Software
Houzz Logo Print
just_janni

Thoughts on "almost Passiv" house

10 years ago

Central NC location. 3600 sq feet. Single story. Very open volume / loft space. Plan is for exposed ductwork and geothermal, with ERV / HRVs, etc

I am thinking this is overkill.

However, I don't like the ductless and our concrete panelized construction isn't very flexible in adding holes that were not designed in.

With the loss of the tax credits (potential / likely) - I am wondering if this is overkill and too much money / no return.

I don't like the noise of the air source heat pump outdoor units - but...

Our heating and cooling loads are really not that high, so our HVAS is more moisture management, I think, that real heating / cooling.

Are there any other ideas that I am missing?

(no access to natural gas, no woodburning fireplace or propane fired fireplace)

Comments (13)

  • 10 years ago

    Mini split and ERV would be my choice. Have you talked to your builder about putting in the holes for the Mini split ducts? What R-Value are your walls and ceiling going to be? Then you can calculate the load for the heating and cooling. Is there a reason that a wood burning stove/fireplace is not being considered for heating?

    just_janni thanked homepro01
  • 10 years ago

    We talked to wall panel provider on putting in holes - it's HARD and expensive. Concrete is VERY hard, and it's 3 inches of concrete on either side of 4" of foam. We've done the land calculations and some passive house recertification work.

    I want ZERO combustion inside the living envelope for safety and indoor air quality concerns. (and the overall lack of love for hauling in wood). Our volume of space isn't all that awesome for ductless or more singular points of heating / cooling, I don't think.

  • 10 years ago

    Jannicone,

    How is your builder running the power lines and the plumbing lines (Gas and Water)? They have to drill a hole for that. 3" of concrete is nothing to cut a hole through. People dig through foundations that are deeper than that.

    I can understand the need for zero combustion but with a Passiv haus with an appropriately sized ERV, you should not have an issue keeping the indoor air combustion free. Wood or wood pellet stoves don't add negative indoor air quality. The stoves don't release smoke into the living space at all. I don't love stacking wood either:-) But I love the wood stoves and wood pellet systems. They are really cool. See some links below. These are not fireplaces but completely sealed systems.

    Wittus Stoves and Fireplaces are my favorite

    Wittus Pellet Stove as an example

    Minisplits are used to heat passiv haus and energy efficient homes. You really use a very small system to heat and cool your home. Where are you located? I have linked a Youtube video that I liked that is not necessary about meeting the passiv haus standard but really focus on the heating of a energy efficient house.

    Backup Heating Passive House Series

    This video shows a mini split installed in an energy efficient home

    Do you know the R values you are getting to with the walls and the roof?

    Good luck!

  • 10 years ago

    We built in all the "mouse holes" into the precast panels for water, electrical, kitchen hood exhaust, some HVAC holes, etc.

    We're getting (maybe not exact) 28 in the walls, and over 50 in the roof with euro triple glazed / passive house certified windows.

    I will look at the mini splits again - if they would work, be cost effective and could be supplemented with fans to move the air (Hubby truly wants a Big Ass fan or 2...) This could be a nice cost savings for us, too, as we had a fairly costly geothermal system planned.

    I won't do wood - I don't want any combustion in the house and for the most part - the wood stove is not the look I am going for. and I am not feeding any stove...

  • 10 years ago

    "I don't like the noise of the air source heat pump outdoor units"

    If you don't want outdoor noise, then how do you plan to cool the house?

    just_janni thanked mike_home
  • 10 years ago

    Austin air companie,

    You are welcome to your opinion.

    Jannicone,

    Noise should not be huge factor in your build with the mass of concrete and the foam sandwich. Mini splits are also less noisy than conventional ducted hvac. I love ceiling fans and have them in every room with my current conventional ducted Heating and cooling home. I am going to get rid of my conventional ducted AC system once the first phase of my energy retrofit is done. Why can't you use the current hole you have planned for your AC system? Do you know with Passivhaus, what the J load calculation for your area will be?

    Just curious, whose windows are you using?

    just_janni thanked homepro01
  • 10 years ago

    The hole we have planned for the geothermal is really only for the water lines so the size and placement would not be appropriate and I am sure with the volume of space we'd need more than one. I will try to find the load calcs from the passive house. I know heating we were there pretty easily, but cooling was the larger challenge.

    as for noise, I am in the woods and cherish the peacefulness. Not having an outdoor unit when I replaced my air source hp made me realize how noisy and annoying that was. Don't know how that would compare to a couple mini splits

    windows ugh. The saga. We have had them for well over a year. We went with HOCO / Stabil who, I learned, went bankrupt and ceased operations in Austria late last year. I sure hope all of the fit and there are no major issues...

  • 10 years ago

    Please realize that you have to take possession of your house by December 31st in order to qualify for the geothermal tax credit. The credit does not apply to the cost of duct work. It does not look like the tax credit will be extended into 2017.

    just_janni thanked mike_home
  • 10 years ago

    ^^^ yeah I know. :-(

  • 10 years ago

    Janninecone,

    Sorry to hear about your experience with Hoco. I did not realize they went out of business. They were a great manufacturer, so your windows should be good. This is a link of a picture of the mini split installation so that you can see the tubing that run into your house. This unit looks likes it has more than 3 outlet units in the house. Depending on your configuration, you may need more or less. Where are you located geographically? They are quite a few mini splits in my area so I can tell you they are much quieter than my newer HVAC system. But it is always best to hear them for your self. They are quite popular in commercial businesses so you should be able to find a business with one in operation.

    just_janni thanked homepro01
  • 10 years ago

    I am in Wake County, NC - near Wake Forest. And I really don't like the look of that thing! LOL (minimalist!)

    Bummed about the windows - it's too bad - I have a sample and they are built like proverbial brick....... house..... totally isolated, great extrusion for the aluminum exterior, we did a custom color, and really pretty larch wood interiors. Thanks for the confidence in their quality. I am pretty sure no one will know what the heck to do with them. LOL

  • 10 years ago

    As long as your builder is familiar with installing passiv haus windows you should be fine. I prefer the mini splits to conventional and don't want large expanses of duct work in my home for forced air. I will the unit mounted on a wall where it is not easily visible. I think if you are comfortable with the cost, the duct work and the space to put in the Geothermal Heat pump, that may be what you get for your aesthetic needs.

    If something happens to the Hoco, several manufacturers can provide the glass for the units. It may take a little bit of cajoling but it should not be a problem. Not much goes wrong with these types of windows. At most, you will want to change the handles. I assume these are tilt turn? Or tilt turn and vents?