Magnolia I purchased from Lowes. On its tag, it said Leonard Messel. Last year it got one flower, and I didn't think anything of it. This year it got multiple, and I do not believe that this is a Leonard Messel. I cannot remember if I bought this specific plant with a bloom on it or not, so I can't remember what it looked like.


Could you help me? What Magnolia is this?

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago

    Leonard Messel is a cross between m. kobus and m. stellata. When the blossoms first appear, they do look like this, then quickly open wide to reveal a white interior and a shape similar to those of the m. stellata parent. Leonard Messel is also mildly fragrant. So, the tag could very well have been correct. If this is Leonard Messel, it is planted way too close to the house. Leonard Messel is a very large growing tree.

  • 10 years ago

    Look up 'Alexandrina'. Very common in Lowes around here, commonly called Alexander. Has a lemony fragrance on warm days. Messel blooms almost a month before Alex here, (TN) has the most frost hardy blooms of my mags, to about 28F. Alex will bloom from late Feb- early March into May, depending on the weather, and on and off through summer if enough rain. Alex is a large multistemmed plant, Messel is a tree.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    A saucer magnolia such as one of the multiple cultivars that have been grown as 'Alexandrina' may be possible but my first thought was one of the Kosar and De Vos hybrids based on the shape and perhaps smaller dimensions of the tepals of the flower shown here.

    'Leonard Messel' is a star type magnolia that never makes the tulip style flower like this one is.

    I've seen more than one kind of pine with the same single variety cards hanging on them at Lowe's. During another visit a block of a single kind of yellow magnolia hybrid - in bloom at the time - was labeled as three different kinds of magnolias, including the completely different sweet-bay magnolia. When you go to warehouse stores for plants you are not availing yourself of the same point of view and approach present at a good independent garden center AT ALL.

  • 10 years ago

    It certainly could be one of the Little Girl hybrids or Alexandrina, but the original photo does not show a classic tulip shape. For a very brief period Leonard Messel does look like this, then quickly assumes the standard star magnolia appearance.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Tepal count, poise, shape and really the coloring not the same as 'Leonard Messel'.

    http://www.ornamental-trees.co.uk/images/products/zoom/1279880723-64081400.jpg

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks. Must be a Leonard Messel...