Our existing door

I would repaint the entire house before purchasing doors. A simple pop of color would give a much updated look needed. If the roof color must stay I would choose a palette to compliment, then add or update your entrance lighting to something unique & bold & expensive looking...The high contrast shutters above need to soften.

Think about going with a painted front door. You can tie in the paint color to a bench, or pottery color with pretty flowers. Do a Houzz search or look on Pinterest at all the painted door options. Having a colored front door in a deep pumpkin color, or maroon is a very striking way to update your entire streetscape.