Software
Houzz Logo Print
veronicac1031

Advice on Experience with Floor Plan Designer

10 years ago

Hi all. My husband and I signed up with a firm that helps people build their own houses. We are paying for them to do the rough in and then they guide us through the rest. The guy who will also act as the general contractor for the rough in is also acting as the designer. We like this gentleman very much. The problem is, his designs don't meet our needs at all. We gave him a pre-existing floor plan that suits our flat 1 acre lot, that isn't too complicated, and that we love. It just needed some tweaking. But he went in a totally different direction. We then drew exactly what we wanted with a CAD program. Seriously, we spent no less than 30 hours making sure everything was architecturally as sound as we could possibly make it. And he still changed it in ways we did not like. We've asked him repeatedly to draw the design we gave him. It's not even a difficult design, but he keeps doing weird stuff to it. We're looking for easy changes and he's moving staircases and rooms around. Is this typical? Should modifying a proven design be so stressful? I can't figure out if we are unrealistic or if he's inexperienced. It's been at least 5 weeks and I feel like we are still at square one.

Comments (44)

  • 10 years ago

    When you say it's a proven design, is it one from a plan factory or one you designed on a consumer CAD program?

    Also if he's a designer, maybe he has ideas that will work better?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    It's from a plan factory. https://saterdesign.com/products/salcito. I was hoping I would be wowed by his ideas, but some of them are rather strange. Like:

    -my daughter couldn't get into her bathroom unless she closed her bedroom door because the bathroom door was behind it.

    -there was a 50 foot hall for 1,000 sq. foot second story.

    -The Jack and Jill bathroom he planned had seven doors (only one door being a linen closet)

    -The grand entrance was blocked off by the moving of a staircase so the entrance butted up against the exterior of the staircase.

    -At one point my son's room was 10 x 15

    -Another time our breakfast nook was 5 x 17.

    There's more, but I've lost track since we have been through so many floor plan versions.

  • 10 years ago

    Are there any reasons he's stating the plans can't be built as shown? Maybe you need to enlist the services of an architect to tweak the plans or at least a draftsman.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    There are a lot of things I like about that plan and its layout as a patio home, but I do agree with your builder that the stairs might not be in the best location. They are a long way from the door and I don't think you'd want to direct a lot of traffic through the nanawall. Also, there are hardly any windows at the back of the house where there is normally a backyard that's relatively open to light. The windows are on the side of the plan with the dining, kitchen, and leisure rooms. Do you have open space in that direction or does it butt up against another house (built or vacant lot)? When you've asked the builder why he's proposing the changes what has been his response? Have you contacted the plan factory to see if they can easily make the mods for you?

  • 10 years ago

    Can you ask for a new designer?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Hi Veronica,

    >We like this gentleman very much. The problem is, his designs don't meet our needs at all.

    Why and what is his design and why doesn't it meet your needs AT ALL?

    It would help if you state your needs?

    >We gave him a pre-existing floor plan that suits our flat 1 acre lot, that isn't too complicated, and that we love.

    This is not a simple plan, ceiling height is all over the place. But it is a nice plan as is, for narrow lot. Somewhat larger foundation. No one knows exactly what you or he is trying to solve. Why move rooms? Master is on the first floor, so why do you care about the stairs. Open staircase with windows will look nice.

    Are you trying to get another bedroom upstairs or something? I would put a skylights over the loft to make it nice and bright. W/o it, or knowing what the issue is - I would just build it as is.

  • 10 years ago

    The original architect / designer of this plan offers to make modifications - I'd suggest you work with them.

  • 10 years ago

    Or take your CAD design that you like right to the builder. I found a plan online where I liked the basics. I called my builder and he said that because every states building laws are so different, that unless it was made for Wisconsin he would have to do stuff to it. So he told me to re-draw it myself with my changes, or bring it in with all my changes marked and we could go from there.

    I re-drew it, resizing some things, added doors, added a garage, adding walls to make an open dining room into a library, reduced 7' halls to 5' etc, added a deck, extra windows, added a walk out basement. When I had it all done I took it to my builder/lumbaryard's CAD design team. They only made a few minor changes, making a 18" closet door into a 2' one, and they gave me a couple of tips where I could cut costs.

    So if you love your plans, why do you even have this "middle-man"? People on here can give you advice as well. Take your plans to your builder's CAD design professional and tell them to draw them just as they are, unless they need to move/change something to meet code. Your CAD designer can also talk to you about things that look odd if you ask him, mine was great, spent over an hour with me one day when I really just popped in to leave him a message about changing one archway. I learned alot that day.



  • 10 years ago

    As noted above, this compact design is for tight city lots.

    It is frankly absurd for a flat one-acre lot. Especially as it's a relatively large home. I would spring a couple bucks for a custom design by an architect. Or at least a plan factory product that takes advantage of the space you have to work with.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Yes, this is a design for a very narrow lot, perhaps a zero-lot line development. It's also a very large and rambling plan inside, with a lot of lost space on the second floor. I think you can do much better with a design more appropriate for the size of your lot.

  • 10 years ago

    Before you consider this plan, I would take a furniture planner and add your furniture into the plan to see how it will work. From what I can see, you'll have a tough time arranging furniture in the public rooms because of all the walkways. I'm specifically thinking of the living room, leisure room and the nook.

    I assume in the nook you'll want a table and chairs. If so, the only real way to have walking room from the foyer to the leisure room is to do banquet seating because at 9'4" wide, you won't have much room for table and chairs.

    The leisure room loses 3' along the kitchen area and 3' along the loggia wall. It also loses 2' along the built ins. So the room actually will be 12'2" x 14'8" of usable seating space.

    The living room isn't quite as bad. You'll lose 2' along the fireplace wall and 3' along the dining/lanai wall and arch wall, making the usable seating space 12' x 13'4".

    The problem is, that even though the fireplace is centered on the wall, I don't see a way to center your furniture.

    You also have some poor things like the toilet closet up against the only wall in your bedroom where you can put a bed, so if your beloved goes to the toilet in the middle of the night, you'll hear the flushing at least. Or if you decide to put the bed between the windows, it means anytime you want to go out to the pool from the master, you have to walk around the bed.

    There's a huge master bath with lots of wasted space and a small shower considering the size of the bathroom. Personally, I'd make the master closet a bit larger and the bathroom smaller.

    If this is a retirement house, I'd rethink where the laundry room is. As is now you either have to shlep it through the foyer, nook, and leisure room to get to the laundry room, or you need to walk out the foyer to the loggia, open the leisure room sliders and then carry it to the laundry room.

    The lanai is 11'8" x 10'. With the doors opening out (I'm assuming this is a FL build and hence the reason for the doors opening out), that effectively cuts your balcony to 8'8" x 7' to put maybe one or two chairs.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I missed that this is for a 1 acre lot. That's what I get for reading late at night and not rereading during daytime.

    Oh geez. I agree 100% with Virgil and Worthy. This is similar to what I'd build on my city lot, not a 1 acre lot! And if you're in FL, enclosing it in like that is even worse.

    This is why online plans do not work well so many times. They look nice in pictures but have no relationship to the lot. Like suggested, find a person of design talent to create a wonderful oasis for you.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I do not think Narrow Lot house is always "absurd" to build on 1 acre lot. In fact I will be building one on 12 acres. Reasons:

    1) Reduces your taxes, it does not look massive like mcMansion. And this is what is important for tax man. We do not want to level finishes "Custom - Grade 1". Tax jumps from 2-3k to $7,000/year.

    2) Lot faces north and I would like to minimize that exposure. Prevents people driving by from been able to see anything in the windows.

    3) Provides good exposures to features of the lot.

    4) Provides nice space for gardens, where you do not need 500' houses.

    5) Provide some (25%) of "unfinished space".

  • 10 years ago

    Brian you can build a beautiful small house on a large lot that doesn't look like it was meant to be a house for a small, narrow lot. There is a difference between building a small house on a large lot and building a house meant for a narrow lot on a large lot.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Everyone brings up good points. We realize it is a rather narrow house, but we love Italianate courtyard designs. Also the lot is not square. It's fairly long, rather than wide. We will be adding a lot of outdoor space around the house. Plus, the guest house will be increased in length for my mom (mother-in-law-house).

    It's not this won't fit on our lot, it will with no problems. He never gives us a reason why he won't draw what we want. He nods and agrees, makes notes and then a couple of weeks later delivers all these weird changes.

    The design company can make the changes, but we've already signed a contract and paid half the cost of drafting the floor plan. He looked at the design and told us, "Oh yeah, there shouldn't be any problem tweaking this" and then changes the whole design like crazy. The first design he increased the square footage by 1,000 square feet. Then he said it was easier to reduce once you have a design you like. This sounds like an unusual way of going about it.

    Someone mentioned we should state our needs. We want that kind of house design, with some changes.

    -No living room (useless space for us)

    -Move the master bedroom into that space. Rework the bathroom (make it smaller) and closet (bigger) to reflect the move of the master bedroom.

    --The front entrance would be in the Great Room (which would be larger).

    -Create a pantry.

    -Create an office off the master bedroom that connects in a hall and the whole thing can be closed off by a sliding door.

    -Pretty much leave the upstairs alone as far as three rooms. Maybe a Jack and Jill Bathroom. As long as the upstairs fits on top of the house and is an efficient use of space, we're open.

    -Make the guest room outside of the house a mother-in-law-house.

    Ordinarily, this guy is the company's San Antonio construction manager/owner builder consultant. I'm starting to think he's new to design and is trying to cut his teeth on our house. Ugh. I don't want to tick him off since he will be building our house. And he's really nice, just not hearing us. Or maybe he's trying to impress us with his creative talents. We meet with him this week. Maybe we'll be able to have a better understanding of each others POV after this week.

  • 10 years ago

    Um - if you change the living room into a master, and then dining into an office you are fundamentally changing the flow of the house not to mention the width - and that eliminates the courtyard feel.

    Have no idea where the "great room is" and how you can move the entry there.

    I can understand why he's changed it - you've made massive changes to the house in what you have described and I don't think it works well at all.

  • 10 years ago

    @cpartist I like how you think! You brought up many excellent points. We addressed almost all of them. We did use a CAD program to fit our furniture in, which was helpful to see the big picture (It all fit). We aren't going to enclose the courtyard. The outdoor space will be increased around the house in future years in the form of several outdoor rooms. We are eliminating the living room altogether, so the fireplace is moot. The bathroom was totally redone, and the toilet was moved to another wall. The master bath was reduced and the closet size increased.

    I like the thought of moving the laundry room, but I don't know how to fit in without changing everything. If we ask our designer, he'll redraw the whole house to do it.

    But we didn't think about the lanai. Hmm, very observant. I must look at that.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    @Lily'smom Well, he's charging by the square foot, so we don't pay hourly. He assured us the changes were completely in his skill set. I guess i was under the impression that working with a floor plan with a basic idea of the shape was easier than making a whole new one and that most designers knew how to do stuff like that. Maybe my expectations are too high. That's what I'm trying to figure out.

    I do worry some that he may have his own vision. But he also has a boss who owns the company to answer to. I can only hope that he is dabbling in something that new to him. We may have to ask for their usual designer. He asked if we minded if he took a look at the plan when we first started. I didn't realize at the time he meant, "I will do the design rather than our usual designer." It bothers me that he never has seen the lot or asked to walk it.

    Anyway, we are definitely increasing the size of the garage. Good call. Thanks

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    LOL, I saw your scream house thread....

    Personally I would eliminate dining room (based on your requirements) and make bigger lanai. Add pantry on the back of the kitchen, and turn Living Room into an office, reduce size of living room [now office] while increasing and redo master bath and the closet. This takes very little changes flow about the same.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Have you talked to The Boss? Described your concerns? There's a lot not right in this process, and it's close to a disaster in the making. Time to take a different direction: 1) Talk to The Boss, whomever that is; 2) Based on that, decide if the situation is salvageable, or if it's time to cut bait and walk. Nothing should be this difficult.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Have no idea where the "great room is" and how you can move the entry there.

    I think she means the leisure room.

    First of all, I agree to cut your losses now before you invest more time and money into it. And tell them you are not going to pay for the design that was done because it is not what you signed up for.

    Secondly, you said:

    Eliminate the living room (useless space for us)

    -Move the master bedroom into that space. Rework the bathroom (make it smaller) and closet (bigger) to reflect the move of the master bedroom.

    --Move the front entrance to the Great Room.

    -Create a small corner pantry where the cabinets meet.

    -Make the dining room (another useless space for us) into an office. That doesn't really change the layout. It's just another name for the room.

    -Pretty much leave the upstairs alone.

    So now your master bedroom will be right next to your dining room?

    What you are proposing is changing the whole house around and how it functions. That is not small changes. It's redesigning EVERYTHING! Once you start doing so many changes, you'd be better off spending your money with a REAL architect who can come out to your property, walk it with you, observe how the light is, as well as the best views and create a plan that works for you and your family. This is not it.

    Trying to change an online plan so drastically is NOT the answer. It's just throwing good money after bad.

    First I'd ask, what exactly about this plan do you like so much?

    Also on your lot which direction is south?

    Which direction has the best views?

    What is your family makeup in terms of what you need? Kids? Animals? Parents?

  • 10 years ago

    I don't see how it is possible to compare two house designs without seeing either of them.

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Write everything down. You've got the beginning of a great horror story. You may not get the house you want, but the book and movie royalties may make up for it.

    Seriously, hire an experienced licensed architect to design a home with you. Architects are good investments, as you may be learning.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Book and movie rights, LOL. Although, the more I think about it, the less funny it gets.

    For anyone interested, the plans are below

    Plan We Had In Mind

    1st floor of one version given to us

    2nd floor of one version given to us

  • 10 years ago

    Random comments.

    As before - your tweaks are really fundamental changes to the design that require real talent to pull off.

    You would be SO MUCH BETTER starting from scratch with someone who has some talent. (like even the people that designed this lovely home to begin with!).

    Based on what you got back - Mark's statement of horror story is right on.

    You are about ready to spend a buttload of money. DO NOT PASS GO or go any further along this path unless you enjoy pain. And bankruptcy.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    There are no words to describe the disconnect among the three plans above. Time for a full-stop, and a new direction with an architect or other person of talent who knows what they are doing.

    Trying to achieve what you are describing to the existing stock plan is probably not going to be successful. You can tweek an existing plan, here and there, but you cannot simply make it over and have it in any way resemble the existing plan.

    That may account for the disconnect above in the plans.

    You really need experienced and creative help.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Sigh. Having no frame of reference, I just wasn't sure what to expect, nor am I qualified to say this plan or that plan is sound except as a consumer. So I guess the plan we got back would be considered unsatisfactory in the architecture world. It certainly looked a bit wonky from my perspective. I think we the past few posts have been right. We need to request another designer with real experience.

  • 10 years ago

    Yikes!!!

  • 10 years ago

    Not sure this thread could go any worse. Poor lady has gone from frustrations with her designer to be threatened with copyright infringement...which honestly sounds like a load of crap to me, although I admit I'm ignorant of the finer points of how copyright law would apply to floorplans.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Wow, very classy input from Dan the designer of the nice original plan.

    Now that's the way to present yourself as a professional in a difficult situation.

    Kudos!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Social media monitoring tools are everywhere. And a reminder that there are real people behind a company name. Dan is way more professional than, say, "No Tesla for You!" Elon Musk.

  • 10 years ago

    @Sater Design Collection, Inc.

    First of all, congratulations on an elegant and gorgeous plan. I have all the variations on my Pinterest page as a reference. Second, I didn't mean to disparage your design. It's not a that it's problematic (except for the lack of a pantry in that size of a house, sorry I just found that odd). It just doesn't meet our particular needs in many ways. Most of the issues I've mentioned have been from the dissatisfaction of the design our designer has put together. Particularly since he is not drafting the Salcito, just using it as in inspiration. At least that is what we were hoping for.

    The Italianate/courtyard plan is what we're looking for. The courtyard being one of the most important aspects. Yours was not the only design we showed our designer. It was just the closest I could find that to what we want (L shaped, house built around a courtyard, 2 stories and a space at the front for a guest house.)

    I realize that your plan is copyrighted, so what I asked was for our designer to begin with the general L shape and to make sure to have the house surround the courtyard. I admit, the Salcito was our go to inspiration because he just does not understand what we want. Believe me, your copyright is in no way being infringed upon by our designer. Not. Even. Close. At this point, I'm just trying to get an L shaped house.

    Buying the Salcito plan is something we considered. But the changes we want will make the design vastly different. I have no idea if the cost for such changes would be akin to hiring a local, experienced architect. You may still end up hearing from us.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I'm not a fan of preconceived plans, but I think it would be best if you gave Dan a call.

  • 10 years ago

    The Sater Group site says: "Homes are designed from the inside out. Once the floor plan is finalized, then work starts on the exterior elevation. It will start with an Elevation Prelim, as with the Floor Plan Prelim this is a back and forth process. This is when the design starts to take on character."

    I've always thought homes should be designed as a whole, both inside and outside at the same time?


  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    cpartist,

    Ahh the lifelong debate. Does "Form follow Function" as Sullivan said or is it "Form and Function are One" as Wright so famously stated? :-)

  • 10 years ago

    Busted.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ahh the lifelong debate. Does "Form follow Function" as Sullivan said or is it "Form and Function are One" as Wright so famously stated? :-)

    Honestly, I'll go with what the architects on this site feel is the best way, which is it all needs to be designed as a whole. In the best designs I've seen, the house relates to the environment and is not just stuck onto the lot. The best designs integrate it all into a whole.

    I'm an artist. If I'm drawing a still life of a bowl of flowers sitting by a window sill, I don't draw the vase and flowers with all the minute details before tackling the background and the window sill. (That's something beginning students tend to do, not experienced artists.) I work the overall feel of the drawing first, blocking in the larger shapes, slowly refining both the foreground and background and only once I have the overall composition, do I start to refine my details.

    So I'll block in the shape of the vases, and the overall, general shape of the flowers, the window, the ledge, working back and forth between all the elements. Next I'll slowly add broad areas of shadow and light to the shapes, which will slowly start to define the objects. Then I'll refine the shapes more, working from background to foreground, and at each step I refine it a bit more until near the end, I start to really hone in on the details.

    From what I can see, good home design isn't much different. Start with the larger, overall picture and slowly refine it down to the details.

    Seems to me that designing a house from the inside out is similar to putting the details in the vase before the background in a drawing is even fleshed out.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I only read the first half of the posts here (and a couple of the last ones) -- but I don't care how "nice" this guy is, you need someone you can WORK with. I agree that most of the changes he made that you list towards the top are unreasonable. You NEED someone else. He apparently lacks real experience in living in a functional house. And you do need some good guidance to make this home as functional as possible for your specific needs.

  • 10 years ago

    @ artemis_ma. Yeah, I guess I already knew the answer. I'm just dragging my feet. Everything seems to confirm this is turning into a big, expensive problem.

  • 10 years ago

    @Andy The designs we received would actually have to resemble the floor plan in question for there to be an infringement. Yeah, that's not going to happen. I finally got sick of the whole thing, so I found another L-shaped courtyard plan by another company that has a better layout, so there are very few changes. I plan on buying it and a new designer will make the few changes. Win Win for everyone! But this time, we're walking the lot to make sure the plan is suited for the space. Phew.

  • 10 years ago

    Best of luck and really take the time to make sure it is sited to take best advantage of your lot.

  • 10 years ago

    Good advice. Thanks!

  • 9 years ago
    @Veronica. I think your architect maybe tweeting your Sater floor plan to his modification to avoid infringements on possible copyrights law. Best to check before going ahead with this plan or rather draw our your sketch on a paper and ask him to modify to your specific wishes. Best wishes with your build.