W/o. And that's not a bad thing. As always, love your style.

I like the way the geometric design in the area rug plays off the black in the egg on the mantel. It also helps to ground the room and gives the eye something to focus on.

I wonder how it will look when you hang the wallpaper.....

Definitely with! Beautiful rug, and it adds warmth and texture, esp. since the chairs are solid. Just move it to the left a bit so it is centered on the FP :-)

Gee I am torn, I think it seems more soothing or peaceful with out the second rug but it feels very pulled together and a bit warmer with the rug. Maybe have a winter with the rug and roll it away for spring and summer. Beautiful space!

I like both. Perhaps with could be your winter look and without the sumer one?

Without.

I think once the paper is up, the rug will draw attention away from it, so I think w/out once you paper...but it looks fine for now.

AnnieD, I don't know if it will detract. In the photos, the paper sample is up (it is next to the orchid). It is like "Where's Waldo" trying to see it!

I'm glad people don't seem to feel too strongly about either choice, because I didn't either. As you can tell, I am pretty darn consistent with my off white walls, WT. upholstery etc etc. I think using the rug does ground it and give the lighter colors something to play off of. Plus, I own the rug anyway. And I don't think it works for my foyer particularly well. So I suppose it's in!

Maire,

The egg thing is actually a box and it's made from camel bone. It's a set of 2, I got them in India also. They have been on my vanity in my bathroom. Should I have two there? IDK

If the 2 boxes are identical then I'd only use one on the mantel but I'd consider placing the orchid in a black container. There's an art to utilizing black accents and I think a black pot would add balance to the mantel.

Hmm, interesting. The orchid is in a too-small pot so i need something anyway. I will try swapping it for something dark.

Just to clarify, is the mural paper black and white?

Is it very not helpful if I like both?:) Probably the second version a bit more..

But it's very pretty, either way

Very smart, about the darker pot for the orchid..interestingly, it asks more for darker pot when the more graphic rug is not there...

I think either is fine, but if you prefer a more calm look/feeling for the bedroom, I'd go without. Love the two chairs. Do you have a steamer? I'm guessing your chairs and curtains are linen? I use a steamer on mine and it works great!

I love the idea of a rug and I love that rug but I think it is a little harsh and pointy for a bedroom.

I think the rug brings out the color in the fireplace brick and gives the room a layer of interest. Just to make you crazy.

Westside, You are right about the brick, good point.

Robo, Yes, I can see where you could say that. I think when I first put it down, I thought "no way" for the same reason. But also really want something that feels different and fresher.

TinaM, "Calm" is part of the reason that my MBR is almost entirely off white --- not surprisingly, the headboard and bedding too. I think it needs a little something. LOL re steaming. The chair on the left was just delivered and the slips were folded in the box ... if the wrinkles don't hang out I will have to steam them. The slips on the right were popped in the wash today; they don't usually need steaming after the dryer.

AKT, That may be why I am on the fence. But "less bold" is also what I had there and tired of (see below) And I don't really feel like buying yet another rug ( i got two 8x10s in India) because I own a lot of rug mistakes and I am kind of fed up with rugs right now! So I framed it as a choice, w or w/o.

Elizabeth, no the mural paper is off white and brown.

I prefer w/o. But admit I always lean toward simplicity.

Love the rug!

I like the layered look. It looks a bit more decorated/finished.

..the third rug, I like too:)

not of much help, lol

oh wow that's amazing wallpaper I know it!!!!

I'd wait and decide once you have the wall paper up.

I'm not fond of the rug for a bedroom. In the photo, it looks like more an indoor/outdoor pattern. Next time you're in India, I'd return it. (wink)

I prefer the simplicity of the room without, but I like the rug in theory! Maybe it can find another spot in your house?

I love the his and her chairs and think I prefer the look without the new rug. I also really like the old rug, but know you said you've grown tired of it. The mirror is stunning!

I prefer it with. Grounds the area and adds texture.

Without. What is under the wall to wall? The chairs are lovely-nice choice!

It's a tough decision because it looks great w and w/o. But I think the rug will add warmth (once properly centered) without taking away from the calmness. Maybe this will be the fall/winter season look. Love the corner WTs, it's such a pretty room!

I like both, but I prefer WITH the new rug.

Both. I do like the rug and I like the way it adds warmth and draws you into the fireplace and a conversational atmosphere. It seems to blend nicely with the vibe you're creating with the vignette. I agree with those who suggest making it a seasonal add. Lovely space, Mtn.

Long term, and assuming the paper is graphic, I would hate to detract from it, especially because the Cole and Sons mural papers I've seen are gorgeous. But for now, if it's going to take a little time to hang it, I do like the rug when I see it as part of the seating vignette. But, I also agree that it doesn't quite feel like a bedroom rug. Where is the bed in relationship to the seating area? If you could use the rug there, it might give you the interest you're looking for, and the bed might break it up and soften it a little. Then if you still want something to define the sitting area you could potentially do something solid or more monochromatic there to coordinate with both the mural paper and the existing rug. Although, I do like the sisal. I know you aren't too excited about looking for another rug, but both from a cost and practical perspective, you're much less likely to get burned looking for something solid or monochromatic ;)

I do like the rug you're tired of, and I also noticed that it echoed the brick and added a little color into the room. But, if you're moving towards more contrast instead of color, I like how you're doing it!

This has nothing to do with your rug choices, but have you ever thought of turning the chairs towards the fireplace? Without knowing exactly how the rest of the room is configured, I realize it may not be possible but just a thought.

I like the room both ways. Without the rug, the chairs/pillows work. With the rug, there seems to be a need for different pillows that can compete with the design/colors in the rug.