Software
Houzz Logo Print
daninthedirt

lessons from the furnace

I did an interesting experiment with a thermometer. I
noticed that my smaller squashes and cukes were regularly wilting in the
afternoon heat and sun. No prob. I give them a soaking, and then they're fine.
But the next day the same thing happens, And the next, and the next. Stick your
finger in the soil under the mulch and it's moist, though the top of the mulch
is dry. Whaaat? The roots of those plants sure aren't hurting for water.

But I think this is the reason. With the air temp at
100F, the top layer of the dry (brown) mulch, fully lit by the sun, is about 130F. When I irrigate, the temperature of that top layer goes down.
The surface temperature of the moistened mulch is then only 95F. That's because
spraying with the cooler water cooled the mulch down? Nope. That's the mulch
temperature an hour later, when it's still moist but thoroughly warmed by the
sun. The moist mulch is cooler than the air because of the evaporation of the water from it
which, if it were windy enough,
would be closer to the dew point, which is about 75F. That's why you feel cool
when you're wet. You are. Especially if it is windy.

So my smaller plants are getting BAKED by the surface of the hot, dry mulch (or
soil). That, and not lack of water and not lots of sunlight on the leaves, is
stressing them. The temperature of the surface is FAR higher than the air
temperature well off the ground. Moistening the surface around the plants cools the soil off and thereby reduces that stress. They aren't getting
baked anymore. Of course one solution would be to give the plants some shade. I'm reluctant to do that because the leaves themselves can
use the sunlight handily. More mature plants, with lots of leaves that shade
the surrounding soil, are not affected in this way. I'm wondering about setting
up shade cloth low down that basically shades the soil without shading the
plant. No, making the layer of mulch thicker won't help, but using a small amount of water to moisten the top layer of mulch would. I guess I could cover the surface with white paper, but that would be a PIA.

This makes me wonder if plants are less heat-stressed at a
high air temperature when the humidity is lower, because evaporation from the
leaves and from the soil makes the leaves and soil cooler. So the "feels like"
temperature may be more appropriate to plant stress than the air temperature.

Always getting new lessons about gardening in HZ10.

Comments (50)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    appreciate your findings, daninthedirt. As i started reading your first paragraph i was thinking a LOW shading apparatus would probably help. Glib has a great suggestion of a living mulch, to shade the surface while living and biomass at the end of the season

  • 10 years ago

    If plants are wilting in the heat of the day but recovering at night then they are simply respiring at a rate that exceeds their uptake. The recovery means that there is available water in the soil.

    If they stay wilted at night, then the soil likely needs to be irrigated.

    If plants wilt easily, even when it's not excessively hot and the soil is moist, then the possibility of root rot becomes something to think about.

    I keep speaking of the kaolin clay spray that I've been using, 'Surround WP'. One of its primary uses is to prevent this daily heat stress on many veggies and tree fruits. I use it religiously on my squash once July comes to Alabama....no more wilting.

  • 10 years ago

    Well we're talking about "excessively hot". Obviously the wilting is because the respiration of liquid exceeds the uptake. The question is whether that is happening because their roots don't have enough water to take up, or because they're just too hot. Also it's clear that when plants wilt, they are stressed, and the fact that they recover at night doesn't remove that stress. So the issue is how to reduce that stress.

    What I've concluded is that moistening just the top layer of soil or mulch is an effective and water-conserving way to cool them off and reduce that stress. Daily deep watering is NOT the answer. One minute of spray on the plants (thereby wetting maybe the top eighth inch of the mulch) completely eliminates the stress. The plants get happy quickly.

    I've heard that kaolin clay spray on the leaves can help reduce heat stress by increasing the reflectivity of the leaves. But the soil around the plant still gets enormously hot (unless you coat that soil with the clay as well) AND the clay actually blocks light to the leaves. So kaolin spray isn't a lot different in that regard than shade cloth. I want to get maximum sunlight on my leaves without cooking the plant.

  • 10 years ago

    Living mulch might do the trick, but it actually competes with what you're trying to grow. Closer plantings might be another strategy but again, it comes down to competition.

    I think the answer is to keep the top layer of mulch moist, just in the time of worst heat. That requires rather little water and, if done manually, rather little time. I'm just not used to thinking about heat stress as not being about the roots not getting enough water. In fact, saturating the soil at root level and keeping it that way is asking for big problems in root rot, as well as consuming large amounts of water.

  • 10 years ago

    take a look at this

    http://images.library.wisc.edu/EcoNatRes/EFacs/NAPC/NAPC04/reference/econatres.napc04.wwillis.pdf

    Fig. 11 and 12 show plant growth as a function of soil temperature. It is basically why modern soil scientists recommend having the soil covered at all times (in winter it is to limit erosion, in summer to improve growth rates). Elsewhere in the text it states that cooler soils hold more water. It is not as simple as having competition for the same water because effectively there is more available water. There is the effect of a truly developed mycorrhizal network improving water collection. Generally a living mulch improves drought resistance.

    I remember a post by PN Brown (he used to be a regular in gardenweb) a few years ago where he stated that part of his corn, planted into a field of purslane, survived the drought and gave a crop, whereas the part in bare soil did not.



  • 10 years ago

    I have experienced the day time wilting of my cucumber plants, I used to have wilting with zucchini. I no longer grow zucchini.


    To minimize the wilting of the Japanese cucumber plants, when I transplant the cucumber plants into the ground they are inside a tomato cage. I place a shade on top of the tomato cage. I am currently using a metal garbage can lid.


    The foliage seldom wilts and does not venture beyond 3-6" outside the noon shade line.


    I feel, the current is too sunny for the cucumber I am growing.




  • 10 years ago

    That's interesting about soil temperature, but I'm not sure it's relevant here. I'm talking about the soil SURFACE temperature, which radiates heat back on the underside of plants. When I sprinkle water lightly on the soil surface, I'm not changing the soil temperature at depth. I'm changing the soil SURFACE temperature because that, I believe, is what is stressing these plants. That has nothing to do with the temperature at root level. But sure, if you're worried about temps at root level, some kind of soil shading is needed.

    As to shades on plants. Sure. But plants need sunlight to grow well and produce. What I'm suggesting is how to keep plants thermally comfortable without restricting the sunlight that would hit them.

  • 10 years ago

    "This makes me wonder if plants are less heat-stressed at a
    high air temperature when the humidity is lower, because evaporation from the
    leaves and from the soil makes the leaves and soil cooler. So the "feels like"
    temperature may be more appropriate to plant stress than the air temperature."

    From my experience, low humidity doesn't seem to make much difference in plant stress when it's scorching hot out. Just replaced some sun fried squash and cucumber plants today as a matter of fact. The upside is my peppers are in heaven.

    Your experiment is interesting. One possible problem with trying to cool only the surface layer of mulch in low humidity, though, is that evaporation happens so quickly you'd almost have to be spraying every few minutes to make it effective for cooling the plants. I'm dedicated, but not that dedicated ;)

  • 10 years ago

    That's a good point. You want to wet the top layer enough to keep it moist through the worst of the afternoon but you'd rather it not stay wet overnight. That would just encourage bugs and fungus. How much you need to wet it will depend on humidity. But by the same token, the cooling power of a moist surface layer is far larger if the humidity is lower.

    We don't get low humidity here in the summer (the dew point is stuck at 75F), so I don't have any experience in that regard.

  • 10 years ago

    You are right Dan, a light watering does cool off the surface temperature of the ground. That's what I've always done, give my plants a light watering around noon, one o'clock and that seems to take care of a lot of the wilting problem. I then give the plants a real good watering at night, after the sun goes down.

    I live in such a hot temperature zone (west of Phoenix Arizona) that water/moisture evaporates quickly. I haven't had any problems with root rot or fungus with my watering schedule. My gardening is over with for a couple of months now due to the heat. We had a couple of weeks of extreme heat, once in early June where it got up to 121F and a couple of weeks of 115 to 119F. (I have pictures of my thermometer which is on a shaded patio about 6 feet off the ground). The hot dry air that reflects off the ground dries up my plants and turns all the foliage into brown crispy leaves that fall apart in the wind.

    Interestingly, I get an assortment of random plants around my yard, thanks to the bird life around here, and this spring I was gifted with a snapdragon flower that grew quite large. It started growing in the front yard, which happens to be composed of 2 inch long, light colored crushed rock. The plant grew up through the rock, and though it was relatively neglected, didn't have much of a problem with the mid day and afternoon wilting that my garden plants had, even though it was growing in direct sunlight all day, including all afternoon. I hardly watered the thing, yet it thrived. Have a picture of that too!

    It made me think, what would happen if I used some kind of very light colored type of *mulch* maybe even some whitish 2 inch crushed rock around my garden plants? The rock keeps the soil surface underneath it damp which doesn't happen in areas that don't have a covering of rock, thereby reducing the soil surface temperatures, and the light coloring reflects a lot of the heat instead of absorbing it. I'm going to do some experimenting next year. Lets compare notes if you have any ideas.

  • 10 years ago

    Well with temps over 100 for days on end most plants are going to have a tough time unless they are succulents or cacti

  • 10 years ago

    What I'm suggesting is a minimal-water and no-shade strategy for them not having a tough time. Seems to work so far. But yes, without doing anything special, that is certainly the case.

  • 10 years ago

    How about applying a silver covering on top of the soil to reflect the heat away?

    Linda

  • 10 years ago

    True but then I wonder if it would just reflect even more heat and rays right back up into the leaves

  • 10 years ago

    Yes. The same could be said about laying out white paper on top of the soil. That would reflect more light back up to the leaves. But the soil level air temperature would still remain comfortable.

  • 10 years ago

    This makes me wonder if plants are less heat-stressed at a high air temperature when the humidity is lower

    In my experience, no. This time of year, my area would normally be in a monsoon pattern where June is hot and then July cools down a bit and we get rain. So far this year, no cool down and no rain. There are stretches of time when the humidity index is in the single digits and temperatures around 95. My plants are not happy, at all. What I find is that the larger, more established plants with better root systems can handle the stress better, and are less likely to get limp.

    I am still trying to find the "perfect" spacing for a lot of my plants in my climate that allow them to shade the soil well but also not out compete each other too much, too. In your situation, you do not state what color your mulch is. I wonder if that has an impact as well?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    My mulch is ground up leaves, which is brown. But I recently piled up some grass clippings (half brown) around some plants, and their response was unchanged.

    I was thinking that with very low humidity, the leaves would have to be cooler, as evaporation off the leaves would remove heat. But that's probably not a big effect and, besides, it just means that the plants have to pump more water.

    But misting the soil surface does cool it considerably. Again, not because the water is cool, but because of the evaporation.

  • 10 years ago

    We are in a severe drought in Massachusetts, very unusual for our area, and I transplanted about 30 trees and shrubs over last fall and this spring. I have been watering them every week, but the hot dry windy weather and lack of established roots have made them wilty. So I've been continuously adding layers of mulch - nothing fancy, just leaves, compost, grass clippings, pine needles, etc. whatever is available.

    I had a bunch of shredded office paper that I was going to compost out back, and instead spread it as mulch around some of the trees and shrubs (in back). It is easy to work with, permeable, and I figured it would amplify the light in shady areas and reflect excess heat. It looks terrible, but it's an experiment and seems to be working well at keeping the soil cool and moist.

    Not sure it if would be safe to use it in the veggie garden - residues in the ink/paper?

  • 10 years ago

    The trouble with using anything reflective is that the plants might then suffer from all that reflected light.

    I agree about the living mulch. Seems a top idea. (Sorry about the pun. I hate puns.) It would cool the soil down a lot.

    Also, is it really competing when it's a different kind of plant? Legumes, for example, with tomato plants. It's the way of Nature.

  • 10 years ago

    Terrene,

    I know that we have to worry about newspaper ink these days because they use vegetable dyes (although I worry a little about making newspaper pots from pages with lots of ink). It might be worth checking to see if the office paper has ink made from veggies too.

    Linda

  • 10 years ago

    Plants grown together compete. Period. Water, NPK, the whole shebang. Different plants use nutrients slightly differently. They don't use different nutrients. The way of nature is for things to compete. That's great for nature, but it's not great if you want productivity out of one of those that is competing.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree, Dan. Here in a slightly cooler part of the furnace, water is precious and planting a living cover would just cause competition for the sparse water resources, which adds to water/heat stress rather than helping. There's a reason we weed around plants we want to do well.

  • 10 years ago

    I also agree. I think living mulches can be useful for perennials, primarily trees but not in an annual vegetable garden. A rich soil in a climate with adequate rain fall would make competition at least feasible but in a "furnace" it would be considered detrimental.

  • 10 years ago

    But although it would still be a furnace above, it would not be one below.

    And, isn't there enough moisture dan? And nutrients? I bet you place a lot of compost in your vegetable garden.

  • 10 years ago

    OK, the issue is not whether there is enough moisture at root level. The question is whether it is cool enough at ground level. Those are totally different questions. The answer to the former is YES! Loads of moisture at root level! That's what mulch does for you. The answer to the latter is no. The heat at ground level is what is seriously stressing the plants. Compost and nutrients are pretty irrelevant.

    Sure, living mulch would shade the ground and make it cooler but it would suck moisture out of the root level.

  • 10 years ago

    I know it was directed at Dan, but in desert "furnace" areas, it's not uncommon to go for 6 or more months - usually in prime growing season - with no measurable rainfall. All moisture is provided by you (and honestly, because a lot of us in desert climates have absolutely horrendous soil, most nutrients, too), and is generally spot-applied only where needed. So adding other plants solely as a living mulch is going to negatively impact the plants you're wanting to get something from as they leech water and nutrients away from your "important" plant, when you could much more easily mulch with something that isn't competing with your plants.

    As tishtoshnm says, it may be a different story in an area with naturally fertile soil and adequate rainfall, but in the desert furnace, it doesn't work that way.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Low relative humidity makes the water potential gradient steeper and increases transpiration rate, causing the plant to pull water out of the soil faster. Mulch becomes important because it conserves the reservoir of soil moisture so that there's water to support transpiration. Yes, that water vapor can provide some cooling effect to the adjacent leaves, but when it's windy the water vapor dissipates so fast there isn't much effect. Imagine running your evaporative cooler in a house with all the windows and doors open and maybe missing a few walls as well.

    Don't know if the above adds much to the discussion but in my area summer brings a triple threat of high heat, low humidity, and near-constant wind. Plants just dessicate. Water is precious, it normally doesn't rain at all during the summer, and watering, even just a little bit, during the hottest part of the day is not only hugely wasteful, it will eventually get you fined by the water authority.

  • 10 years ago

    As I said, just briefly sprinkling the top layer produces remarkable recovery from stress. Wilted leaves suddenly stop being wilted. But just sprinkling the top layer is irrelevant to the water supply of the roots. Certainly true that wind will sweep off a cooler soil-top layer of air, but by the same token, it will cool that top layer more efficiently.

    I completely agree about water being precious, but I'm talking about spreading a gallon of water over a couple of yards of soil. Takes one minute with a hose and sprinkler. You're unlikely to get cited for doing that, and it isn't even slightly wasteful. What would be hugely wasteful is responding to daily wilting by daily soaking of the soil with large volumes of water. That's the kind of thinking that I'm trying to counter.

  • 10 years ago

    I see no difference, water wise, in having the water evaporate from the surface, or from the living mulch leaves, except that a) this needs a continuous manpower commitment and b) you do not have the thermally advantageous air gap between soil or top of mulch and the first layer of the canopy.

  • 10 years ago

    Dan, You certainly have started one of the more interesting discussions that I have seen on here recently. I think it is fun to delve deeper into some of these issues, so thanks for getting it started.

  • 10 years ago

    I see some difference between water evaporating from living much and surface mulch. The surface mulch absorbs water. The living mulch doesn't. That advantageous air gap is produced by nutrients your veggies didn't get. That's not a price for an advantageous air gap that I'm willing to pay.

    Continuous manpower commitment for sprinkling? You mean, two or three minutes a day? Whew! It does mean I have to be there every day, but the time spent is nearly nill.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    virtually all water is used for evaporation. In Michigan, for a 44X44 garden I use one inch a week, 4.6 tons (so maybe 100 tons for the season, rain or irrigation). I extract less than half a ton of produce from it.

    So this thread brightly clarifies the contortions we go through when we try to avoid imitating natural systems. On one corner you have continuous manual input, on the other a finely tuned natural system where stomata open at well specified temperatures, automatically and exactly and evaporate the right amount always. This system prepares the soil for next year much better, leaving micro-channels in the soil, and OM at depth and on the surface, without any work needed.

    All I learned from this thread is that it forced me to think how living mulches are optimized. Are you a water miser? Use purslane and its waxy leaves. Nitrogen miser (or have chickens to pasture in the garden at the end of season)? Use clover. Space miser? Use sweet potatoes or savoy cabbages under your bigger plants.

  • 10 years ago

    In regard to nutrients, I don't see a problem. Any established garden is too high in P, K, and a number of other micros. Anyone who has done a recent soil test to an established garden will agree. That is the effect of repeated mulching and composting. I am years away from bringing my nutrients down to optimal levels. Plus roots access only 2-10% of the soil below the plant, and plants further have large differences in root depth. There is little competition frankly.

    The exception is N. But I find that to be a negligible expense, and also a two shot application at most.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I think what you're underestimating is how very quickly water evaporates in a hot, low (or no) humidity, often windy environment. Seriously, on a day like today (I think it's around 100 or a little above, today) I could take a completely soaked thick beach towel and put it out in the sun and it's dry in a matter of 10 minutes or so. If we were having our hot, dry winds, it would take a lot less time. I know because we do it all the time with our beach towels, so it's not hypothetical, just an example.

    A gallon of water sprinkled over a couple of yards of soil, in the same weather conditions as the towel, would be gone probably before I finished sprinkling. That's where the continuous manpower commitment seems like it would come in for me, you'd literally have to be sprinkling almost constantly to have any effect, and even then I'm feeling doubtful that it would. I think you are better off, in this environment, pouring that water into the soil at the root level (and planting wilt prone plants where they get afternoon shade, and mulching deeply).

  • 10 years ago

    Nope. It's not about mulches. You can have a foot of mulch on the soil and the plants would still be suffering. I have six inches in places. Living mulches may be optimized to reduce stress. They are in no way optimized to increase productivity in the long run.

    You don't see a problem with nutrients? Well, hey, just throw some extra N on, and plant your tomatoes an inch apart and they'll thrive because they're LOTS of nutrients down there. That's why we don't do that. Because they compete. Just like live mulch will. Avoiding imitating natural systems? Ha. Let's just let the weeds grow. That'll be, er, natural.

    Humsi, you are exactly right that my proposed strategy might not work when the humidity is very low. It works for me. I am myself right now at 96F 40% RH, 70F dewpoint. That's pretty moist. That's the way it is ALWAYS in my summer. But I feel pretty cool if I go outside when I'm wet and I'll stay cool for quite a while.

  • 10 years ago

    If I put tomatoes one inch apart, the limiting factor will be sunlight.

  • 10 years ago

    Here's the results of my little experiment this morning.

    Time: 11:00am to 12 noon. Air Temperature 111F to 112F. RH 24% Dew Point 60. Sonoran Desert - Peoria Arizona.


    Surface soil Temperature Medium

    155 F Soil surface in full sun

    120 F Soil surface in shade

    150 F White ground cover on top of soil in sun

    140 F On top of light colored rock in sun

    132 F Soil surface after watering

    110 F Soil surface in raised pot in shade

    Gah!! No wonder nothing wants to grow here in the summer. Guess I'll just continue to wait it out til September.


  • 10 years ago

    It's called syringing, and it's been used in the turf industry for decades. Not sure why there has been so much discussion about it here. It's why humans sweat. It's why gasoline feels cold. It's how swamp coolers work. It's based on the same principle that allows h2o to be both liquid and gas at 100c.


    Google "syringing turf". Or search on a lawn enthusiast forum. Lot's of cool season grass guys run their irrigation systems for a few minutes multiple times an hour on the hottest days.


    Honestly i thought most competent gardeners knew about this. Not that everyone practices it but they should at least be aware of it.

  • 10 years ago

    That's precisely right, mtwiles. Many thanks for this. Fantastic! When I first looked at it it looked to be about just promoting germination of grass seed, wherein you only need 0.05" of water or so, because the water only needed to soak in that deep. But other sources specifically call it out as a way of mitigating summer heat stress in mature grass. Though it may not be that effective in very low humidity sites. At such places it gets VERY cool, for a VERY short time. Sounds like just about all golf courses use this strategy, as the cool-season bentgrass doesn't like temps much over 80F. The trick is timing. I need to read more about this.

    So yes, Marie, you knocked the soil surface temps down by 20F, though not necessarily to even a comfortable level.

  • 10 years ago

    'What would be hugely wasteful is responding to daily wilting by daily soaking of the soil with large volumes of water. That's the kind of thinking that I'm trying to counter.'

    But would you get daily wilting if using a living mulch?

  • 10 years ago

    As I've been saying (over and over) the disadvantage of living mulch is that it competes for nutrients as well as water at root level. But if you aren't there to (shall we say) do syringing of the bed, and if living mulch removes heat stress, then that's a compromise you may have to make in terms of yield.

    It would be interesting to throw down a bed of sticks, and throw some leaves over that, such that you have aerateable shade that doesn't compete, and see if that does the trick. Or just a shadecloth well above ground-level, but below the veggie foliage.


  • 10 years ago

    this take on nutrients is in practice wrong. In an established garden, there is a "nutrient bank". Having tested my soil in 2008 and 2011, during which a lot of compost was laid, I got my P from 7 to 80 ppm (optimal would be around 50), and my K from 80 to about 300 ppm (optimal would be half as much). Ca and Mg were high all along. Since 2012, I have not added anything except leaves and nitrogen, and later cover crops. It will probably not get back to 50 ppm P for decades, or until i work this land, considering that some beds are mulched and I always carry in more OM than I take out.

    If you have manured your garden twice, or mulched it four times, you roughly have a bank to work with unless you live on a beach. That means you will not be nutrient limited this year. Over long periods of time, you will have deposits from mulch and compost and organic matter and unused fertilizer, and losses from herbivory (the plants you take out). But the biggest losses are not during harvest, but rather in the winter, when higher precipitation carries nutrients below the root depth. Nitrogen is lost faster because it diffuses 50 times faster than P (I don't remember the exact number but I think K is five times P). In most cases the limiting factors in an established garden is water, sunlight or nitrogen. Or, as Dan noted in the original post, adverse temperatures in both directions.

  • 10 years ago

    'You don't see a problem with nutrients? Well, hey, just throw some extra N on, and plant your tomatoes an inch apart and they'll thrive because they're LOTS of nutrients down there.'

    That is something I wouldn't want to do for various reasons, but mainly because it would be a monoculture. They wouldn't be helping each other but hindering each other.

    However, in the case of a living mulch, I might choose dwarf beans among the tomatoes. (Or tall beans. I enjoy experiments.) Or clover. Or lucerne (alfapha) if I felt like it. Why not? Even just so that I could chop it down from time to time and add it to my compost heap and heating it up.

  • 10 years ago

    this has been an interesting thread for us northerners (given also that I may move to a much warmer climate in the medium term). If I were to garden in a hot and dry area, I would set up windbreaks if needed, but I would bunch my plants as much as possible. It is not even a matter of living or dead mulch, but rather to create a microclimate that is more beneficial to plants. More humidity, cooler soil, and cooler air in the immediate surroundings of the plant.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, as I said, the problem with bunching is competition, and competition is the reason why plants are supposed to be grown so far apart. You plant things close together and they just don't do as well individually as they would if they were farther apart. That's a fact. I guess you can make up excuses for that fact, but nutrient competition is the most sensible explanation. Mainly nitrogen, I would expect. Certainly you're more likely to get away with closer spacing if your soil is excellent. It's a strategy that needs careful management. It helps to have big mature plants that naturally shade things. But that's not possible if you're trying to do starts in midsummer for what we call the "second season". In fact, we really have three seasons. Two in the summer, and one in the winter.

    If you don't want to do syringing, I think that something that shades the soil but not the plant is what you're looking for. Maybe a foot off the ground. That will be inconvenient if you water from above, however.

    No offense, but northern gardeners largely don't have a clue about southern gardening. I've been in both places. When I moved down here I had to throw away more than half of what I had learned. Took years to figure it out. There are advantages and disadvantages.

  • 10 years ago

    It occurs to me that commercial misters could be a useful tool in this regard for garden "syringing". They can cover a large area, such as a porch, with flow rates of less than a gallon per hour. Maybe turn it on for a few minutes every half hour in the mid-afternoon. They are documented as lowering the air temperature by 10-35F. Many of these work off of line pressure, so you just need a good quality hose and a timer. Most cheap water timers just do one on/off cycle per day, so you might need something a bit fancier.

    These commercial misters are regularly used to cool people (e.g. "patio misters") and livestock. Home Depot and Lowes have simple and relatively inexpensive setups.

    Has anyone used these for relieving fiercely hot weather stresses in gardening? I'm pretty sure these systems are often installed in greenhouses for precisely this purpose - "humidification fans".

  • 10 years ago

    I cannot believe people are still arguing this. Syringing is a settled fact and has been around for a long time. You cannot argue against it based on science or practice. I'm not saying everyone should utilize it - not all plants need it, not all climates respond well, no research on increased yields, time commitment - but it works.


    And no it's not huge waste of water. We are talking about misting the mulch, not a soil drench. It uses way less water than the amount your living mulch is "wasteing". And I'm not hating on living mulch if that is your thing.


    Kudos to Dan for figuring it out on his own, most ppl only know of it from reading about it.

  • 10 years ago

    Hehe, I would have to agree with "No offense, but northern gardeners largely don't have a clue about southern gardening". I learned to garden in northern Ohio from my Grandpa. There, you could just drop seeds/transplants into the dirt and bounty would spring forth.

    I had to relearn everything here in southern California, and sometimes it feels like it's less growing plants than coaxing and wheedling them into doing what they're supposed to.

    glib and tete a tete, all your ideas sound great in theory. They really do. In reality, windbreaks do nothing to create micro climates when you have bouts of hot, furnace like winds that average 40 mph and the real temperature - not the apparent temperature - is already into triple digits. You might create a decent windbreak with a fairly high wall of some sort, but then you've built yourself a giant solar powered pizza oven, great for baking plants too. Or when your soil in summer generally has the dampness and consistency of cured concrete except where you've been adding water, and you can't water your entire garden - just spot watering/drip irrigating - because you're in a drought and it is actually illegal and you can be fined if caught watering on days/times you're not allowed to, or longer than the stipulated amount of time, or end up with a $400 water bill. It normally doesn't rain here from around February through November, so your water input is it, period. You're not going to waste water trying to keep living mulch alive to just shade your crop plants...every drop is vital for the things you are actually trying to grow. And most likely your soil is generally crap because if we didn't have things like aqueducts this place would actually be a desert, so nutrient competition is a real concern, even when you're been building your soil for years (insert long explanation about moisture making nutrients available in limited areas).

    It's a different style of gardening with completely different issues and rewards, that's for sure.

  • 10 years ago

    I think the lesson here is that folks who do vegetable gardening don't talk much to those who do golf course maintenance. Looking back in the archives here, syringing is referred to very occasionally, but without explanation. The term "syringing" is pretty unexplanatory. You don't use syringes to do it. It has been reflexively dismissed here as contributing to fungal infections. That's nonsense, if used for this purpose. The foliage will dry out quickly in the fierce heat. Thank you again for bringing it up in this context.

    One would think that this would be especially straightforward for garden plumbers who like to do drip systems.