Software
Houzz Logo Print
jjunk

To keep the slate tiles or remove?

10 years ago
We recently bought a mid century home, but the entire house is covered with slate tiles. I'm sure it's not original but we're not sure what to replace it with or whether we should keep it. We are considering linoleum ( not vinyl )
Kitchen
Front entrance
Living room

Comments (15)

  • 10 years ago

    They are beautiful, i'd keep at least the entry, kitchen & bathrooms if you have them in there. If you do remove them do it carefully and store them for the next home owner years down the road.

    jjunk thanked tooky58
  • 10 years ago

    I'd keep them too.

    jjunk thanked User
  • 10 years ago
    We would take them out and put in something that doesn't look like a patchwork quilt. This would give a cleaner look to the house...more in keeping with a mid- century modern feel. By chance do you know if they tired over terazzo floors? That would be an awesome find underneath.
  • 10 years ago

    I would definitely keep them! Why go to the expense of replacing something that is in great shape.

    jjunk thanked Bev
  • 10 years ago

    I would remove them and install a light linoleum. I love slate, but it makes you rooms feel dark. Look into this blog, this couple remodeled their mid century home, and used VTC flooring. They also pained their dark wood whites and grays to make it feel bigger and more open.


    http://fogmodern.com/living-room/

    jjunk thanked ashli swaim
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    There is no need to keep the slate at the entranceway/kitchen/bath if you are working with sheet lino/marmoleum. The two floors do the same thing = water proof.

    Just ask the lino rep about discolourating in direct sunlight...especially if the windows do NOT have high UV rating. Find out about discolouration underneath certain types of area rugs. The same rugs that cause problems with vinyl, hardwood, cork, etc also cause problems with lino.

    Just be prepared for these tiny issues. If you are prepared for them, you can work around them. If you don't know about them and something happens, you will be very very upset. Better to ask now so that you can prepare later.

    jjunk thanked Cancork Floor Inc.
  • 10 years ago

    I had no idea about the discolouration , yes it is good to know,, thanks we have a full wall is windows with a lot of light. Something to think about!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Keep them, they are beautiful. I love these tiles. I once had them in a large kitchen in a house we rented, they are so durable, non slippy and so easy to clean plus they look so beautiful. I truly wish I had them in this house but hubby put marble down and kitchen has a tile I like but I prefer those you have.

    As much as marble is beautiful, and they have beautiful designs on them, I still can't get over first time we entered our new home.. the contractors had the marble polished and it shined so beautiful too but, when we started moving in, many of us slipped! I even started holding onto doors lol for fear of falling! I had them stop the regular polishing, it was just too dangerous.

  • 10 years ago

    Depends on which direction you are going with the house. If you are buying and able/interested to keep it true to period, keep it! I you are buying a house in relatively authentic condition, untouched by multiple updates and/or DIYers, it will be much more interesting (and maybe valuable) later if you've preserved and modernized keeping it consistent with the house. We've relocated to Europe where they are often required to update with a "consistent to the original property" approach. I find it a pity when I return to the States and see so many missed opportunities when buildings and homes are simply updated without regard to historical value.

    That said, ultimately it's your investment and you should love what you have!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I am not sure what sort of climate you live in but if you have winter and those tiles are not heated they are just plain cold. I also think they look dated. They remind me of what we were doing in the late 90's and early 2000's. Also I find standing on slate in the kitchen hard on my back and hips they start to ache not to mention everything shatters if you drop something on the floor. I really think it is a matter of personal taste. Something is beautiful if you appreciate it and love it but I find if my client finds something is not to their liking it is best to change it. It is not my job to convince otherwise. I believe people should LOVE where they live. It is so irritating to walk in the front door and be reminded of things you don't like. Unless you know you will be moving in two years why would you live with something you don't like to save the resale value. Might as well rent.

  • 10 years ago
    http://www.diyadvice.com/diy/flooring/install-resilient-floor/loose-lay-sheet-vinyl/

    I would use loose lay over the tile. I happen to like your floors.
  • 10 years ago

    Similar to what Theresa Holt said you could put a floating floor over it. Laminate wood or vinyl are good for that. Then in the future if someone wants the tile back they can just lift the floor. I'm on the fence with you current floor.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    That is a great idea as long as it is flat enough.

  • 10 years ago

    Keep them. They are beautiful and blend very nicely with the fireplace. I can't imagine that any linoleum would be an improvement over the slate's rich look