Software
Houzz Logo Print
wendy_pitcher

Exterior Paint Choice Advice

10 years ago
Any help would be very welcome! We just had all our windows replaced. We are disappointed that the exterior window frames are much wider than we expected. Anticipating narrower width frames we had painted and had installed a smart board trim that we thought would coordinate with the decking. It doesn't work...not with the windows, not with the roof and not over all......now what? We can reprint the smart board trim, paint the house, or paint house and smart board trim. We have always wanted a warmer colour so painting the house is ok but we have no idea if we should keep the smart board trim colour or change it to white. Would white make the window frames way too big? Any suggestions on what colours to use if we started all over and painted the smart board trim and house?

Comments (28)

  • 10 years ago

    The sun glare on your roof is making it a little tough to see what color it actually is. You'll want to coordinate with that though. For example, you can't really pull off a gray house if your roof is brown.

  • 10 years ago

    Since your railings and front door are white, I wouldn't paint the smart trim white. I think that would be too much. Your deck wood looks untreated. Do you have plans to stain or paint that, too?

  • 10 years ago

    Roof looks brown. How about a white house?

  • 10 years ago

    How about a dark blue almost navy ? It would look nice with the white and wood trim color

  • 10 years ago
    Wow...such a fast reply...thank you. The roof looks grey in some light but actually has browns in it.....will try to take another photo. The deck has been stained the same colour as the posts on the side and back of house under the deck. It is Benjamin Moore Greenfield Pumpkin. We are stripping it since the stain did not hold up and redoing it in the spring ....my husband is looking into a new product ...I believe it will be a cedar colour.
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    It seems your house has a modern/contemporary vibe. I am loving dark color exteriors with this style. You can punch it up and keep some trim white or paint it dark too and pop the front door color. If your roof is more gray, you can do a charcoal or even a navy. If your roof is more brown, I'd do a taupe color. Check out these screen shots from Houzz when I searched dark exteriors!
  • 10 years ago
    Here is a photo of our garden shed....what do you think of using the same colour on the house and keeping the BM Greenfield Pumpkin trim around the windows?
  • 10 years ago

    Shed roof shingles same as house shingles? If so, and you like the gray color, why not? You can always decide to repaint the pumpkin trim later if you don't like it.

  • 10 years ago
    The shed roof colour is not the same as the house. I am waiting for good light to try to take a photo of house roof. The colour of the shed siding is actually a dark brown with a greenish tinge not grey. In my photo above I have placed some of the Greenfield Pumpkin smart board against the shed. I will attach a couple more photos of the shed to try to show colour better.
  • 10 years ago
    I am really appreciating the help......thank you! Took some more photos to better show colour of roof...will take another in different light and also shed colour and a piece of shed siding against BM Greenfield Pumpkin trim on house.
  • 10 years ago

    Those pictures are very helpful. I'm actually loving the idea someone mentioned before about a dark blue. Take a look at Benjamin Moore Hale Navy.

  • 10 years ago
    I took a look at the navy colour. I like the colour on houses and our neighbour has a similar colour so don't want to go with a blue. What do you think of the brown shed siding colour? It is CanExel siding colour called walnut..dark brown with a greenish tinge. We live in a mountain town and I am leaning more towards earth tone colours.
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Ok so it's sounds like my navy recommendation is out! My other suggestion was taupe, which is a darker brownish color with green undertones. Perhaps the taupe I'm thinking of is a few shades darker than your shed color (since I was recommending go dark). I'm not a fan of the pumpkin trim, but it may look very good with a taupe. Like someone said above, paint the trim last!
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Here's a dark taupe with white trim....then pain your front door the pumpkin color!
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Then, here's a really dark taupe, more like brown, with white trim. And another lighter taupe with a dark brown and white trim! Can't wait to hear what you decide!
  • 10 years ago
    Thanks Kelli. I am going to play around with the Sherwin Williams app and see what looks good....good thing it's too cold to paint now....I have until spring to make final decision.
  • 10 years ago
    I think it looks very nice. You just need to get used to it with the new windows and you will probably be fine with it in a few more days.
    Wendy Pitcher thanked felizlady
  • 10 years ago
    Maybe paint the foundation wall, if anything.
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    You're welcome Wendy! I'm a 100% Sherwin Williams gal and the app is awesome. Make sure you notice the feature where you can check the sample house in daylight or nightlight!
  • 10 years ago
    I would either paint to match siding or white to match windows. It requires more work to paint siding and trim.
    Wendy Pitcher thanked kathleen MK
  • 9 years ago
    These are the colours we decided on BM HC103 Cromwell Grey for body colour and BM OC 150 Brilliant White for trim around windows etc. What do you think?
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Looks Good! You'll need to show a few more images when its all done. What did you decide to paint the front door?


  • 9 years ago
    Thanks Kelli we are really happy with the body colour....still working on trim....we know we want white for the trim....tried BM White Dove but it was too creamy against the over wide window frame....we need to get as close to the white on the frame for it to work. We tried BM Bright White but we think it will be too bright so we are off to the paint store today to find a better white. We are ordering a new door....fibreglass with glass (Sort of Craftsman style) with a full sidelight. We want more of a wood look for the door....we will need to decide on the colour to paint it......we have such high heat exposure at that door that I think we will need to have it done by a body shop. Any suggestions on door or trim colours? I am attaching a photo of the window with white dove painted on left and bright white on bottom.
  • PRO
    9 years ago
    I think I like the bright white!!! If your feeling it's too bright, talk to the store about tinting it with a drop of your gray body color. This could tone down the brightness while giving it a matching hue. The store should be able to help you with this. Be sure to try a small amount before they tint the whole can!!!!

    I liked the idea of a pumpkin colored door! A wood tone would look great too! Something rich! You could even do an orangey stain.
  • PRO
    9 years ago
    Oops.....I see it's a fiberglass door, not wood.....so I still like the idea of pumpkin. Or a more wood tone color would be an orangey brown. If you have to go the auto body route, it will be very shiny! I'd keep the trim around the door white to match the other trim. A color stands alone and looks best on the door only :)
  • 9 years ago
    Thanks! Never thought of adding a bit of the Cromwell Grey...we will talk to them today and try a sample. Painters are coming in the next couple of weeks....getting excited. Yes for the door we were thinking of the kind of colour we have on the base of the deck.....if you look at the posts at the back of the house or lattice at the side....that we are leaving as is.
  • 9 years ago
    All finished. We are happy with how it turned out. We are taking the summer off from renovations and will decide on what to do about the front door in September! Thanks for all the advise and comments.