Software
Houzz Logo Print
heruga

Pinus thunbergii 'Thunderhead' size control

10 years ago

I've heard that they can get up to 10 feet tall and 15 feet
wide but is this size controllable by regular candle pruning? I have one thats
about 4 feet tall and like 3 feet wide right now. It was planted in late may.
Its planted in next to my front door steps and has like 3 feet space from the
trunk of the pine to the steps. I also have dwarf garden junipers planted next
to it. I really don't want to get 15 feet wide as I have no space for that. Ideally, I would want it to be like 8 feet tall and width maybe 5 feet. So 2 main questions:

1)Is this possible with regular pruning?

2)Would I have to move my garden juniper thats on the left?

Some extra info: This pine was bought and planted in burlap form and planted in late May.I live in northern NJ in zone 7a and it is in full sun. Here is a pic.

Comments (27)

  • 10 years ago

    20' by 20' in time is more likely so I am not at all sure this is sited well. Yes, you can keep growth restrained by candling but I doubt you will be able to maintain it successfully at a size that will fit in that particular space.

  • 10 years ago

    Well do you know what would happen if I keep it there? I really don't want to move it because I have no other area in my yard where I can plant this. Plus it was expensive and I dont want to have to risk damaging the roots when transplanting and the tree was very very heavy and it took me hours to plant this so I don't want to have to go through that again. I always heard they were dwarfs but all of a sudden I see these things in the internet saying they grow 20 feet..

  • 10 years ago

    You're not the only one with a thunderhead that needs to be replanted but won't.

  • 10 years ago

    Oh may I ask where your thunderhead is planted? And how big is it currently?

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    These things get huge and ungainly. Left unpruned they generally do not make good focal point specimens. I have two that are pruned yearly by an aesthetic pruner. He takes off enormous amounts - the pile on the ground is often as big as the tree! You could simply candle it but i don't think you'll be happy with the shape. I really don't understand why this cultivar is offered for sale so widely; it's really not suited for most people's gardens. Easy to fall in love with those deep green needles, though!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Oh and Heruga - dwarf doesn't mean small, it just means that it grows more slowly than the species, which is an enormous tree.

  • 10 years ago

    just look at last springs growth ... no scale in pic ... but it looks 6 to 9 inches.. yes???


    as they were extending ... perhaps you should have pruned the bud ... at 2 or 3 inches ...


    timing is IMPERATIVE.... so it will set buds on what you left there ..


    i have never done it ... so thats all i can add ... but you will become an experienced pruner ....


    ANYTHING else you add.. will have to be a mini ..


    ken

  • 10 years ago

    You could probably get away with moving it out diagonally another 4 ft

    get rid of the stone ,, just mulch

    I know it's heavy , but , YOU CAN DO IT !

    ron

  • 10 years ago

    I absolutely love this cultivar with its long white candles against the dark billowy green needles. I'm with Ron, it should be moved out quite a bit but it's hard to tell how it will look on your siting without being there. If you don't want to move it then treat it like a giant bonsai, pruning the branches that are growing towards the house when needed and directing the growth away from the house. Chop them off and have fun with shaping it. Look into the art of Niwaki. With the right branch pruning it could make a stunning specimen. If that doesn't strike your fancy then let it grow, enjoy it until it gets too big, and cut it down to replace it with something else when the time comes. =)

  • 10 years ago

    Well I really don't plan on moving it and yes I LOVE bonsai. But I heard you can't really get into it unless you're experienced or else you're gonna be killing the plant without proper techniques.

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Niwaki is a great suggestion. You can't hurt this thing; practice on it and learn how to shape it the way you want it.

  • 10 years ago

    Proper root trimming and keeping a bonsai alive in a shallow pot is indeed something that can require a little bit more know how but a larger tree that is in the ground with an established root system is something you can have fun with without worry.

    Since your tree is newly planted you will want to give it some time to settle in before you do any major pruning. After it has had time to acclimate next year you can start with some small pruning, selecting a few branches here and there to start shaping it, anticipating the future growth of the branches left. After it has been in the ground for a few years and has a good root system it is safe to go crazy and take off a large amount if you like. Just leave enough branches so that it can still make food for itself. Like Sara (Form and Foliage) said, her pruner takes off enormous amounts and they visually benefit from it. Just make sure your pruning sheers are sharp and sterilized before cutting.

    For inspiration Google Niwaki techniques and look at some of the photos. You'll find that the majority of them are Japanese black pine (Pinus thunbergii) like yours. Start small until you feel comfortable with your shaping. Revealing the inner branching structure can look realy nice. I also enjoy the minimally pruned dense billowy green cloud look too. Whatever floats your boat.

  • 10 years ago

    Garen Rees's advice was spot on! You really can have fun with it. I butchered one when I was learning to prune and after two years you wouldn't have known that it had happened. Now this is right by your house so you may want to take it a little slow so that you don't have an eyesore right there, but you get the idea. You might practice on the backside. (fyi I have no idea why sometimes I come up as me and sometimes as Form and Foliage, which is my blog. I have tried to figure it out by logging out and logging back in again, but it seems to have a mind of its own...)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I've seen (one and only one instance of) these "out of control" at about 25' tall and 15-20' wide. One house I drive by fairly often has a few of them that are huge(I'll try to remember to take a pic next time). This one was planted too close to a pyramidal white pine on the left, a Baker Colorado blue spruce on the right, and rose of Sharon in the back.

  • 10 years ago

    This one was planted too close to everything. Then the volunteer American basswood came along(it has been pruned pretty good). This is the latest(earliest?) in the season I've planted something. January 12th, 2014. I remember using the shovel as a chisel. This poor thing has very little going for it as it is not in a very sunny location at all (and the obvious). While it isn't thriving it is doing ok.

  • 10 years ago

    Oh wow so I guess pruning can be done to prevent it from becoming this monster. Do you plan on moving it or are you gonna let it stay there?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This one was planted too close to a volunteer pin oak(about three feet back from back right of thunderhead). Then I added a white pine, Fat Albert blue spruce, and globe blue spruce. Then a couple volunteer oaks came along in front of the thunderhead. There is other stuff I need to replant, will probably end up replanting some of this stuff too. Now that my trees are past the 2+\- years of settling in I am starting to see significant growth on many.

  • 10 years ago

    This one was planted too close to the house. And I planted the mum too close to it.

  • 10 years ago

    Lol I have mums in the same bed as my thunderhead too as you can see in my pic. Guess I'm not the only planting this giant too close to anything

  • 10 years ago

    I'm a little embarrassed that I planted so close but live and learn. I'm planted out so I will have to apply this knowledge to my future dwarf conifers lol.

    By the way I did have one thunderhead that did not survive. My land is very wet and I did not build a mound high enough for it.

  • 10 years ago

    Pete, that's a lot of thunderheads. I like them quite a bit too. In fact I baught one for my neighbors yard lol.

    Thanks for all the photos. I would definitely like to see the huge ones you mentioned whenever you get the time.

    Here's mine this Spring. Planted it too close to the fence when it was a tiny one year graft so I have been pruning the backside. =)

  • 10 years ago

    Your weeping larch looks real nice Garen as does the thunderhead and everything else. I planted one (larch)this spring and while I think it will make it long term (showing new growth) it is definitely ragged looking and brown in more places than I would like to see.

    Lolol I'm not the only one who plants in neighbor's yards. I've got a 980 foot property line and have planted about 20 conifers (so far, hardly done) on one of my neighbors property. My number one goal with my land (and hers lol) is "dense conifer 'forest'" in 40 years, the bigger and taller the "forest", the better. She loves it as she's also very into gardening and trees/conifers. Free trees, wish I could get some.

  • 10 years ago

    Here's my Thunderhead Pine. It's approximately 10 years old.

  • 10 years ago

    Hidden in there lies....



  • 10 years ago

  • 10 years ago

    Those look fantastic. I even like them big. It's like a small Thunderhead forest. Thanks Pete! I really appreciate you taking the time. They just need a few brighter conifers or companion plants to brighten things up and add contrast.