Software
Houzz Logo Print
sabine_h

Help!!! decision time paralysis... Colors, materials, etc

10 years ago

Hi all, We are DEEP into our kitchen/dining room remodel. The whole living area of our house has changed so much! It went from choppy and boxed in to open and airy! Although my kitchen layout doesn't follow the rules , I really like it compared to how it was before! I wanted a big kitchen with big island and I got it. It is a far cry from the tiny galley kitchen we had before. We have taken does walls, raised a sunken living room, borrowed space from the garaged, built archways, taken out dropped ceilings, etc. All DYI with the exception of electrical and drywall finish. Having a super handy hubby rocks!

Although I started to plan and think about this kitchen years ago, I am having the HARDEST time deciding on my materials. I have commitment issues when it comes to stuff like this, lol!

continued below....


Comments (18)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Continued from above (for some reason I ran out of characters)

    I really need some feedback from all you experts! I need to decide on my materials ASAP!

    My style... I am not into the traditional look- my style is sort of eclectic, I like to incorporate stuff from my travels , etc. I also love the local spanish and beachy styles ( I am in S. California). I want something light & airy but also a pop of color. My walls will be a shade of white. We are planning to do rustic wood beams on the ceilings (same wood as on my mantle). The floor will be the same wood that is in our living room.

    Here is where I am stuck- cabinets and counters! I am doing ikea with Scherr's fronts.AS you can see we have already started to install ikea boxes.

    I originally wanted to do a rustic wood island with a light gray concrete countertop
    . Maybe give the wood some sort of neat patina. Now I am thinking too much wood! Wood on the floors and wood beam ceilings, I need to break it up. My design at the moment includes white perimeter cabinets and then the island in a blue/green ( a color I pulled from my armoire). A walnut countertop on the island. Perimeter counter in a light quartz. The hood over the range (you can see the outline on the wall where it is going. Its 42" wide, we have a new 36" bluestar platinum going in! ) will have the same smooth plaster finish as our fireplace. I will somehow incorporate the carved wood trim (it's a salvage piece from India) on the hood. See the photo below.

    Do you think the green will be overwhelming? The island is big 104x42... What about the walnut counter? Too dark? Will it darken the space or be a nice accent? Any suggestions.

    Thanks!!!!


  • 10 years ago

    I would do the same lighter cabinets for the island. I think then you could go with the wood top on the island. Will there be a sink on the island? The wood could need more care but would add some warmth. I'm not sure long term if all are happy with concrete. There are some quartz options that mimic concrete.

  • 10 years ago

    I like all your choices together very much, but I question the placement of some of them. For instance, I'd incorporate the carved wood on the island -- maybe as an edging around the walnut counter -- instead of on the hood. Spanish-style plaster as on your fireplace and on the hood-to-be is very simple, and something that ornate will look out of place on the hood. Also, as it stands now, the entire perimeter -- walls, hood, counter, cabinets -- will be all-white or nearly all-white while the island will be green and wood. I think this will make island and perimeter look totally unrelated to each other and not in a good way. Think through how you might have some white on the island or some wood or some green on the perimeter. Do you have an awesome green dish you could display on the hood?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I like your materials. Maybe you could look at a cement tile backsplash that would have the green/turquoise color in there. Maybe you could hire a designer for a consultation just to talk about your finishes. Just an idea. I think the carved wood piece could look good on the hood. Maybe you should consider the same material on all counters?? Diff cabs and counters on perimeter and island is a lot...I am sure it can be done well, though... Fantasy brown could look good with all the colors...maybe? Or a quartz.

  • 10 years ago
    Thanks Jilius, that is really helpful.
    I did want to do a backsplash with that same green- I'm looking at Tabarka tile currently. They have some gorgeous patterns... But I wouldn't be able to use those if I used that carved wood on the hood... It would be too busy!
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I would use one countertop for both the perimeter and island to tie it together and that should be the light quartz.

    I like the idea of the blue/green island.

    Ditch the carved wood. Instead use a wood similar to your mantle and beams in that same rustic feel to outline the bottom of your hood. That will help tie it all together.

    Then I like the idea of kelleg69 of maybe tying it all together with a cement tile backsplash that picks up a bit of the white, the brown and the island color. Will be stunning.

  • 10 years ago

    I like Cpartist's suggestions as well. I love the carved wood- but I might find somewhere else in the house to use it... that way I can do a really nice backsplash tile with a pattern... I have been thinking about that, but I just wanted to do something with the darn carved wood.

    I am not sure I want to combine the green with light quartz though... don't really love the combo. I think the green looks great with the walnut and in a larger sample I could see that the walnut has a some variation to it with tones that pick up the floor and the mantle/beams.

    I can't really change the floor color as it is already existing in most of my house.

    I was just looking for photos and found this... similar colors, much nicer house, lol ! [Montecito kitchen with green island[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/montecito-residence-mediterranean-kitchen-santa-barbara-phvw-vp~4267224)

  • 10 years ago

    What about instead of the green with wood top, I do an island sort of like [this?[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/award-winning-lake-travis-residence-rustic-kitchen-austin-phvw-vp~1572906)

  • 10 years ago

    I hoped I explained it well.

  • 10 years ago

    I think it could work with two different counters and cabinets. as shown in the last photo linked. they have related the backsplash to the counter on the island. there does need to be some relationship to make it work and I love the piece of molding from India. I would use it on the hood:) Keep your backsplash simple, use one of tabarkas more faded designs and I think it would be beautiful.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks Isabel! I am going to take all my stuff to the showroom and see what I find. Maybe that will help bring it all together.

    If I recall they have a designer there that helps with tile design, maybe I can get her advice as well.

  • 10 years ago

    When I use something as special as the Indian trim, I try to make it portable. Ya just never know where life will take you! Use the trim for picture frames. It will add a nice contrast and can move wherever you do.

  • 10 years ago

    Nothing constructive to add except you're so lucky to have this fireplace plastered already..I couldn't do the same since against fire code( they had to drywall before plastering-very uneven surface).

    Ah. And Tabarka will look amazing..if you have this option-go for it. They're one of the best. It will tie everything together.

  • 10 years ago

    I noticed in the Montecito kitchen that the wood window frames also helped to pull it all together -- can you copy that element? I think using your carved wood (which is reminiscent of the deep relief carving often found on Spanish colonial furniture) would similarly help connect the darker island to the light perimeter

    I love the green and hope that you keep it.

  • 10 years ago
    I went to the tile store today with all my samples. They had a very extensive display of Tabarka tiles! I ordered a few samples using my colors! Patterns which include the Brown, blue-green, off white etc. They also loaned me a few quartz samples . The designer was super helpful! We both agreed, although the carved wood is gorgeous, a bold pattern backsplash with all my colors with unify and make more of a statement! I will instead use just a plain wood trim , like what is on my fireplace mantle.
  • 10 years ago

    I think your kitchen is going to be absolutely smashing. Please be sure to post once it's finished.