Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_28126706

Down to Trane and AS but...

10 years ago

We are planning our new home build and down either a Trane OR AS unit. While the variable speed units MAY sound nice, I am of the thought after speaking with a few local installers to avoid the units as some can be very very fickle. Not to mention, parts cost and availability. Chances of finding a part for an AS single stage 16 SEER unit on a Friday morning at 10 are reasonably good. However, finding a part for a more elaborate variable speed unit that is in stock, well maybe not so much. My thought is keep it simple and efficient. One COSTLY out of warranty repair on a variable speed unit would most likely be COSTLY and soon make the unit be not so favorable. A friend put something similar in along with a heat recovery unit for free hotwater and is pleased as pie. Thoughts ? House is not overly large at about 2,600 sq ft under air and a 4/2.

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago

    What is your location?...when you refer to variable speed, are you speaking about furnaces or the new inverter type outside condensers. It is clear the top end HVAC market is moving in that direction. And of course that comes with a price. What you get is comfort and while SEER is increased, you can not put the numbers to the paper as far as a reasonable justifiable payback. It just won't happen. Most consumers and dealers believe the sweet spot for AC is now 15-16 SEER. I don't buy into your statement about the parts availability issue on higher end HVAC. It is true field history is small on these type condensers as far as reliability and breakdowns. There were some documented cases of noise issues as well but I believe this has been resolved. As with any new technology that is rolled out into the market, you can expect some start up problems.

    IMO


  • 10 years ago

    Thanks, Pensacola, FL. and I am focusing my comments on the AC side of the unit. Furnace will be gas. Last but not least, I would think that if a tech is not trained properly aka gone to school on these new "hi tech units", I'd be off to a bad bad start.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Most parts for Trane or American Standard are unit specific, like fan motors as an example.

    Most Dealers for Trane or Am Stnd. either one do not stock these specific motors on trucks because they cost a premium. Many other major name brands do the same thing such as Carrier as well as Lennox.

    Why do you suppose? I'll tell you why... the manufacturer's want the part money when the unit breaks and because the motors are unit specific they can charge whatever they want for those parts.

    Major name brands are nothing special, they break down just as much as anything else out there.

    So when the unit breaks down and it will, pray that the distributor has stocked the part you need otherwise you'll sweat it out for a while.

    User thanked Austin Air Companie
  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the continued input and I have been through the sweat it out LOL. July 4th in Fort Lauderdale FL. HOT is not the word, BRUTAL pretty much covers it.

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Just realize a 'new home build' is considerably different than hiring a 'retro fit HVAC contractor'. New home builders are builders they typically are not in the business of 'servicing'. So when the new home build unit breaks it's typically not long after that 1 year in most cases (after the house was built) that you'll be looking for a new HVAC contractor.

    The reason for this is primarily construction companies operate on razor thin margins, which is why when housing starts diminish a good amount of them fail and blow away with the wind.

    Construction companies are not known for 'servicing' they are known for building.

    There's a popular one in my area that brags about 100,000 systems installed. However, they don't brag about serving those customer needs after the fact. There is always two sides to every coin. Well, unless you're a magician.

    Quantity rarely means Quality.