Love the carerra marble - subway style.

Yeah we don't mind the current backsplash but we really do not like what's behind the stove.

White subway tiles might look too stark against your cream/off white cabinets and granite. I would use a solid subway tile in a light taupe or tan from your countertop.

Something like this maybe?

That tile you found above is gorgeous.

I loved this one!

Thanks everyone! You have all been so helpful. Really, really appreciate it!

WS granite tops is that a picture of our counters with the new backsplash? Pretty amazing, thank you! I like it and now I'm torn on whether to go with the cream subway tile or the glass cream subway tile.

Yes, its your picture! I did a quick collage on Photoshop so you could visualize it.