Software
Houzz Logo Print
ebony_clark69

HELP! Black scales on jade.

10 years ago

HELP!


I have a beautiful jade plant that once belonged to my late beloved grandmother, so it's very sentimental and precious to me. She kept it in her front yard - facing south - and likely just let it be.


When she passed, I brought this beautiful plant home and put it outside on our pool patio. It's screened in, gets tons of sun and rain, and faces west.


But it seems it's sick. It has raised black spots on the leaves and they're slowly falling off and it's BREAKING MY HEART.


Do any of you have any idea what it is and how I can nurse her back to health?

Comments (19)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    It may not be scale, at least not all of it. IMO, if there was so much scale, you would see some on the stems too - I can't see any in your photo. Are there bumps like that on stems? Did you try wiping it off with moistened tissue/rag/cotton ball? Some even use just fingernail...If scale, it would wipe off.

    If you have to force it off and it leaves a scar/hole into the leaf tissue, it is likely not scale. Some of it is probably oedema (edema) - happens when plant is taking on too much water, more than it can transpire. Some could be a fungus, like mildew.

    *What kind of soil is it potted in?

    *Is there a drainage hole in the container? Also, that kind of container (with recurving top) could make it difficult to repot plant, especially if the plant grew some new stems and especially good root system (root ball could be large and difficult to take out of smaller top opening).

    *What is your general location? *How much is 'tons of rain'? *Is it very humid where you live?

  • 10 years ago

    I'll have to go do the scrape test tomorrow - and check the stem for black spots as well. I live in Florida - so it's VERY humid and VERY rainy. In fact, it's raining now so I didn't have a chance to bring it under shelter today. And I'll need to check for drainage as well.


    As far as the soil, I'm not sure. It's been the same soil since I got it from my grandmother so I have no idea.


    I was thinking I should - if I don't repot just yet - add some drainage holes if it didn't have any. If I can't, I'll likely have to break the current pot and repot in something similar in size, but with a grittier, sand-type soil with drainage holes and maybe even a rock base.


    If it is scale, I'm happy to treat each leaf one-by-one if necessary since I had to do the same thing for one of my gardenias and it was so worth it. I guess it's just a matter of determining that tomorrow.


    THANK YOU! I'm so hopeful I can get her well again!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ebony

    No sand! In the humid climate it will be even worse. And no rock base - it doesn't help at all. What you should be aiming for is the mix with grit, and perlite or pumice. Soe ppl use 50/50 mix of Cactus&Succulent soil with perlite or pumice. I believe that in very humid and wet climate, it would be better to use even grittier mix.

    Drainage holes can be drilled in many containers. It may be simpler just to buy one with drainage holes in it already. The plant doesn't need bigger pot, only one with drainage. Hope you don't have to break existing pot...I did learn the hard way -:(

    One of our members, Crenda, is in humid Florida, she posts about it quite often. I hope she will see your post and gives you some tips.

    Post about your finding about the marks/spots pls.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi there!

    OMG I'm so happy to have help from both of you!


    I'm in Tampa - the lightning capital of the world, to be exact - as was my grandmother. And it's hot and humid 10.5 months out of the year. I'm sure you're familiar, @crenda. ;)

    So it rained last night, and after everything I'd been told and been reading, I panicked and sent my poor, incredibly helpful husband to go bring her in under the covering of the pool patio/lanai.

    The stems are in perfect condition, as pictured below. There doesn't seem to be a lot of soil of any kind left in there, and when we started to move the pot to drill a few drainage holes (there was one big one already, but we added 3-5 small holes just in case), we noticed that the bottom of the pot is VERY raised (like the underside of a wine bottle) so the roots are super cramped with very little room for soil of any kind.

    I did the 'scrape test' and brown bumps/blisters do come off, but leave a pock mark behind. And with rubbing alcohol and a cotton ball, nothing comes off. Not even slightly.

    So it seems - if your experience and suggestions are any indication - that this is edema.


    Since she's now sheltered, can you tell me what her ideal conditions would be and how I can nurse her back to health? She is one of the most beautiful jades I've ever seen.

  • 10 years ago

    I thought mine had scale too but it looks like it's edema.


    CLICK HERE FOR MY THREAD

  • 10 years ago

    Great pictures in your thread, Nancy! Good for Ebony to compare with.

    Unfortunately, the edema spots will not go away. But as the plant grows and gets new leaves, the spotty leaves will be replaced by good, clean growth. It really won't take as long as you fear.

    My jades don't grow much in the summer. When it is so hot, they pretty much shut down. The good thing is - it is now October and our rainy season is about over. The temps and humidity will go down and our jades will perk up!

    Even if your grandmother had a great potting mix for her jade - and I'm guessing she did since it is a nice plant! - it is probably degraded now. I see some moss growing on top of the soil, and that tells me it is pretty moist in there. (of course it is! It's our rainy summer!) Drainage is imperative for us Floridians, and that means more than holes in the pots. I don't see any signs of rot in your plant, but excess water can enhance chances for edema, too.

    Many people use cactus and succulent soil mixed with perlite, a 50/50 ratio. It works great for them, but not for me. It stays wet too long during our summers. I've progressed through several mixes, getting grittier each time. Now I used granite grit, some turface and perlite. No soil at all. My plants are much happier.

    There is no rush to repot, but I would recommend that you do so this month to give your jade a leg up for the growing season. (You mentioned that there isn't much soil left in the pot.)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ebony

    The raised bottom of the container was/is good, since it keeps the roots from too much water; and if there was a drainage hole - even better.

    It would be most likely best to repot the plant into mix that is quite gritty - it helps in the wet and humid climate. I am sure Crenda will chime in.

    When/if you do that, check the existing stems, especially close to soil line - gently squeeze to feel if they are firm. If anything is soft and dark, there could be some water damage. I can't see any in the photos.

    I would not leave the plant in constant rain (do not know how often it rains where you are), but if you pot it in very grainy mix, it will help a lot with extra rain water. If you keep it somehow sheltered, I believe you'll see much less leaf drop.

    Eventually, you should do some pruning. I see some branches that are long and 'leafless', also there are too many - especially in the center of the plant. Pruning those off will help the air circulation which is very important in your humid loc. Btw, every clipping could make a new plant, so you could be inundated with jade plants if you keep them, lol.

    Lets wait 'till Crenda post about her preferred mix (I use mix of grit, perlite and some turface - no soil at all and it drains very well). It could be potted up in just grit, or grit+perlite, or grit+pumice...

    edited to add: Crenda already posted as I typed...

  • 10 years ago

    For my first succulent, I bought a commercial Cactus & Succulent mix. Within a year, I discovered that it held too much water. And since we tend to get rain almost every day during the summer, I had a real recipe for disaster.

    So as suggested by many people, I mixed the soil with 50% perlite by volume. It looked like this - - and it still held too much water for our conditions.

    So I moved on to a 1-1-1 gritty mix. That was one part granite grit or perlite, one part turface and one part bark repti-bark. This, too, held too much water for my conditions, so I stop using the bark. Also, the bark degraded in about a year and a half in this mix.

    So I went to using one part Turface, one part perlite and one part granite grit. I was surprised to find this was still a little too wet for our summers. And someone suggested that I use less Turface, the part of the mix that hold moisture. That seems to have worked for me!

    We're not kidding when we say gritty mix, are we? LOL Ask away with more questions as you have them! The particles are about the size of aquarium gravel. My plants stayed out in the sun and rain this year and I don't see any edema - yet.

    BTW - my son live in Temple Terrace, near the University. I think he enjoyed USF so much that he doesn't want to leave! LOL

  • 10 years ago

    You all are THE BEST!

    I will do all that has been recommended above, especially since we're nearing the end of the humid and rainy season, so i feel that I should take advantage of these more (hopefully) mild conditions. So that would be:

    1. Prune 'empty' branches, especially in the center. (If you have tips for how to prune/where, please advise!)

    2. The pot now has 4-6 drainage holes. I can add more if you think I should.

    3. Repot maybe - to something bigger? Wider? Please advise.

    4. Use one part Turface, one part perlite and one part granite grit. (Where would I find this?)

    5. She's now sheltered from the rain and direct sunlight, getting most sun around sunset since she's facing due west.

    Anything else I'm missing? Again - THANK YOU!



  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ebony

    You likely do not need bigger container, I just mentioned that it may be difficult to take plant out (either now or later) since the op opening is narrower than 'body' of the container. Drainage sounds very good with the extra holes.

    From Crenda's post: ...So I went to using one part Turface, one part perlite and one part granite grit. I was surprised to find this was still a little too wet for our summers. And someone suggested that I use less Turface, the part of the mix that hold moisture. That seems to have worked for me! ...

    I would make a mix using grit and perlite (or pumice if you can get it) in approx. equal amounts. You could leave out turface if you don't have any or can't find. If you use it, I wouldn't add much more than 10-20% (maybe less?) of total volume.

    I would prune off all skinny branches in the center of the plat to open it up for better air circulation:

    I would cut those off completely, closer to the trunk, leaving short stub - approx. 1/4". This will scab over and eventually scab will fall off, leaving pretty smooth surface. It is very difficult to tell you exactly which branches to cut off - the couple I marked with red are easy for me to see. You need to use your judgement...if not sure, do just few and wait few days. Eventually you'll see what 'interferes' and should go.

    On 'outside', there are many branches that are just as long, skinny and leaf-less. They should be pruned off (same as above) or shortened. You could possibly leave that for later. If you repot into new mix, plant should start growing healthier leaves. You could decide then which branches to get rid off. Let see what Crenda will suggest for pruning.

    For pruning, use a sharp knife or blade, wiping it with a towel moistened with rubbing alcohol.
    Give the plant all the sunlight you can, just keep out of too much rain.

    Any pieces/branches you cut off could be potted to grow new plants if desired. If you want to do that, let us know - will give you few tips.

  • 10 years ago

    My only suggestion on pruning would be to wait a couple of weeks. It's still hitting 90 and we are getting a lot of rain from the disturbances caused by Matthew.

    I had to prune a couple of jades with long, heavy branches. I blew it by not snipping this past spring. The clippings have not done well and I had to move them inside - a first for me. And the pruned branches have not yet budded new leaves after a couple of months. In fact, a couple of them shriveled back almost to the trunk. I think it is just too hot for recovery right now. They still may sprout new growth when we cool down some, and probably will.

    When we finally hit the end of rainy season, and it cools a little, go for it! Rina gave you some good starting suggestions.

  • 10 years ago

    Alright. I may hold off until the weather 'cools' - or at least drops from 90 degrees and 100% humidity. We don't get a lot of cooler weather down here, so it may not happen until December/January.

    When you say 'leafless,' you just mean branches that have leaves at the top, and nowhere else, right?

    And where can I get the components for the gritty mix? And would I just pour it into the existing container as the plant sits currently - meaning I don't need to repot or take it out to put the new gritty mix in, right?

    Sorry for all the questions, but I want to make sure I'm following your suggestions to the letter. :)



  • 10 years ago

    Ebony

    Yes, leafless just as the couple I marked for pruning off. They have just very few leaves on top - since they are struggling for light, the stem keeps growing taller & faster, trying to reach it. Etiolated (stretched) stems will stay like that, that's why they need to be pruned off or partially - depending on where exactly they are.

    As for where you can buy the supplies/components for the mix, I really do not know in your area. I buy chicken grit (small white granite chips) in farm supply store, in 50lb bags for just about CD $10 - very inexpensive. If you have only 1 or few plants, you may not need big bag; I add some to potting mixes for non-succulent plants, and also use it for top-dressing, so it goes fast. Perlite is available in small bags in many stores (garden centers, Lowe's, HomeDepot, Wallmart...). I would recommend to sift it, using ordinary kitchen sieve from a dollar store (best to do outside & do not breath the dust...). You could use pumice instead, if you can find it (on line, you could buy it from General Pumice Products, they ship free in US). Turface is used for golf courses and play fields, you need to find supplier. It could be substituted by product sold by Napa, I believe the # 8225?-sorry, not quite sure. Try searching this side, I believe there were posts about where to find supplies, just do not know about your loc. Hopefully someone from same are will post...

  • 10 years ago

    This thread discusses Turface and where we can find it. Near the bottom is a link to Ewing Irrigation. They carry the Turface MVP (recommended) and it looks like they have a store in Clearwater.

    http://forums.gardenweb.com/discussions/4004466/question-about-turface?n=12

    It's really best to remove all of the old soil from the roots instead of adding to the pot. The old soil, that may be broken down and water retentive, will still be surrounding the roots and causing problems. Chopstick, skewers and a blast from the hose will help remove that old soil.

    We need to think about how to get your plant out and hopefully not break Grandma's pot! No doubt, some roots will be broken in the process. I want to minimize that, so I am going to think that over some more. Maybe someone else has some suggestions to help on that!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Might I mention again just how much I love you ladies?!

  • 10 years ago

    Ebony, aren't you sweet!

    Those are the products you want.

    Petsmart carries the Manna Pro granite grit. Call to see if your local store has it. It's about $7-8. Granite is heavy and probably expensive to ship. I get mine at The Tractor Supply Store.

    Site One - which used to be John Deere Landscaping - carries Turface All Sport. That's what I am using because that is what I could find. It works fine, but the Turface MVP is better with larger particles and Ewing Irrigation carries that.

    And I get my perlite at Home Depot. Lowe's and Walmart also carry it. I do have to sift and wash it, but it's only $4.50 a bag.

    I hate to pay for shipping . . . so I probably use $20 in gas to run around and get my supplies instead. LOL

    Any place that sells bonsai supplies will have a good gritty mix for you, too. It might be a little pricey, but it will be made up and ready to use.

  • 10 years ago

    BEAUTIFUL! I bought a plant dolly for her today so I can easily move her out into the sun for a few hours and then give her shelter when it's raining etc.

    I'll buy the new gritty mix soon and replace the old soil with it. I've pruned a few 'leafless' branches, but only a handful since I want her to get a little stronger first.

    I may pop back over here if any other questions arise, and hopefully again in a few months with an updated photo of my rejuvenated jade - it's not easy to remember anything these days with three little ones running around but I'm going to try to remember.

    Thank you so, so much for your help! I feel confident I was in the most capable hands, and for that I'm incredibly grateful considering how much this plant means to me.


    xo E.