Software
Houzz Logo Print
goldblush

Did I just hurt my plants?...

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I have been noticing a number of casualties to slugs every morning to my seedlings and I decided to closely monitor the situation.

After a heavy rain shower early this evening I went to check on my garden and it was infested with slugs. I had never seen anything like it...perhaps I was oblivious to them before, since I am relatively new to gardening, but wow they were all over my young plants. Trying to kill them one by one was now out of the question so I grabbed table salt (had run out of epsom salt) just doused it on top of each one. I also put a protective ring around the young seedlings. As I was putting the salt the question of what this might do to the plants was running through my head but all I was thinking of was ridding of as much of the slugs as I could:)!

So now the question is, did I harm my plants with the salt around them and if it is harmful is there a way to rectify the soil around them quickly?

Thank you for you salient advice!

Comments (11)

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you for your advice rhizo. I did not notice some plant distress on a few of the seedlings. I will get sluggo and the beer traps. I had always heard that beer traps do not work but I will give them a try.

  • 10 years ago

    Beer traps work very well!! As does the Sluggo. You can also try spraying or soaking the area around your new seedlings with leftover coffee. NOT spreading coffee grounds - they have a minimal effect but are a good source of OM for the garden - but with the actual coffee. It is the caffeine you are after (CG's have minimal caffeine left in them) - caffeine has been found to be an effective neurotoxin on mollusks (slugs and snails). And it is harmless to the plants.

    goldblush thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 10 years ago

    A very effective alternative to using salt on slugs is to spray them with a 50/50% mix of ammonia and water. They dissolve immediately, the ammonia does not hurt the leaves, and clears the trace of the slug easily.

    Renais

    goldblush thanked renais1
  • 10 years ago

    I had the same problem with slugs! For some reason my plants were infested with them! I am uncomfortable with idea of using any type of poisons when treating for them, so I did my research and came across this all-natural/organic solution for snail and slugs. The product is called Wilco Snail and Slug Gel. I used the gel to create a barrier around the base of my plants and I noticed that the snails and slugs stay away from it. It might be worth a try.. Good luck!

    Here's what it looks like..

    https://wilcodistributors.com/information/products/homeowner/wilco-snail-slug-gel/

    goldblush thanked kayseeg
  • 10 years ago

    What great tips kayseeg, renais1 & gardengal48! Thank you! Some of these solutions I had not heard about, so I feel so much more equipped to handle the slugs moving forward! Thank you again hey!

  • 10 years ago

    Kayseeg, I can't find any directions or labeling online. Do you mean that this gel is applied as a barrier around each plant? How long does it last? How many plants will be protected per bottle?

    goldblush thanked rhizo_1 (North AL) zone 7
  • 10 years ago

    The active ingredient in Wilco Snail and Slug Gel is Sodium Chloride, common table salt, according to the web site the link above connects to.

    kimmq is kimmsr

    goldblush thanked kimmq
  • 10 years ago

    I noticed the sodium chloride on the labeling of the gel but assumed that perhaps it's harmful effects on plants would be counteracted by the other ingredients?...My plants definitely suffered, unfortunately, from the table salt around them. I will have to regrow or buy more seedlings to replace the babies I have lost:(. Quite bummed. More lessons learned in gardening!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    kayseeg, I would be very interested in seeing pictures of your application of this gel around plants, especially plants with a succulent stem like seedlings. I've seen such gels sold before, and have only seen ill effects from their use. I was surprised that they even still sold such a product. I would also consider being careful not to use much of this gel where you want to plant salt sensitive plants in the future. I'm glad you had what you perceive as good results, but I remain extremely concerned about the use of this product in a garden.

    I would avoid the Wilco snail like the plague. It is just a cheap gel with a significant amount of salt content. I see this as a case where the cure is worse than the disease. Yes, the gel might kill a snail that went through it, but you are adding about 25 g of salt to your soil per container of gel. I've seen similar snake oil products before. Folks used to make a gel like this from soil moisture absorbing polymers and cornstarch with added salt. The cost of making the Wilco product is probably very tiny, but my suspicion is that it is sold for over $1/pound--exorbitant in my opinion.

    I wondered if I was being overly cautious about this stuff, so I called our extension folks who confirmed my thoughts, and also my put is on an agenda for master gardener training to help spread the word. I seldom get worked up much about garden remedies sold, but this one piqued my ire because it could hurt folks plants and soil.


    Renais

    goldblush thanked renais1
  • 10 years ago

    I just looked up the price of the Wilco product: $20/pound. Get Sluggo instead for a proven, save and effective solution to slugs.

    Renais

    goldblush thanked renais1