Software
Houzz Logo Print
zensojourner

Need interior paint with longer open time

10 years ago

I need oil based paint but apparently NOBODY makes that anymore.

After going round and round with various sales type people, apparently there is no paint on the market that has a longer open time than 15 or 20 minutes. At least that was what I was quoted by Benjamin Moore when I gave up trying to get accurate information from the salespeople at the paint store and called them directly. The guy insisted that there is no paint on the market with a longer workability time.

Even their Advance Paint, which has a 4-6 hour dry-to-the-touch time, I am being told directly by Benjamin Moore (and given that I live in a desert, Northern Nevada High Sierras) only gives me 15 to 20 minutes to get it up on the wall before it gets too dry to blend when you're painting in sections. And I need to be able to sit down and rest between sections because I'm old and decrepit.

If there is ANYTHING out there that gives you a reasonable working time, please please please share with me what that is. I'm getting really discouraged.

Comments (19)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    There is oil paint out there, it just is not labeled for home use. Other than that, I don't think there is anything else.

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    You need to learn how to paint with Aura. You don't need a long open time because it blends into itself. You don't need to keep a wet edge all the time like it used to be in the old days. It's okay if you roll a section of wall, sit down for a short bit and go back and pick up where you left off. You won't be able to tell where you stopped and started - that's the inherent nature of Aura and how it works.

    Apply Aura and do not roll back into it. It's like nail polish; apply it and move on.

    You just have to be sure to cover tightly your brush/roller and paint when not in use.

    Don't stop in the middle of a wall, don't leave your edge for hours or overnight. But breaks between sections will work out just fine. I've done it with Aura in dark colors and light colors - and you really can't tell where I stopped for a break.

    Pyewacket thanked Lori A. Sawaya
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Seriously! It wouldn't be so bad if I lived where there is humidity, but all the drying times are basically about halved due to how dry it is here. Also, the best extenders are propylene-glycol based - and they don't work well in high-temperature low humidity areas - which is here.

    Behr makes an oil paint but it is only available in semi-gloss and they insist there are no flatteners for that. Not even from them.

    Sherwin Williams makes an oil in Satin, but Sherwin Williams is pretty awful paint in general, plus its NOT CHEAP either.

    The tech at Benjamin Moore said to add 8 oz of water to the paint to extend drying time, but it seems to me that would thin the paint to the point where (because its going on all drippy and wet) would actually dry faster due to the thin layer you'd be putting on. Maybe not. But adding water to paint makes me shudder, I have never had to thin paint like that that I can recall, unless MAYBE I was getting to the end of a bucket - and then I would be thinning it back to "normal". Its not something I've done much, if ever.

    Behr says to add 4 oz of water to their acrylics to extend drying time. Less water, but I don't know the % of solids and pigments between the 2 (Benjamin Moore vs Behr) so possibly that's just as bad as adding 8 oz to the Benjamin Moore.

    The tech at Behr also insisted that the company has NO DATA as to open time or wet edge time, either one. At all. I don't believe him. If its true, seems like a pretty serious oversight.

    Yeah. I'd say that at least in my circumstances, I've entered the era of "painting sucks". You can hardly even find turpentine in gallons any more. I'm SO over-the-hill, LOL! At least I can still get TSP.

    Have any of you ever thinned an acrylic with water to extend drying time? Does it really work that way, without affecting the paint in other, negative ways?

  • 10 years ago

    Some paints I splash a little water in just to make it flow better. And it does seem to extend drying time a bit, but only a little. If you do put too much water in though, it will affect the integrity of the paint and makes it less able to self prime.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I was in El Paso for 8 years, now in Phoenix. I'm from the midwest. I get the humidity thing. It's not that bad once you get used to it. I do think Aura is the most user-friendly as far as leaving lap marks - meaning it is very forgiving and you really don't get lap marks. With a lil practice, I think the short open times can be managed without additives. I'm not a fan of messing with the paint.

    Overall that's my m.o. - don't mess with the paint. I don't mess with tweaking formulas either.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I wonder if you could pre-humidify the room before you start, close the windows and shut off the fans.

    I would out down a plastic cover on the floor, then a canvas dropcloth, and spray with a garden sprayer of water. The humidity should skyrocket.

    Casey

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I dont open a can of paint anymore without adding floetrol. It really helps extend the drying time. I still wouldnt end up in the middle of a wall, or ceiling, and take a break, but, it keeps the streaks away, and the paint looks even all over. Oh, and I am old and decrepit too (77)

  • 10 years ago

    After 15 or 20 minutes all the walls should be coated and you should be enjoying an iced tea.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I made the mistake of having a bathroom painted with oil based paint 12 years ago when you could still get it here (Cali). I painted a second bath with eggshell latex about a year later and the 2nd bath looks way better than the oil painted bath. The oil is very shiny (ugly) and it has cracked in places. The latex bath still looks like it was freshly painted, seriously. I'm in So Cal so I get the dryness issue. But I really regret using the oil based paint. Used it on some trim, too, and it yellowed and cracked. My front door looked like a spider web of cracking and it was a bear to remove it all. Now that I'm repainting that oil-painted bathroom, I'm stuck with messier prep work, too, in order to repaint with a latex.

    I've used Aura paint throughout the exterior and interior on my recent DIY repaint. I've only used it in the matte finish inside and it really is easy to use and has a beautiful and washable finish. I used the matte in the kitchen, too, and it cleans right up. They have a little video on how to roll it on the BM website. Easy peasy.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    quote from above" At least I can still get TSP." which you really should not be using for painting purposes anyway.

  • 10 years ago

    All I can say is I empathize with you. As a DIY'er and engineer and amateur woodworker I have applied many different finishes. My last experience was a similar PITA.

    Wanted to paint the inside of my 27 x 27 garage. Last time I did any painting in the house was about 5 years ago. I've used Valspar, with good success for the past 15 years.

    Well something happened to the formulation of paint in the last 5 years. Seems nobody wants to talk about it. The Valspar that was once OK, now is awful to work with - same drying problem - and I'm in Minneapolis. Hard not to leave roller marks, does not flow well. Brush used to cut-in was clogged / loaded after 15 minutes - threw the brush out.

    I've come to find out that now most paint is crap. Must have been some sort of EPA edict - that it all got changed.

    I know why professional painters spray - it may be the only way to get an acceptable job.


  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Things change all the time in paint world. Not sure anybody can keep up. No matter what changes chemical-ish or whatever, what I do know is the paint color chips remain the target. Whatever they do, they gotta be able to make paint to match the chips within reason. Some colors have not made it thru all the transitions. There are colors in the SW fandeck, for example, that I know for a fact cannot be mixed to match the chip. Same with some stain colors.

    Which is why I find the paint code formula threads amusing.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    quote from above"I know why professional painters spray " some do , some don't, I don't. You just have to adjust with the ever changing paint formulations, which seems to change daily. Now, I work with paint 8 hours a day 5 or 6 days a week( normally) so it's a little different for me and other professionals, we HAVE to adapt.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Just use Penetrol for oil products and Floetrol for latex products to extend open time. Benjamin Moore still makes some oil based products like satin Impervo and super spec DTM. Not sure if they are being sold on West coast though.

  • 10 years ago

    If its available, AND if your walls have are defect free enough, Satin Impervo can look really good on walls. It has a fairly long open time. And more so if penetrol is added.

    If you go this this route, proper prep is a must.

  • 10 years ago

    No....not Floetrol. Latex Xtender from XIM is much better. I have it in our Paint-dept at an ACE hardware, & I believe it's in most ACE Regional warehouses.

    Just checked...the ACE Lacrosse, WI whse has some. Ask at your ACE for sku #1524446, for the qt. size. Stores have to order a box of 4 unfortunately....

    Faron

  • 10 years ago

    @Faron 79 -- Sadly the Latex Xtender is exactly the stuff that doesn't work well in hot dry climates.

    @Global Paint - I'm skeptical of the use of Floetrol for this purpose as their engineers insist it won't improve wet edge time for more than about 15 minutes. Plus, I've heard a lot of reports of it going stringy.

    @Lori - I don't like to muck about with the paint either. I feel like it ought to come out of the can and go right on the walls without adulteration. Sadly it seems paint isn't what it once was - some good, some bad there. We're almost done cleaning about a decade of nicotine and tar from smokers off the walls. Getting close to getting ready to paint. We need to put up a double coat of the Kilz original, then paint. I've not bought the paint yet because I keep waffling about which paint to buy, but it looks like it'll be the Behr, because all the dry times are pretty equivalent except for some of the alkyd types (mostly from Benjamin Moore), and their dry times are not THAT much different that I would feel right about spending almost double the cost on the Benjamin Moore.

    @Christopher Nelson Wall Coverings - I "shouldn't" be using TSP? Seriously? Care to explain that? Because it saves a crapton of time sanding. I've used it for decades and my father before me. Probably his father before him, too, I don't know, was TSP available in the late 1800s? LOL! Its the stuff that was the primary active ingredient in Spic 'n Span until they banned its use in daily cleaners.

    I don't know where folks get the idea that its supposedly so hard to rinse off the walls. Its deglossing activity alone is enough to make it worthwhile. For most rooms, its a rinse down with bleach water, then a rinse with plain water. The bleach water is to help remove any saponified grease, and the plain water gets rid of any lingering bleach residue. In and near kitchens I will do an extra bleach rinse. Its a lot more likely that you'll have saponified grease to clean off in the kitchen.

    If your objection is environmental, all I can say is in the quantities I am using it, it won't be a problem. There were VERY good reason for legislating it out of laundry soap, but when its only being used once every 8 or 10 years (or longer) to clean walls prior to painting, that's a different matter. Not enough of it enters the environment this way to matter. Hence, it is still allowed to be sold for that purpose.

    I won't be using it in the bathroom (TSP), because it can damage tiles, and nearly 60 year old tile doesn't need to be subjected to any more stress. I'm not sure what I WILL use in there, but due to the fact that things like Dirtex and other TSP alternatives don't degloss, I'm not looking forward to sanding even that small area to prep for paint. The paint in there is the 2nd layer that went up, maybe the third. Most rooms were initially painted yellow, then this hideous taupe, then the green, then the current coat of paint. Not much painting in 60 years, actually. I may have reversed the green and taupe layers. I'll have to check. Anyway chances are good (or bad, depending on your point of view) that there is lead in that thar paint. Give me TSP over sanding any day of the week.

    @sambah06 - Sadly my walls are textured. Ceiling too. It was a "thing" in the 50s. The walls are wet-plastered - they put up wallboard and then plastered over it. The walls are pretty thick because of that. Anyway, not smooth. I'm sticking with a Satin - there is semi-gloss on there now and the texture of the walls does look funny with that much gloss. I would call it "lightly" textured, but its still textured. At least I don't have popcorn ceilings, but that was more a thing in the 60s/70s.

    @Brushworks - sorry, no. I will NOT be enjoying a cold drink after finishing a room in 15 to 20 minutes. Even when I was young and spry, I couldn't paint a room that fast. I'm not even going to aspire to painting a room that fast as it would definitely be bad for the walls, and probably not so hot for my heart, either, LOL!

    @Sombreuil - I noticed an obvious increase in humidity just from washing down the walls. I will never get used to living in an environment that is so dry you can literally FEEL it when the humidity goes up just from hauling a couple of buckets into a room. (Well, that and having all 4 walls and the ceiling in a damp state due to washing them down).

    I do have a large plastic tarp. I was going to use it as the bottom layer under less slippery drop cloths when we actually start to paint. I'm pretty sure spraying it down some with plain water would do exactly what you describe. I think we'll give that a shot with the first room we paint and see how it goes. I'm not so much worried about the primer since its Kilz Original (oil-based, longer dry times), but the actual paint sure could use a little help to extend the dry time. We'll try it and see how it goes.

    Thanks to everyone for the responses.


  • 10 years ago

    Satin Impervo is a satin finish.