Software
Houzz Logo Print
jay6a

Cast your votes aside.

10 years ago

You know,when the tip plant scientists in the world(the scientists that give all plants their Latin names),when they get.together to identify a new species,and they have a differing of opinions do you think they take a vote on it and that the majority wins?No,they keep on doing more DNA tests on it and scrutinizing the results(no matter how long it takes) until they reach a unanimous decision that the plant is undoubtedly one thing and one thing only.Imagine what darkness we would all be walking in if they did use the voting method? Shouldn't us common folk here on GW try to aspire to the same goal? Regular people getting together and voting is why we have so much confusion with common names.Several unrelated plants from different families end up being known by the same common name like for example stinging nettle and moss rose. I find it a bit annoying when I'm in a creative discussion with other members and people observing from the sidelines,who aren't contributing, chime in with "I vote this plant".Most of the time those three words is all they say.What is that? A hiccup?They could at least write a couple lines explaining why they feel that way.Then at least their comment might be more interesting and not a complete waste of time reading.I think saying you agree with someone is fine because it tells us you have the same views as the person you're agreeing with.When I'm having an enjoyable discussion and you chime in with that "I vote" one liner it feels like you impatiently want to rush and bring an abrupt end to a creative discussion.It's like"Let's stop right now and take a vote so we can close this thread and move to the next post and cast our vote over there".There are some serious plant lovers on here who thirst for knowledge and you voters are like pesky gnats buzzing in the faces of them while they're sitting at the picnic table of creative discussion.And sick as it is. I think some members are voting to show favoritism to members they like,andto cast shade and uncertainty on members they don't like.That kind of behavior has no place on this site.We should all be above that.You can go to facebook and twitter if you enjoy taking cyber digs at other people.Write something with substance or don't write anything at all

Comments (11)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    already posted this.

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/4056812/cast-your-votes-aside?n=1

    Edited to add that it's your post - you posted the same thing twice.

  • 10 years ago

    I had no idea anyone posted about it before.Well it's nice knowing there are others.People are still doing it so either they didn't read yours or it went right over their heads.

  • 10 years ago

    Erm... I occasionally use "My vote goes for X", when a number of people disagree on the identification. The said vote is an opinion. It is based on factors already discussed earlier in the thread and is directed at the plant, and not other posters. >_>' I think you're overthinking it, dude.

  • 10 years ago

    I had no idea anyone posted about it before.Well it's nice knowing there are others.


    ==>> uhmmm.. the other post is also under your name ...

  • 10 years ago

    Favoritism & digs & pesky gnats? Please don't go there. It's a friendly plant forum where anyone/all are welcome. The purpose of this forum has never been to invent plant names, just to attempt to match pics with the correct botanical name. Common names are optional because most plants have many of those. Many have an interesting story behind them. It's not a competition or popularity contest unless one is having their own internal one.

    There are other forums if one decides to seek a more in-depth discussion about a particular plant or cultivating it in a particular area/climate/circumstance.

    It's customary to include a question mark when one isn't sure, or suggest comparing. Really a gray area, if somebody thinks they know and they are wrong, they still thought they knew, and I assume all responses are given in the spirit of trying to help. If you read the responses that way, they're all pleasant. Exploring similar plants from close-but-not-quite-a-match suggestions is often fun too. I read as many as time will allow, and learn a LOT here.

  • 10 years ago

    There's been many times I thought for sure I was right when I was dead wrong.Those are the most fun because I always learn something from it.you can pretend none of those negative things exist here,but that doesn't make it so.Voting is useless,it adds nothing,just a waste of time."I vote this" sounds like something Hattie Canfield would have said,at the church plant sale,in Iowa,one hundred and fifty years ago. To deadhead or not to deadhead.What's more beautiful?Having a longer season of colorful zinnias and tithonias or watching the goldfinches forage through the flowers I haven't removed? I prefer the goldfinches.Ok,so for a question like that a vote could be fun,but when it comes to positively identifying a plant it doesn't really help the process along,does it???

  • 10 years ago

    I think many people underthinking it.Too much for you to handle? I'm already beginning to see the wheat being separated from the chaff in the responses.The true colors are coming out.

  • 10 years ago

    Jay, what the H-E-doubletoothpicks are you talking about??

  • 10 years ago

    Jay, check that wheat you've separated. It may contain ergot. This is a whole lot of ado about nothing.

    "There's been many times I thought for sure I was right when I was dead wrong.Those are the most fun..."

    Are you having fun now?

    Besides, it's an election year and I want to vote early and often.

    tj

  • 10 years ago

    I am working in Pathology lab, doing diagnostic chores every single day, identifying disease under microscope, doing DNA, RNA stuffs, whenever in doubt I asked colleague opinions, some times their responds were just simply like "voting", but it did helps. Really!

    I love this forum, a mixture of beginner and pro, a mix of acid-science and free spirit just like gardening, when brain gets overheated working in lab, its relaxing reading post, refreshing and ready again to work. if this becoming seriously scientific, it wont be so much fun. Please be patient Jay, then it will be fun, at least it works for me.