Software
Houzz Logo Print
kayla_thomas3817

Stomped ceilings

10 years ago

Our new house is just over 5300 sqft, and every single ceiling surface in the home is stomped. I really want to remove it. All of it. I hate the look of any texture on a ceiling, and would prefer a smooth surface. The house is new enough that there looks to only be one thin coating of ceiling paint over it, so the spray and scrape technique would (hopefully) work. I am planning to put crown up in most of the rooms, and I don't even know how I can get it to sit nicely with all the uneven, bumpy surfaces. I'm not sure if it's worth it to remove, or if I need to just look past it. Thoughts?

Comments (29)

  • 10 years ago
    Stomped? Not sure I know what that is! If you just mean heavily textured, you've got quite a job there! It can be done, but it will be messy.

    But I feel for you, I dislike textured walls and ceilings.

    As for crown molding, don't feel bad, even the newest of new homes are not completely aligned, so filling in the gaps is usually necessary somewhere.
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    The auto correct of stamped to stomped should make this the next epic house thread. I wanted to laugh milk through my nose. Just hit my funny bone just right I suppose as we are all prey of autocorrect.

    Yes, scrape them all. No don't DIY it. It is worth it to your lungs to hire professional crews who wear the correct air filters and tape off each room as they go so it isn't in the ventilation.
  • 10 years ago
    You could save some cash by just scraping the stomping from the main living areas and your bedroom. After all, bathrooms aren't used for long periods of time and the kids probably think it's pretty cool that someone stomped around and made foot prints on their ceiling. :)
  • 10 years ago
    That's so funny.
    Photos of what you're describing would help. Remember , not all homes need crown molding.
  • 10 years ago

    I'm surprised that a new home of that size would have heavily textured ceilings, unless there is some reason for it? Photos?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I agree get it done by pros it is a huge job and really messy as for molding not all homes suit crown molding so no comment without pictures

  • 10 years ago

    I'm sorry. I almost forgot I even posted this! Hopefully you can see from this what I mean. Excuse the mess. I just painted (I know, I know...that's last. But literally everything was yellow. Walls. Doors. Trim. Augh.), and am working on...everything.

  • 10 years ago

    It needs more substantial trim everywhere to add some sort of visual interest and depth. Almost 10' ceilings with piddly 4.5" baseboard and super basic casing throughout. It just wasn't finished well. Then we open up to this kitchen...



    It's a mess...with potential (and on 4.5 acres), but still a mess.


  • 10 years ago

    Can't really see the ceilings, but I trust you. They certainly aren't smooth. But at this point, I'm wondering if the ceilings are really one of the first things you need to think about. I know it's best to get them out of they way before you move in, but it looks like you've already done that?

    Not sure what your situation is, or your budget, but it it was my place, one of the first things I'd do is remove the carpet and tiles, and put in real wood floors. Talk abut an upgrade!

    Then I'd work on trim, the fireplace (which I see you have tackled), upgraded light fixtures, and yes, the trim. But I think I'd work on trim around doors and windows first. Ceiling molding won't disguise piddly trim around doors and windows. Unfortunately, this builder went cheap. Not bad, just not as nice as it could be.

    Kitchen looks fine. It's so hard to do it all at once!

  • 10 years ago

    Oh, and chaninging floor trim too. In my place with 9' ceilings, I have 5" trim. And I think I could have gone for 6". I had 7" in my 100 year-oil old Craftsman, which also had 9' ceilings.

  • 10 years ago

    Kmkane, that's all my plan. Hardwood continuously throughout, stone fireplace, more substantial trim... :)

    I'm working on it ALL, but I don't want to get everything else finished and then go back to the ceiling. It needs all new trim, and I am planning to do larger that I'll route and put together myself. I made and installed all the trim (minus crown which isn't even pictured here bc this was just a little basement bar area...) in our last remodel, and I'll do it again for this house to elevate the feel without REALLY feeling it in the budget.

    I'm also planning to reface the kitchen here. I just prefer white shaker cabinets, and not staggered heights. I've already contacted the cabinet maker to talk about this, but you're right. Ican't just do it all at once! It would've been so nice to move in AFTER everything was done, but that wasn't possible for our timing. Here's another, closer picture of the ceiling too.



  • 10 years ago

    Boy, I would hate that ceiling too, but 5200 sf is a *lot* of ceiling mess! Given that it's not full popcorn stalagmites, I'd be tempted to skip it, but I applaud your dedication! Good luck.

  • 10 years ago

    It is a lot...I can't decide what to do!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    40 years+ in the business, and I have no idea what a stamped ceiling is! Looks like just a texture though it doesn't even show up in your images. It's not even popcorn texture. None of the lighting selections are helping your situation.

    I think the painters can sand the texture off, or minimize it. If you select only ceiling flat white paint for your ceilings, that will help minimize the appearance.

    You have a contemporary home. Why did you buy this home if you are looking for a Hampton's detailed home? You are looking for solutions based on a rather limited exposure to what might be going on with interiros. Spend some time educating yourself on what is occurring out there. None of the existing interiors posted below have 'crown moulding'. That's not what makes a room 'interesting'.

  • 10 years ago

    It really is "stomped" or stippled...not stamped. It's not an auto correct mishap. It is applied with a "stomp brush." It is a horribly textured ceiling.


    I'm not sure what you're after with asking me why we bought this house, as if I could roll back time and change the fact that we did. We own it.

    I also do not see what is making it contemporary. It's more-so a colonial style house that had shortcuts taken in the finishes. Is it the black doors? I just painted them this weekend to try it out, and agree that they stand out more than they should, but also think that's because of how large they are when paired with the thin white casing (to be replaced) next to them. They were butter yellow, along with the rest of the trim. This is what it looked like last week (only change since purchasing in this picture is removing the giant raised hearth that was covered in the cheap $.67 12x12" :Lowes porcelain tile).


    (After re-installing a French door the previous owners removed and starting to paint.)

    It needs some love, and I'm trying to figure out how to help it. I understand that crown molding isn't the only option to add "interest" in a home (though your first image after telling me that does have crown at the top of the ship lap). I love ship lap, interesting furniture, beamed ceilings, nice lighting, floor to ceiling windows with grilles, art, nice textiles... and I have actually already purchased ship lap for the laundry and mud rooms (which are currently a lovely shade of terra cotta orange, with turquoise doors and trim, and the same cabinetry as the kitchen--I'm telling you-- identity crisis house), have grilles on order for the windows, stone and a new mantle in the works for the fireplace, hardwood samples scattered throughout to choose from, plans for lighting, a rug, a huge coffee table...we have a lot going on, and it's not just crown molding, though I happen to like the look of it in a formal living room, and think that a room this size needs more texture, depth, etc. Everything is just too diminutive and plain in the whole house...except the giant out of place Tuscan style corbels on the range hood... The room is roughly 15'x25' long. It's a large space, but I think the house has potential, and I don't think you have to buy a home with all the finishes you want already installed if you're willing to do a little work. I'm obviously in the beginning stages of making this house my home.

  • 10 years ago

    Congratulations to you for seeing the potential in the home. It sounds like you love the property and can imagine a way that the home will suit you perfectly. I too am not the kind of person who needs to have the house exactly as I want it before I purchase. My current home is a 4500 sq ft home that I have made my own over the 10 years I've owned it. It is my forever home and I enjoy changing it to suit my needs and wishes as I have the money and the time. It is on a beautiful piece of property on a lake. I would imagine that you are the kind of person like likes to buy art that appeals to you rather than something mass produced just forth sake of "decorating". I admire you for wanting to deal with the ceiling now and think it makes sense. I do have horrible popcorn ceilings I wish I had dealt with initially. Now 4500 sq ft of popcorn seems overwhelming.

  • 10 years ago
    I realize you are just brainstorming and asking for opinions here. You will get hundreds of opinions and ideas.
    Have you considered hiring an interior designer?
    At this stage, it would be well worth an initial consultation. Interview at least three. Choose one with good references and whom you feel gets your style.
    Come up with a multi stage plan. She will save you from some expensive mistakes and will ultimately save you tons of money.
    Putting grids on Windows, changing moldings, painting, new floors etc. all needs to be done with a plan in mind.
    I realize the previous owners did some projects that didn't go with the style of the home. Did they install the Windows on the lower floor? They are not the same style as the uppers. I would not put grids it them, it will only draw attention to the mismatched Windows.
  • 10 years ago

    I'd get rid of the stomped ceilings before you do any more work or make purchases. It's a big mess but worth it IMO. Be aware that when it is removed you will probably have some damage and possibly repairs besides new paint. The reason builders use this in the first place is because it hides or minimizes a multitude of errors and its cheaper than smooth ceilings. Good luck with your new home.

  • 10 years ago

    SandyC. unfortunately those windows were installed when the house was built. I'm not crazy about the arches, but the windows below the arches are exactly the same as all the other windows on the front of the house (Andersen 400 series). I have been working on painting the sashes black to help them stand out a bit more in the dormers. I finished them all tonight, but think I'll have to wait and see how I really feel once I've seen them all turned around in the morning. I think the impact will be greater on the lower windows though, since they're not totally encased in white, but have the white and then brick.


    And just heading back to the topic on hand- I bought a new sprayer tonight and wetted the ceiling under the soffit in the kitchen nook. It scraped right off. I have zero desire to sand and skim coat, but I think I could take a few days and have it off most of the ceiling. I'll hire someone in to do the finishing, and feel happier about it all.


    I think hiring a designer would be a great idea. I don't know of any local to me that I've been impressed with though, and am really not sure how to go about finding someone.

  • 10 years ago
    I don't know where you are located. If you are near a design center in a city, call around to some of the showrooms. They work with designers all the time and may know of someone in your area. You could also check out some good furniture/ design shops that also work with designers in the area.
    I found mine, from a recommendation of a custom drapery guy. I needed lots of fabrics and he recommended her. I have used her for years for big remodel projects,wallpaper and paint selections, new furniture selections, you name it.
    It's a great way to get the most bang for your buck, get a plan working with your budget. Designers have working relationships with their own contractors and subs.
    She will advocate for you, help you work with a budget and supply a list of vendors available through the trade.
    Why are you painting the Windows black? Is that wood trim?
  • 10 years ago

    The exterior trim is not wood, but the sashes are. I followed this info: http://www.oldhouseguy.com/painting-windows/

    This is my goal:


    I feel like it's going to come together better once the grilles are in, and everything is done. I like this idea because I feel like the dormers are so plain in all their white on white on white...there's no definition. There's not enough room for shutters or any other decorative options to add depth to the windows, so black is where I'm going.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you! Still side tracked on Windows, but eventually it'll get it all smoothed out and finished!

  • 10 years ago

    Are you planning on making any changes to the kitchen? Also, what's in the cabinet above the range? Storage? Ventilation hood?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Float mud over that and finish; no scraping required.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi Joseph. That s a great idea. I will bring it up to the drywaller when he comes to quote me on my projects.

    Futuro-- I am planning to make changes to the kitchen. I want to have the cabinets refaced with shaker doors/drawers, with a white finish, and replace the two lower cabinets so they're all (except the hood) the same height, and have little lit, glass front cabinets on top to the ceiling. It is a ventilation hood above the stove, but it isn't exteriorly vented. I plan to redo that as well. I can vent behind and out the opposite side. Currently, it is just unreachable storage.

  • 10 years ago

    That's a ton of ceiling to scrape. I'm in the same boat just not nearly as much. I've been looking for an overlay that's not Sheetrock. I just don't want to scrape or float. It's tough if it's been painted over. Found a company in South Africa making a rigid foam beadboard and a v groove panels that look awesome. But nobody makes them here in the US in panel size larger than 20"x20".

  • 10 years ago
    The first thing I did with one short-term house was sand the ceilings (2,700 sq ft). I paid to have it done, and I can assure you the guy who did the work will never do that again. I did it first-----a real mess! Do not lay hardwood until you do the ceilings (if you do them). I like the previous suggestion of doing the main rooms and MBR. It's ultimately a personal choice. I abhor textured ceilings.
  • 10 years ago
    lol. In 10 more years, textured ceilings will start trending again, and you'll be asking for opinions on how to achieve the perfect stomped ceiling look.
Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions