Software
Houzz Logo Print
dragon49_gw

Is this Vietnamese Coriander or a weed?

10 years ago

This is popping up in and around my garden. At first, I thought it was a weed, but it looked familiar and the growth pattern more resembled an herb rather than a weed. I have grown Vietnamese Coriander before and it looks almost exactly like this, EXCEPT, these lack some blotches of color that the Coriander had. I tasted a few leaves. It had no taste at all. It didn't have the normal grassy taste of a weed, nor did it have any flavor at all.



So, is this some crappy, bland, overwintered, Vietnamese Coriander, or is it a weed?



Comments (13)

  • 10 years ago

    Looks like smartweed, Polygonum.

  • 10 years ago

    Vietnamese 'coriander' is a Persicaria odorata, so it is very closely related to Polygonum species and consequently similar in appearance. However, it is a tropical plant so I very much doubt it is what you have in your NY garden.

  • 10 years ago

    A few seasons ago, (I don't remember how many year's back) I bought Vietnamese Coriander from a local nursery. I don't remember it overwintering, but thought maybe I missed it and it came back again. The internet tells me that Polygonum is spicy and I didn't notice any taste, but to be honest, I only took a tiny bite of one leaf and chewed very briefly. Now that I know these are edible and don't have to fear for my health, I can have a proper taste. I'm away from the family garden for a week and a half and will taste some leaves when I get there and report the results.

  • 10 years ago

    I really don't think Persiacaria odorata could overwinter in your region unless there is something we don't know, like this is growing inside a greenhouse or something. It's a tropical plant.

  • 10 years ago

    It doesn't have any of the trademark spots on the leaves. And if you can't taste anything, then it's definitely not Vietnamese coriander. That stuff is potent.

  • 10 years ago

    That definitely looks like "rau răm" or vietnamese coriander to me.

  • 10 years ago

    I wasn't kidding about literally no flavor, so if it is Vietnamese coriander, it lost flavor after some ovewinterings.

  • 10 years ago

    ngan007 - It resembles Vietnamese Coriander because it is in the same plant family. But aside from the lack of flavour and lack of markings there is no way the tropical VC would survive a New York winter outdoors.

  • 10 years ago

    Hee hee - zone 11 -14 is what one website says for Vietnamese Coriander. Certainly not something that can survive a NY winter. I checked the NY Flora Atlas. One of these plants is most likely your tasteless plant:

    Accepted Name Persicaria amphibia ssp. laevimarginata American water smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria arifolia halberd-leaved tear-thumb

    Accepted Name Persicaria capitata pink-headed smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria careyi Carey's smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria coccinea scarlet smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria extremiorientalis far-eastern smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria hydropiper water-pepper

    Accepted Name Persicaria hydropiperoides mild water-pepper

    Accepted Name Persicaria lapathifolia dock-leaved smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria longiseta low smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria maculosa lady's thumb

    Accepted Name Persicaria nepalensis Nepalese smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria orientalis prince's-feather

    Accepted Name Persicaria pensylvanica Pennsylvania smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria perfoliata mile-a-minute-weed

    Accepted Name Persicaria punctata dotted smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria sagittata arrow-leaved tear-thumb

    Accepted Name Persicaria setacea bristly smartweed

    Accepted Name Persicaria virginiana jumpseed

  • 6 years ago

    I have a tasteless plant that looks just like the Vietnamese Coriander growing wild in my garden in the Piedmont of North Carolina. I believe it to be "Lady's Thumb", many with striking dark red markings. Such a disappointment when I tried it and it had no flavor.

  • 6 years ago

    I don’t recommend nibbling plants you haven’t affirmatively and conclusively identified. People in my area end up in the hospital after mis-identifying poison hemlock as wild carrot or sweet cicily. Best to figure it out first.

  • 3 years ago


    Very disappointed because I find these in my garden, and they dont taste like anything