Software
Houzz Logo Print
sandysnewhouse

Gas Fireplace - Log or no logs, how to decide

13 years ago
We are planning for new home construction. Yesterday we were to make our selections for fireplace. My husband and I had different ideas of what we wanted and now I am second guessing.
We are building a colonial or french provincial influence home, the exterior will have a traditional, symmetrical look. We are including some distressed hardwood, crown molding and wainscoting so there is traditional influence on the interior as well. I expect many of my fabric and furniture choices to be less traditional though with lots of clean lines. I was drawn to the gas inserts without logs, my husband thinks they are too modern. I figured that mantel, stonework, surround could influence the look. I feel like logs might look dated and I really love how the rocks look...am I wrong here, do the landscape, log free fireplaces belong in very modern design? I also want something that won't look out of style 10 years late.
Thanks!!

Here are some rooms that we like...
Traditional Indoor Fireplaces · More Info

Home Staging Hingham, Scituate, South Shore, MA · More Info

Great Neighborhood Homes · More Info

Comments (20)

  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I don't see how logs could look dated...that's rather like saying a sink might look dated. The logs will make it look more like a real fire. But other than that I don't think it will matter too much. The fireplace surround will determine the style and feel of the fireplace. Most people probably wont' notice logs or no logs.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Love it!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    And even with that more contemporary insert, I don't think logs are going to make or break the design. This might be a great place to compromise and earn the final decision somewhere else ;)
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    gas logs look very realistic and you can even get an accessory that makes a crackling noise :)
  • 13 years ago
    I love the look of the modern fireplace just above. I live in a very traditional style home and we have a real fireplace in one area. But, my husband is going to do a "mancave" and it will have pool table and a modern looking fireplace as above. So perhaps since your husband likes the log look you could do that in the room with the other traditional elements and in a different area go with the more recent modern look.
    The reason I say recent modern look is that when I toured the Vanderbilt Mansion in Asheville, there were items that I thought were recent modern looks but actually, were from the turn of the century.

    Have fun with your new house. It sounds amazing.
  • 13 years ago
    Personally I think logs look more realistic and I agree logs in a fireplace can't look dated considering that is what was meant to go in a fireplace in the first place.
  • 13 years ago
    I noticed that all of the scenes you liked had logs. That may tell you something:-)
  • 13 years ago
    Sense of Space: I like the design of the fireplace in that left photo. Nice!

    Sandysnewhouse:
    The house you describe and the examples of fireplaces you included make me think: logs. And no, they won't look dated. In fact, the landscape log free design will probably look dated sooner than a more traditional looking one.
    But I do like the landscape design, so perhaps Carolina Photo To Go gave you the best solution there.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Why not both?? Check out the Regency Horizon HZ40 with optional driftwood logs (surround is optional as well)
    Living Room · More Info
  • 13 years ago
    what else would you burn in a fireplace? it's a fireplace :) fire-cracked rock is used for other things. logs are elegant. you are so lucky, i'm sure your home will be beautiful.
  • 13 years ago
    logless does seem more contemporary. i love my gas logs in the greatroom. may add something like the regency in the owners suite this fall.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    It looks beautiful just the way it is :)
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Simple yet elegant
  • 13 years ago
    I like the fireplace you chose, with or without logs. We have a gas, Heat and Glo FP, more traditional with yours with logs...when it's lit, the logs get reddish, like real logs..and when it's not on, they really don't look bad at all. Either way, I think yours could look great!
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you for the comments everyone, I appreciate the feedback!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I love the contemporary look you're considering. Is it such that you could change it out for logs in the future if you wanted to? Friends in a new house have gas fireplaces in which they are placing stone (?) balls of varying sizes. But I know they could do logs later if they wanted.
    Carolyn Albert-Kincl, ASID
    Barton Creek Residence · More Info
  • 13 years ago
    You may have already made your decision, but I put a propane insert in our regular fireplace that was nondescript, and I picked the bowl of clear glass. I'm like you. I was afraid the logs were outdated. We can always put logs in later if we want.
  • 13 years ago
    I hadn't considered that logs might be optionally added...I will check into that, thanks! Perhaps I can change it up at some point.