Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_21934719

An early Fall?

10 years ago

Anyone else noticing leaves falling prematurely due to heat and drought. I am south of the more severe drought conditions in New England (or easter LI), but I am raking up leaves of Swamp/Pin Oak and American Elm.

Comments (66)

  • 10 years ago

    The big problem with pin oak is that it wants to look like a large shrub. If you have time to periodically perform crown raising they can be a nice landscape specimen. I think nuttal oak is a better alternative, no extensive/routine pruning must be performed on it.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree Logan. The lower branches always bow down. I have had to prune a few tiers of nuttall's oak branches this summer but eventually it will stop the need to be pruned soon. I have several in a row that I do need to limb up, but, nowhere near the need of Pin oak.

  • 10 years ago

    subtropix, some chance of tropical moisture from a Gulf coast storm drifting northeast from Louisiana in about a week, but way too far off to be sure.

  • 10 years ago

    poaky, my pin oak (at least I think it's pin oak), is tall. the lowest branches are two stories above ground so not a problem walking into them.

    In my previous house, there was an ENORMOUS one on the property adjacent to mine. People would sit at the patio table, notice the truck and start to look up, and up, and up. As they looked higher, I could see the facial expression subtly change as they got to the top of the tree canopy. The old lady that lived there did not wanna pay $2,000 to have it removed. Then a storm came along and sent a single massive branch into my roof. You would have thought it was a plane crash; she ended up having an arborist cut the most vulnerable branches, and I moved.

    Yes, still hoping for some rain. Hopefully, whatever form the storm does take it will go up east of Louisiana and let the land down there dry up some. I know they were/are predicting an active season but seems strangely quiet so far.

    P.S., Fall?! Good one.

    We are back to the mid 90's tomorrow and the start of another week long heat wave.

  • 10 years ago

    It's been in the upper 90s here as well. Not looking good for my new perennial hibiscus plant. Didn't have time to water for the past 2 days.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Subtropix, it could've been a pin, but, I've only seen one with anything near enourmous branches. And they really weren't enourmous. Pin oak branches tend to be the T. Rex arms of the oak branch world, well, they get long bit thin. But, maybe it was an exceptional old Pin oak. Logan and anyone else, we are 92F right now. The week before last week the weather guy said we would likely not get any more 90's until next year. It was 98F earlier, it's 6 PM now. If your is a pin Subtropix, it will always have it's lower branches downward even if the trunk is pruned up pretty darned high, even 30 feet. The branches usually don't fall when dead they just hang on and look ugly because they are usually small and thin. There was a big deal made when one of the branches fell off of a Pin oak at Graceland sometime during Elvis's funeral, because they usually don't fall. Something I read in one of my many tree related books. Later

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Poaky, I am almost POSITIVE it IS a Pin Oak. I will post pictures of the leaves and acorns as they FALL. Yes, the lower branches grow down, but I never pruned it up..., it's just old!

    P.S., We hear NOTHING in the news about DROUGHT, but as soon as Labor Day is over, that is all the news that there will be. God forbid it should actually rain when someone has off from work and the beach beckons.

  • 10 years ago

    Okay, I'm sorry, there is one tree that i think is a Pin oak, and it has some fairly big limbs. It's at a one time nunnery near me. There is a nursing home there I used to work at. And we used to go on break outside and sit. There was another building across from where we sat and there was a Gingko tree, a Pin oak (pretty sure) and I think a maple, other trees. The place is full of trees, most oaks are red oaks though. And I would stare at that tree alot. I can easily go see it any time. I may go just to see if I can iD what kinda oak it is for sure. Sub just post a pic of the tree anytime. The acorns will be foreign to me anyway, you can ID any of that as good as I can anyways.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Poaky,

    This center tree is my Pin Oak (I think). The tree's canopy opens up about two

    stories above ground.

    P.S., Here is an article about the 'Extreme' drought in the Boston area.

    Not quite as bad here, though it has been hotter, but drying out once again real fast.

    http://boston.cbslocal.com/2016/08/29/massachusetts-extreme-drought-trees-eversource/

  • 10 years ago

    i am fighting the urge to put out scarecrows and styrofoam pumpkins.

  • 10 years ago

    Interesting thing about pin oak, one reads and hears about the low branching habit and the issues with mowing beneath one. Just about all the images of this tree one sees are of juvenile trees. An adult or mature pin oak looks nothing like a youngster, except for the foliage. Much like sweetgum, juvenile trees have a single leader, are low branched, and shaped like a conifer. As the tree matures, it loses its conifer shape and drooping lower branches and the crown divides and becomes round headed. These trees can become huge, but are not often seen at that size. Why that is I'm not sure, it could be that homeowners remove them, trees on basic sites die from chlorosis early, or maybe are destroyed in storms, they aren't the strongest of the oaks. Around here bacterial leaf scorch is playing hob with them.

  • 10 years ago

    The Pin at the nunnery (I think it's a Pin) has a different shape than the younger ones. I need my 2 Pins limbed up again. I will try and get a pic of that tree old (maybe) Pin oak. Subtr. Nice tree, do you have any idea on the age?

  • 10 years ago

    Subtropix, I have posted pix of the Pin oak at the nunnery, just search on the GW tree forum, it will say so in the title. If you don't find it, I'll post the pics here. Well, I'll just post them here now. Pin oak

  • 10 years ago

    Another pic Pin oak limb

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Oddly, m significant other was commenting on this recently. Lots of trees here are turning brown and losing leaves.


    kentrees, could it just be that pin oak did not be me a really popular landscape tree until relatively recently? I find urban and suburban forestry seems to have fads that cause distinct generations...,you rarely see a young catalpa planted in a yard or as a street tree around here, but rarely see an old ginkgo.

    Out of curiosity, what are the strongest oaks?

  • 10 years ago

    Living in CT the first half of my life, pin oak was about the only oak available at nurseries and garden centers, there were no box stores back in the dark ages. The story was that pin oaks transplanted easily and grew rapidly, the other oaks did not and were not grown. They were planted quite extensively, but even then there weren't many large old ones. I personally believe that pin oaks are subject to more ills than the rest of their clan, and are relatively weak wooded and short lived, 100 years or so of useful life. Here in TN, they are currently under heavy attack by bacterial leaf scorch.

    The shade tree of choice back then was sugar maple, the reds- freeman hybrids just beginning to come on the scene.

    The strongest oaks in my opinion are the white oaks, world wide.

  • 10 years ago

    I think Q.Virginiana is the strongest oak, one of the ships made from it's wood was called "old ironsides", cannonballs bounced off of it.

  • 10 years ago

    I have never seen a Q. Virginiana in person

  • 10 years ago

    I KNOW they are in NC, but may be only near the coast. For the north Q.Alba and Burr oak, Swamp white oak etc. I just remember hearing about "old Ironsides" ship made from Live oak wood, and the cannonballs bouncing off, so figured it must be the strongest oak wood. The British whose ships were made of English oak, were surprised to see that.

  • 10 years ago

    I was sure they are here somewhere. Just not in my area, never seen one in person. Live oak is a tough tree.

  • 10 years ago

    Both English oak, Q. robur, and live oak, Q. virginiana, are white oaks.

  • 10 years ago

    Yeppur.

  • 10 years ago

    Logan, you have to see a Quercus Virginiana tree in person at some point in your life before you die. And since they are so damn close to you. The sooner the better. They are in Williamsburg, Va, so surely you can grow one in NC!

  • 10 years ago

    While mowing today I saw that Q.Lyrata, Q,Rubra, London plane tree, Nuttall's oak and possibly others are shedding their leaves. Also my dying Peach tree. My Hazelnut bushes are not in very good shape this year anyways, I have 2 of them.

  • 10 years ago

    I did happen to stumble upon 2 live oak at a historic home in the area. They were stunning in the front yard! Imagine 2 live oak in front of a large historic home with japanses maples and crepe myrtles planted underneath. They allowed me to collect some acorns. Good riddance silver maples!

  • 10 years ago

    Great Logan, even better that they're free.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes! They can be extremely expensive.

  • 10 years ago

    Saw that here too. Late August and September until this week were quite warm and dry.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    In SE PA and NE MD, the main ones I'm seeing are Tulip trees. About 10-20% of their canopy is turning bright yellow, early. Often only 1 or 2 leaves on a branch, so it gives the tree an odd variegated or spotted look.

  • 10 years ago

    I raked leaves yesterday. Acer saccharinum, cornus florida, and liquidambar styracflua are dropping leaves.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm starting to see true fall colors, not caused by drought. Not much yet though, most trees are still going strong

  • 10 years ago

    Happy Autumnal Equinox everyone in the Northern Hemisphere. I guess cherry trees are blooming in the Southern Hemisphere which is hard for me to picture. Have you been able to see the ringed planet? I didn't.


    Pretty much an average first day of fall here. 'Meader' persimmon is ripe and ready to eat, don't have to wait for frost for this one.

  • 10 years ago

    Funny reviewing this thread, noticed Logan mentioning the ground in his NC area being covered with silver maple leaves....on Aug. 24. Here, many hundreds of miles to the north, silver maples have not even begun to change to fall color. I believe a great deal of the "coloration" being discussed in this thread is the result of a long, hot and very dry summer across a big chunk of central, western, and eastern N. America. Up here in the GreatLakes, it's been anything but dry, although there were a couple typical dry weeks or two during the summer. We just got another couple inches of rain overnight. It's real green up this way, yet parched and brown across vast areas, mostly to our south.

  • 10 years ago

    I've seen a few Silver Maple crimpled leaves from the neighbors trees, several yellow leaves from my slowly dying Peach tree, a few burgundy leaves from 1 of my Pin oaks, some of my Q. Albas are kinda chloroticly green and yellow, as they've been since I sprinkled seaweed powder around them about 5 years ago. One tree more than the other. The older the tree gets the fewer leaves get this chlorotic crappy leaf show in fall. I know as the fall gets further along my Pin oak at the rear of the yard will get more burgundy leaves on it, my Shumard, IF I rememeber right gets a nice red color, well, I'll try and get pics as these trees actually get these colors.

  • 10 years ago

    Here black gums are putting out new growth, while the older leaves are turning.

  • 10 years ago

    I have a feeling the Northeast drought of 2016 is about to end big time.

  • 10 years ago

    subtropix, there's a front that'll become stationary along the east coast and generate a few weak lows, but w/the ocean nearly at summer temps should generate good rain. Problematic for it to get west into my interior region, tho.


    Again, Sept rain varies wildly.

  • 10 years ago

    Y'all can take some of our precipitation! We had 2" of rain last Tuesday and then a whopping 7" on Wednesday, which is a major weather event for this part of the country. These amounts may not be all that unusual for the S/SE part of US, but up here it creates serious problems. We could use a long drying out period.

  • 10 years ago

    I'll take some rain, we had rain last week but need more, we're short a few inches this year.

  • 10 years ago

    maackia, some research suggests that with the new paradigm of greater atmospheric moisture that has unfolded as the globe heats up, northern and western Wisconsin could be one of the areas that gets quite a bit wetter. Sure has been lately. Sheesh. 12 inches of rain overnight washing out the harbors on Lake Superior and US Hwy 2! We're nice and moist over here on the east side of the state but man, you guys have been soaked all year like that.

  • 10 years ago

    Yeah, these single event rainfalls are getting to be a real problem. I hope the research is wrong and we get back to normalcy. It would be a tough blow if these excessive rains become the norm along with the polar vortex. Flood-prone summers and arctic-like winters: Who wouldn't want to live here?!

  • 10 years ago

    Heh, let's face it, each year, usually some time in March, don't all of us sconnies start to wonder why we still live here? I know why though-it's called summer. We have the nicest summers of anywhere in the world I think. Sure, it gets hot and humid up here, but we're not stuck in it for the duration the way say, Georgia or Texas would be. And it's green here, not parched and brown. Stuff grows in a place like Wisconsin, where half the year's precipitation is locked up in snow and ice, and much of which is then available for the spring flush of growth. Lawns stayed bright green here all summer and usually do. We've got water up here in the Great Lakes and that's not nothing! I've been a lot of places, but having just returned from a long weekend up in this state's Door County, I'm convinced this is paradise. Just hope we don't completely ruin it.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, as far as leaf fall and/or color not much here yet. We still need that rain, but to my happy surprise we've been having cooler weather, so I've been able to go out and water my newer transplants and sow some acorns and put some plant labels where the acorns and smaller seedlings are, and put some containers of mothballs with holes in the top where the deer may stick there noses around them. I hope that keeps them away. I saw 3 babies and their mama eating acorns from my Chestnut oak a couple days ago. I don't mind that at all, just don't eat my trees heads off!

  • 10 years ago

    Only seeing prunus serotina dropping around me, which is normal around here.

  • 10 years ago

    It was 80 degrees F here a few days ago but right now, it's varying shades of gray. with a little gray thrown in for contrast, then a darker gray for contrast coupled with just plain gray! And it is about 60 degrees F now and colder at night. So things are changing yet we hear from the forecasters that this is going to be a long drawn-out fall season, with above-average temps. So, despite this seeming cooldown that is happening, the outlook is for more warmth. And wetness. In a way, I feel we've already added about two weeks to the growing season up here. Each fall just seems warmer and longer than the last. And note; while every other person seems to think weather forecasting is hopelessly flawed, I don't see that at all. These forecasts are getting amazingly accurate, especially the precipitation forecasts. They run these animations showing where the rain will be light, where it will be heavier, and then it unfolds exactly as they said it would. I don't see the inaccuracy of such a chaotic system as our atmosphere...I see amazing strides being made in the art and science of forecasting what the air is going to do. Can you tell us what the atmosphere is going to do tomorrow? I didn't think so!

  • 10 years ago

    Well, we finally got some rain here in SW Pa, quite a bit of it, very much needed. Well, some red oak family oaks are shedding a few leaves here and there. The dying Peach tree is still shedding leaves, there's a tropical storm/hurricane out there in the gulf stream (Mathew) however it;s going to impact the US, who knows?

  • 10 years ago

    Got 2.5" inches in my rain-gauge, up to & over 4" to the west in LaVale (just west of Cumberland against the east side of the Allegany Front), but Hagerstown only got .6", so it was spotty. A good soaking that was needed & may help fall colors coming, but some trees like black walnut have already dropped alot of leaves from autumn anthracnose.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Got over 3 inches, so I am happy about that...however concerned by what seems like the pattern since 2010 for rain to come in huge clumps interspersed with dry periods. Wish there was a plot of rolling standard deviations of rainfall for various stations to confirm this recent trend.

    Looks like this was the first 5 day period in a long while that eastern MA got significant rains:

    http://www.srh.noaa.gov/ridge2/RFC_Precip/


  • 10 years ago

    Sept. precip at my place ended up at 1.05", about 2.50" below average and temps around 4F above average. Many days in the 90's, if not for the lack of rain fine by me. Most lawns are showing moisture stress and have stopped growing, some trees are looking a bit thirsty. Oct. averages driest month here, about 2.50". The color outlook as of now doesn't look good, but that could change with a tropical system or two.

  • 10 years ago

    After nearly a week the upper level low has exitted the Great Lakes, I recieved 3.5 inches since Wednesday, down near Detroit and Windsor double that. Most of the trees here are still green, the autumn blaze maples are about a third of the way through their usual display, everything else except for prunus has yet to turn, any stress from July early August heat and drought is a distant memory.