Having had basically the same problem, I'm happy to have switched to nitrile gloves. Don't provide the cushioning of heavier gloves, but provide excellent grip, permit your fingers to move easily, and wear well. When they'really worn out ( which takes a long time) just throw them away.

Here's a link to one of the brands I've used. In fact, I picked up a 5 pair pack this past weekend at HD. Some stores stock them as work gloves, some as garden gloves. http://www.homedepot.com/p/Firm-Grip-Nitrile-Multi-Color-Large-Multi-Purpose-Gloves-5-Pack-3210/202790055