Software
Houzz Logo Print
samhain10

QUESTION ABOUT DAYLILY HYBRIDS

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I posted this over in HYBRIDIZING, but it was suggested I should post over here as well. So here it is:

This spring I planted my first daylily hybrid seeds gathered from
crosses last year. When I planted them out I checked references which
suggested 6-8" would be sufficient spacing for this nursery phase. All
are doing fine, but my question is: will I need to do any transplanting
during the second year to give more space, or will they be OK if I wait
till the 3rd year when I can hope to see blooms and know what may be
culled or given away? Here's a pic of them as of a few days ago. Thanks
in advance!

Comments (44)

  • 10 years ago

    Forgot the photo -


  • 10 years ago

    I'm no pro, I space mine about 6" apart & leave them until they bloom & seems to work fine. I don't tend to get much bloom til the 3rd year. Yours look very nice & healthy. Mine have to work with more weeds :)

    samhain10 - 5a thanked Nancy
  • 10 years ago

    From my experience, your spacing is OK as it is now & for the next couple of seasons. The seedlings will develop at their own programmed individual pace. Some will develop several additional fans over the next couple of years while others may continue on with only their original singe crown/root system. Consequently you will have some crowding in places, however, this should not cause you any serious problems or set-backs. Should the crowding become a concern for you simply lift out the plant itself (With suitable root-ball) for relocation - or it's nearby neighbours.

    There are a few points to keep in mind regarding your seedling's developments. It looks as though I live in a similar gardening environment as yourself (South-Central Ontario) so some of my observations might be relevant for you to keep in mind.

    One key is to ensure good husbandry - plenty of water & nutrition - Keep them growing. Another is that they are ALL individuals, even though they may be from the same parents. In general daylilies are mongrels - usually labelled with the '50 cent word' - Hybrids. Thus the mixture of the genetics within each of your seedlings could likely be quite diverse ....

    Expect precocious maiden blooms as yearlings (Very few if any); second year plants might surprise you with some scapes & blooms (Likely for a few); Most of those that are what you seek should bloom during their third season - some however may not. A highly experienced breeder working in a similar gardening zone as ourselves, once explained that his results revealed that any seedling that has not bloomed by and including its third season, should be discarded. (Out of curiosity, I've personally kept some on for a 4th and even 5th season still unbloomed and simply finally gave up on them.)

    Another personal opinion: If you have the space, keep everything that looks interesting to you your first few times through this process - even though the specific seedling might have serious faults. By observing those seedlings developing into mature 4-5 year old plants, it will assist you in learning about the evolution from maiden-bloom through to adult development. During year 4 you'll wonder why you decide to keep that particular seedling or this one over here ..... Most serious breeders usually keep 'border-line seedlings' for a few years - sometimes several years - before committing to that final decision of 'Go-No-Go! (Check out the AHS - American Hemerocallis Society & ATP - National Gardening Daylily websites among others)

    My conclusion after many years of involvement is that the long complex process of 'trying' is the more satisfying aspect of breeding daylilies. Actually standing over that seedling that finally shows great overall plant habit & intriguing beautiful blooms is exhilarating of course, ..... But you will not be long reverting back to the excitement of starting again, trying once more .... Getting there is where most of the fun is.

    samhain10 - 5a thanked wildbirds
  • 10 years ago

    Thank you both for your responses. Nancy - I'm familiar with the weed issue - LOL, though my problem is more often the wild grasses we have on our property - stuff that grows 5 feet tall in places.

    Wildbirds - very in depth response; my hearty appreciation! Yes, the process of anticipation is a prime factor. :) I have no idea what to expect with these crosses - three daylilies were unnamed "mongrels" that I had growing in my garden - though beautiful, and the 4th was a Siloam double classic. There should be at least a few keepers out of the 26 plants, I hope.

    I will leave everyone in place unless I see excessive crowding, at which point I will move the least amount of plants to alleviate the problem. I was hoping someone might offer me the news that there was a chance of bloom in the second year. I note that more than a couple of the plants have developed extra fans, which made me wonder if I'd get lucky.

    Thanks again,

    Alex


  • 10 years ago

    I am south of you in west central Indiana (on the border of zone 5b/6a), but in our experience judging by the size of your seedlings now, I think you have a good chance of bloom in the second season. We got about 500 of our seedlings in the ground early this year (April) and we have already had a few blooms. I would expect most of those 500 to bloom next year. We put out another 1000 (just finished that process) and I expect many of them to bloom as well. I think seedlings seem anxious to bloom their second season, many putting up scapes before our named cultivars.

    We also plant our seedlings 6 inches apart (sometimes less than that if we have a lot to plant) and leave them for three years before we move them. The weak ones are crowded out, but I don't want those anyway.

    Nancy

    samhain10 - 5a thanked hoosier_nan (IN z5b/6a)
  • 10 years ago

    Was getting ready to walk out to the garden, and thought I'd check the net one more time. Thanks to both Nancys for offering that hope of bloom next year - oh boy! 1500 seedlings, huh? That's alot of daylilies!

    - Alex

  • 10 years ago

    John Rice grows his seedlings even tighter than that - about two inches apart. Those that thrive in that environment are the ones selected out.

  • 10 years ago

    Had to go look up who John Rice was, not being conversant with the daylily world, and was impressed with the rave reviews. Two inches apart is pretty close. But I suppose with experts working in well-prepared beds, then the spacing can be negotiable. In any case, I'd say it clinches the issue of whether my 6" spacing is acceptable!

  • 10 years ago

    I think I need clarification as to what "first year", "second year", etc. mean. If I plant seeds in January I will shortly thereafter have foliage. Is that "year one" or, as I would call it, "year
    zero"? In other words, is the "first year" the year in
    which foliage appears, even if it is less than a full year?

  • 10 years ago

    Year 1.


  • 9 years ago

    It looks like all my babies have survived the winter - big smiles! And I'm seeing multiple fans on some. Here are a few. Maybe I'll get to see bloom this year!




  • 9 years ago

    Thanks, Nancy! I'll be sure to post pics. :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Just thought I would pop in with a few comments . I grow in S.W.Ontario Canada about 2 hours from the US Border at Michigan . 4 years ago , I planted my first seedlings about 6 inches apart .

    i do have seedlings to plant this year however , I will definitely plant farther apart . I dont know if it is because most of what I planted were UF/spider varieties but by year 3 the crowding was horrendous and I had even gone in and removed some daylilies who's blooms attracted me in an effort to alleviate the crowding . I had approximately 1500 seedlings in two different beds . Both were overcrowded.

  • 9 years ago

    Signet - glad for the feedback. I will watch these plants this year with that warning in mind. I can make changes in the fall if it looks like there is a problem brewing - thanks!

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Hey! There's a scape forming on one of my 2nd years! I bet there'll be more... :)

  • 9 years ago

    2nd year? What is a "2nd year"? I have hybrids I crossed in 2015, planted that fall and put them outside in 2016. To me that is year #1, and this year, 2017, is year #2. Is that how it's calculated?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    However you count the years, I have 15 plants, and at least count 11 have buds.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi Dave. You got an earlier start than I did, so your plants would in actual fact be older. I made my crosses in 2015 also, but didn't start the seed until end of Feb or beginning of March 2016. I planted them out in May 2016. So, as I understand it, and Dick in Ohio agreed, 2016 was my 1st year. 2017 is now my 2nd year. Wait a minute...I did start the seeds earlier than that, now that I think of it, because I stratified them for at least 2 months in damp paper towel in the fridge. Still I'm not counting that time since the seed wasn't germinated and planted until early 2016. The daylily masters on here can correct me, but I think you are counting growing seasons. My plants had an initial growing season (Year 1), then went into dormancy, and now are on their 2nd growing season. And as I understand it, it's not uncommon for daylilies to wait until their 3rd year to bloom.

    So, lucky you! 11 surprises in the making for this year! I am eager to see what my first ever hybrid daylilies look like. :)

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Alright - we have bloom! A humble beginning, but still beautiful to me. I think I will call this one "First Out the Gate" - ha!

    That color is fairly accurate - I guess you would call it mahogany. The mother was not quite so brownish, but, to tell the truth, I'll need to see her bloom again to make sure whether she was the more orange-ish red or purple-ish red NoName, since I have both. I see a little of the crinkling to the petal edges which comes from the male donor, the pink Siloam classic.

    The other thing I will say is that it was a surprise to see a bloom on this plant so early since it's a shrimp in comparison to some of the others - not much of a fan at all. Surprise!

    Anyway, more to follow very soon, as a good many more than half of the plants have scapes. This is exciting! :)

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Congrats on your first seedling bloom. Our first one was deformed but we must have looked at it 20 times that first day. The excitement of a seedling's first bloom just doesn't wear off for us.

    Nancy

  • 9 years ago

    I'm loving it, my first born. I greatly look forward to seeing the next ones. :) Will post when I do.

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Love the name! Amazing what blooms generate from seedlings Isn't it ?

  • 9 years ago

    I have been a "serious" gardener for over 30 years now, and even now I am thrilled each time I see a seed germinate. Knowing that within that seed is the blueprint for something potentially wonderful. And to play a part in the assortment of genes that produces that bloom and completes the cycle - sublime!

  • 9 years ago

    Oh, oh! Look at this one!

    Isn't she a beauty? I'm calling her My Delight. And on the subject of names, I hadn't even considered naming any of these when I started, but a friend took a walk through my garden and when I showed her the daylily bed with all its scapes, she made some comment about the fun of thinking up names for my hybrids.

    Well. Since I don't have names for any of the parents except the Pink Siloam Classic, I can't register any of these, I would imagine - not that I ever had any intention of doing so; this was just for my own enjoyment and to share with friends. But I don't want to spit in the face of tradition - in the Daylily World, is it considered "not the thing" to name my mongrels? Nancy - hoosier_nan, you're one of the pros - what's the usual practice in a case like this?

    BTW, I was wrong about the first daylily - not a cross with the Siloam, but a cross between the yellow pictured below and either a maroonish-red or a burgundy-red, which goes a ways to explaining how I ended up with a mahogany color. My Delight is definitely a cross between the Siloam and the yellow below.

    Sorry about the color on this yellow - it's in very bright morning sun. I tried to tweak it to get the color right, and that's pretty close, if a little too garish. It's a very large bloom, by the way - very hardy plant. Looked through my records to see if maybe somewhere along the line, I had a purchase record for this daylily so I could supply a name, but I couldn't find anything. I'm thinking now it was a hand-me-down from another gardener along the way. I've had it for decades.

    OK, so more to come - probably a new one tomorrow. Here's the bed as of today. That's Marble supervising from the chair. Later - Alex

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Samhain , there is no reason , if you want to pay the cost to register, that you cant register any of your hybrid daylily babies. There are plenty of them out there that are registered as pod parent "unknown" and pollen parent " unknown" . Even some of the largest hybridizers out there register unk x unk . So if it is a good plant ( and it usually takes about three to four years of growing it to know if it is a good plant) and you have all the specs recorded go ahead and register if you want to . I myself balk at paying $ 20 per cultivar for someone to log a name and stats into a computer database. But that is just me . there are lots of people with lots of money who register daylilies every year .


    Oh, your yellow daylily , is it very fragrant ?

    samhain10 - 5a thanked signet_gw(6b)
  • 9 years ago

    Signet - yes, the yellow is very fragrant! Are you thinking maybe it's an old variety you're familiar with?

    So if it is a good plant ( and it usually takes about three to four
    years of growing it to know if it is a good plant) and you have all the
    specs recorded go ahead and register if you want to .

    Nah, I don't feel the need to go that route. It will be fun to see what I get, and if it's not poor etiquette to name my babies while discussing them here on GW or elsewhere, then that's good enough for me.

    Oh, and if you have a clue about the yellow, I'd like to hear it.

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hi again Alex , I need to know a little more info ( such as how long have you been growing this plant ? How tall is it ? ) The reason I ask is I think what you have there may be the daylily Hyperion but you would need to check the stats on that cultivar to see if they match your plant . The reason I ask how long you have been growing it is often newly planted daylilies dont measure up height wise or bloom size wise until they have a few years to settle in . Anyway here is a link to the info on Hyperion for you to check against your plant ( it is a very popular plant ) https://garden.org/plants/view/5015/Daylily-Hemerocallis-Hyperion/

    Naming your plants is fine , sharing the names on the forum is ok but the names may be used by some other hybridizer if you put the name out there. I think it was Shive who had shared a name she gave one of her seedlings and someone else registered a plant by the name she had given her plant . ( Not sure exactly what happened and also not completely sure it was Shive ......but someone on the forum should be able to confirm this or not )

  • 9 years ago

    Signet - dang! I was just out there and meant to measure the yellow and forgot, my mind being focused on my latest bloom. I'd go out again right now, but the truth is I'm hobbling around with an orthopedic boot on a broken ankle, and I need to get off it again for awhile. :(

    From memory, I'd say it's got to be 4 ft tall. As to how long I've had it...gee, anywhere from 15 to 26 years - can't narrow it down unfortunately.

    Well, if someone wants to take a name I use, then - oh, well. I figure it's not improbable that I might unknowingly name one of mine something that's already being used elsewhere. As I'm not trying to sell or be in competition, I guess I'll just deal with it.

    And, now - the unveiling of #3 - Michigan Sunset. I love it!

  • 9 years ago

    Nice flower! I love the fact that is a bitone with midribs and veining.

    Alex, the issue with your garden names is if you give them to friends with that name. For example, your latest flower, Michigan Sunset. That's a pretty name and quite apt, but that name was registered with the American Hemerocallis Society in 1992. It's ok if you want to call it that, but don't give them away under that name. Then the recipient gives it to somebody else under that name and that person decides to sell at the local farmer's market, or on the lily auction, or perhaps start a nursery. Then they are selling your Michigan Sunset, not the real one. A customer orders one thinking that it's the real Michigan Sunset and gets a surprise when it blooms.

    As I said, it's ok to call them what you want because you know they aren't registered. But if you give them away, I suggest either give them with no names attached (Alex's orange seedling) or put your name in front of the name you call it--Alex's Michigan Sunset.

    As Signet said, Shive (on the forum) has a seedling she called Valentine Sweetheart. She was debating whether she should register it and while she was considering it, someone else registered one under that name. On this forum, she now refers to it as the former Valentine Sweetheart. If she decides to register it, she will have to come up with another name.

    Are you familiar with the American Hemerocallis Society database? It lists every daylily that was ever registered. It is available online here. http://daylilydatabase.org/search.php

    I'm not trying to be picky, but every one of us on this forum has a bunch of Noid (No Identification) daylilies. It's easy for a seller to dig the wrong plant (especially when not in bloom). The recipient won't know (if he ever does) it's not the right one until a year or two later sometimes. Honest mistakes like that happen, but we don't need to muddy the water with duplicate names.

    Nancy

    samhain10 - 5a thanked hoosier_nan (IN z5b/6a)
  • 9 years ago

    Nancy - got it. That's the info I needed to hear, because I figured there would be some issue with names. So - there's already a Michigan Sunset - ha! Well, I'll go with your advice and call it Alex's Michigan Sunset. In the future, I will bookmark the AHS and check proposed names, but still preface them with Alex or some other identifier in case someone comes along later and registers under it. I'm not imagining I will do the daylilies big time, but who knows? I'm certainly enjoying seeing the surprises so far. May have to invest in some commercial ones just to enlarge the gene pool. :)

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Signet - and I think you must be right about the yellow being Hyperion. All the info I looked at checks out. It would be nice if some of my crosses with it have fragrance as well. I must admit I didn't check for that, but I will now! Thanks!

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Just went to look at the AHS database and see that both Michigan Sunset (1992) and My Delight (1946) have both been used. Interesting. No one has used First Out the Gate, however.

  • 9 years ago

    'First Out the Gate' has bloomed a second time, and the color is slightly different - more reddish than the initial brown color. The plant is so small and spindly, I'm a little concerned that it might bloom itself to death - can this happen?


  • 9 years ago

    Alex, you will be surprised how this bloom will change over a few seasons . Rarely does a bloom stay exactly how it bloomed the first season .


  • 9 years ago

    Signet - but when a plant is rather small and weak looking, can it be good for it to bloom so rapidly and successively, is what I was wondering. The blooms themselves are normal and reasonable size - 4", considering the plant.

  • 9 years ago

    I wouldn't worry about the size of the plant. Many seedlings will bloom when they quite small. Since it has already grown the scape, I don't think it will hurt the plant to let the flowers open. I just wouldn't let it set pods.

    Nancy

    samhain10 - 5a thanked hoosier_nan (IN z5b/6a)
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks, Nancy. I have been removing all the spent blooms so far, my intuition being that maybe they shouldn't be allowed to set seed. I may have 2 more blooms on other plants today. I'm excited to walk out there, but think I will wait for the dew (and mosquito clouds to clear off a bit first). With this boot on my foot, I'm not able to move out of their way quite as quickly. :)

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Alex , I see Nancy has answered your question about letting a first year seedling set seed quite nicely . I too try to stop a seedling from setting seed its first bloom season but there are so many I do miss some . I cant honestly say I have ever lost a new seedling from neglecting to remove potenial seed pods but it does make the most sense to allow the new plant to focus all its energy into growth as opposed to seed production .

    samhain10 - 5a thanked signet_gw(6b)
  • 9 years ago

    Signet - yes, that's how I saw it. Now I think I can't stand the suspense any longer - must go see what surprises I have this morning. :)

  • 9 years ago

    Didn't get any new blooms yesterday, thanks to this one which was taking it's sweet time opening. As a result, I have named it "YOU KEEP ME WAITING". (So far no one has registered that name, so I'm not adding the "Alex" prefix). To cut it some slack, I must add that it's a large flower - 6". Takes after his Dad - the yellow Hyperion which has blooms over 6" wide. It was also apparently trying to open it's second bloom at almost the same time - it's behind it on the right.

    In addition, Alex's MICHIGAN SUNSET bloomed again:

    As did, Alex's MY DELIGHT:

    Question: When I'm measuring blooms, using the pic above as an example, I generally hold the ruler up to it as close as I can and am measuring from that farthest point on the left to the farthest edge of the curve on the right, but not to the actual tip of that petal, right? It's what is apparent, not the actual length?

    I'm happy so far with my babies. :)

    - Alex

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, that is the correct way to measure.

    Nancy

    samhain10 - 5a thanked hoosier_nan (IN z5b/6a)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Just a note , when you are naming a daylily for registration , you are limited to 30 letters. I know you say you aren't interested but your thoughts on registering may change over time so thought you would like to know


    samhain10 - 5a thanked signet_gw(6b)
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks, Signet. Yes, I did go read their guidelines - even though it's doubtful I'll ever register. But ya never know... :)

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations