How about a dark green for the garage and front door. Think jaguar green. Trim black to match shutters or else paint shutters and trim a rich brown.

Jamie, sadly the garage door is dominating the front facade of your home. When I am challenged with that problem I make a design statement with the garage doors. Adding false iron hardware (hinges and door pulls) You can add a ton of personality and character to the front of your home. If you visit the project photos on my profile page you will see a few examples of garage door designs. Also, I like to look at the "color combinations" available at most paint stores for suggestions regarding body/trim/accent colors. I hope this helps! Enjoy....