Software
Houzz Logo Print
emma_taylor1224

Help me shop for a conifer please

Zone 5, 30 miles SW of Chicago. I want a pyramidal shaped conifer for full sun, no size limitation. Clay soil. Leaning toward Norway Spruce or a fir?. Also, is it OK to plant this fall or better to wait for next spring. Thanks.


Comments (16)

  • 10 years ago

    early fall would be great ... or after ground thaw in spring.. april ...


    are you willing to mail order a prime specimen ... or willing to drive across Chi. and visit a place for some great ideas??? .. see link ... best afternoon you could ever spend .. even if you dont buy anything .... i would call ahead.. and make an apptmnt for a guided tour ...


    the two options you mention sound like bigboxstore options ... blehhhh ... lol ...


    btw.. they make telephone poles out of Norway spruce ... they really are forest trees .. given decades .. unless you find some dwarfer variety ...


    see potential here:

    https://www.google.com/search?q=Picea+abies&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwja1pK_kY_OAhVn7YMKHQsUA2wQ_AUICCgB&biw=951&bih=745&dpr=0.9


    good luck


    ken





    http://www.richsfoxwillowpines.com/

  • 10 years ago

    Google Metasequoia then Metasequoia Ogon. A friend ofbmine in Chicago has two species trees I gave him which are growing well. I wouldn't think they would have 100 foot potential up north but they seem to grow well.

  • 10 years ago

    If you've got the time, visit The Morton Arboretum, it shouldn't be too far from you. They've got a great collection of mature conifers, including fir, and see what suits your fancy... In another 4-6 weeks it will be fall planting time in Chicagoland.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the tips. I checked the Metasequoia; not really the look I have in mind.


  • 10 years ago

    How about Picea engelmanii 'Bush's Lace'. It's one of my favorites and grows quite fast. It's a weeper with a very strong central leader so you won't have to stake it unless it's a young graft.

    Here's mine

  • 10 years ago

    Beauty, Garen.

    Gracie, I live in the same climate as you. I really like my Canaan firs and Serbian spruces.

    Abies balsamea var. phanerolepis

    Picea omorika

    You can't go wrong with these.

    Dax

    gracie01 zone5 SW of Chicago thanked gardener365
  • 10 years ago

    What is the purpose for this tree? Shade, specimen, privacy?

    Why just one?

    Mike

  • 10 years ago

    miketann, speciman for front yard.


  • 10 years ago

    Probably the best price you'll find for a Serbian spruce:

    Evergreen Plant Nursery: Picea omorika 2-gallon

    They have 1-gallons also for 5.95.

    I've bought many trees from them and they are of good quality roots and the trees themselves. They have many other spruces for the same price. They lack in firs though. Abies koreana is choice and they sell them but it's going to be extremely slow to grow. And you don't want to plant Douglas fir which is the only other fir (not true fir) they offer.

    Dax

    gracie01 zone5 SW of Chicago thanked gardener365
  • 10 years ago

    dax , why not douglas in north IL. ?

    ron

  • 10 years ago

    Garen, your 'Bush's Lace' looks almost identical to mine. Nice conifer!

    Dax, I couldn't agree more with your Korean Fir and Serbian Spruce suggestions. The only difference I might have would be growth rate of the Korean Fir. Following the disastrous winter of '13-'14, this seedling has grown 4'. It's not super fast, but not exactly slow either.

  • 10 years ago

    Ron, needle cast.

    Bob, I've never heard of a Korean fir growing that much. That's interesting to me. I gave a 1-gallon (beautiful seedling) to a friend in WI with wonderful, rich, black-loam; this was I'd say five-years ago and she told me it "has really grown." Apparently, from a foot to now 2.5' she 'approaching 3''. I thought that was a ton considering the first 4-5 years trees put a lot of energy into the roots - as their priority.

    Here, on loamy clay after 8-years I have Nordmann firs now 3' tall or 3.5' I'd guess. I also have Canaan firs going on 10-12'; Serbian spruces going on 9'; These all being from a 12=16" bare-root seedling pl. 2008.

    What size root-system was your Korean fir and what year planted?

    Dax

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    It was planted spring of 2013 from either a #7 or #10 pot. Oregon Pride was the grower and it was very, very healthy. I couldn't believe my good luck when I ran across it at a nursery in Duluth, MN. BTW, you can see where it suffered winter damage above the snow line that first year. The dead needles are still hanging on. Does Korean Fir ever lose its dead needles?

    This has been a exceptional year for firs, with most (fraseri, concolor, and koreana) putting on 20"-28" vertical growth.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Gracie , here is a nice one,,,picea abies 'argenteospica'

    medium to large,,, imagine dark green , couple weeks in spring ,,POW

    Ron

    this is just a small guy,,,available from conifer kingdom

    gracie01 zone5 SW of Chicago thanked plantkiller_il_5
  • 10 years ago

    other specimen worthy,,,all norways

    Perrys gold

    a few other spring flush ones I can't remember

    RED spring flush,,,Rydal , Rubra spicata

    ron

    gracie01 zone5 SW of Chicago thanked plantkiller_il_5