I would suggest painting the white garage door and other white areas gray.

I know everyone is too much into gray right now! I only suggested it because of the color of your stone. It is a light gray right?

I love the taupe better as well. Check out Grant Beige HC 83 or Sandy Hook Gray HC 108- more taupe but I don't see how that would work with the color of your stone..........

How about changing the white to khaki and painting the door olive green? Or the door could be a dark red....not lipstick red.

Your closer picture popped up after I posted......I do not think that gray goes with your stone. You were right about the warmer colors.

Here is what I've come up with in the BM color visualizer so far.

I like the colors you come up with especially given the narrow range of options available given the specific brick blend and your red roof. But I think a new wood door and matching garage door in dark/med brown tones would be a really fantastic upgrade here.

Gustavson Dundes Architecture · More Info

High Park · More Info

Yikes! The original picture looks totally different than the latest shots!!!!! I think we are all in agreement to leave the grays behind!!

Are you able to show us Thicket AF 405 - it is a sage green. Or check out Hamilton Blue which is a deeper slate blue. Or even Montana Agate or Fresh Clay which both resemble the roof color - might be interesting.

You will find the colors are just not 100% accurate in translation but good for a general idea. I would get a few test pots done up just in case - always test first before committing to gallons!

Hi there - this has so much potential. May I suggest that the gables and roof mean that you are going to get the best result if you emphasize some more traditional exterior features for scale purposes. From a distance, in the first photo and in the close up of the brick, there is a greige in your brick (the mid tone) or the warm gray that the brick reads from a distance are going to do a lot for you - a lighter tone but darker than white .. and in the gable, we need to add some elements to help bring the scale down.

So - test this shade for all your siding http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/plymouthrock

and use the off white as your white trim - london fog http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/londonfog

Use this on the double gable that has siding over the front door . . the trim light tone there will help balance the house by emphasizing that gable and de-emphasizing the dormer . . necessary . .

May I suggest in the dormer gable that you add a slatted trimmed out shelf on three or four evenly spaced corbels under the window . . a shelf is not as much maintenance as a window box . . you can drop it just 8" below the sill so you can add a box seasonally . . but visually, it is going to lengthen the window which because of the dormer comes out seeming high on the dormer wall ..

Paint the garage door the siding color rather than the trim color - deeper so it hides .. and picking a color that will hide in / seem perfect surrounded by brick . .

I would suggest a mossy green door . . http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/piningforyou

but one that matched the roof tonally (terracotta red) would also be fine .. test http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/terracottatile 

The house does need a punctuation mark and the door is the right spot for it .. .you could go to a deep mustard / dijon tone . . http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/turmeric

ps - can't see a pergola advancing the front elevation . . What would be nice is a trough planter with a columnar evergreen or vining trellis to vertically sort of fill in the gap between the garage and the brick post to the left of the front door . .