Software
Houzz Logo Print
mrblubs22

Is this scale?

9 years ago

Recently my lemons have begun 'acting' strange.

A couple weeks ago one of them (there's 5 in a pot) started getting brown in the middle of its leaves. I didn't think much as none of the others had it so I thought it was just losing the competition to the other more dominant plants.

Then just a few days ago another one of my lemons started doing the same thing. Except it's not exactly the same.

Can anyone tell what's causing this?

Here's a leaf of the first lemon which was just the browning

And here's the one which I'm thinking (hoping not) might have scale? It causes these blemishes on the top of the leaves


They're in 50 perlite 50 potting mix and are situated in a South window. They're in too small of a pot and have their roots growing out of the drainage holes which is impeding on the drainage a bit.

Currently only the one lemon has the issue as the first 2 images and only one has the other issue.

I was going to try to wait to repot but I'm thinking I should quickly get the 3 good strong lemons out of there and leave these two in quarantine.

I've never delt with scale before, but I thought they easily came off by scraping them with yoyr finger nail. The bumps under these leaves do not come off that easily at all. Yet I don't know what else it would be.


Comments (7)

  • 9 years ago

    "For a start scale is usually underneath leaves along the veins."

    Not at all true. Scale insects, including those common to citrus, will be found on the upper surfaces of leaves and even the stems. I don't know of any scale that is typically found only under the leaves.

    I'm wondering if these symptoms are that of oedema, not uncommon with indoor citrus and other plants. Oedema of plants is caused by a physiological and environmental imbalance. We see it often when houseplants are exposed to darker, cooler temperatures in the winter but an excess of water.

    MrBlubs thanked rhizo_1 (North AL) zone 7
  • 9 years ago

    Oh dear - seems I'm wrong again. Perhaps I wasn't clear enough. I was speaking from my personal experience. I had a Meyer lemon for over 15 years and when it had scale, which it did periodically, it was almost all under the leaves. Note I said 'usually', not 'always'. Of course, it was also along the stems but I was talking about why I didn't consider the OP's problem to be scale, so I was discussing leaves, not stems, since that is what is shown in the photos. Not many of my plants get scale. The only other one is Schefflera and on that too the vast majority of scale is beneath the leaves and on the stems. Very rarely on the upper surface. BTW it seems there are 25 species of scale in the UK and over 1000 in N America. The RHS describes them thus: "Scales or shell-like bumps on plant stems and the underside of leaves." (My italics). Apparently ours ours prefer to hide. Perhaps it's the weather;-)

    MrBlubs thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 9 years ago

    Thankyou for your responses!

    The bumps are only found on the bottom of the leaves and no where else. They are just causing yellow spots on the top of the leaves.

    It could possibly be odema as we had a week and a half of -20 to -30 C weather and very few bits of sun. Thus rather cold and the mix wouldn't dry out normally. Yet I don't know why it would only show up on 2 out of 5 lemons when they are all in the same pot. And why one would turn brown with not bumbs and the other would have bumps?

    I think I'll repot them either way just to make sure they get into something that has proper drainage and away from eachothers roots.

    Here's some more close ups of the bumps.

    I'm glad that it may not be scale!

  • 9 years ago

    Can you take ridiculously close close-ups?

    MrBlubs thanked Amynoacids (z6 MI)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thanks for the close-up view, that clinches the diagnosis.

    The diagnosis is edema, sometimes spelled oedema.

    The affected areas are usually quite small at first, and are seen on the back (sometimes also, or, on the top) surface. At that time, they appear water-soaked.

    Later on, the lesions become corky as shown in the above close-up views.

    Not a disease. Not critters. Instead, environmental.

    MrBlubs thanked Jean
  • 9 years ago

    That's as close as I can get! :)

    Thanks Jean! Never knew that oedema could cause bumps. Glad it's not scale!

    I repotted them today, something I'm sure they'll greatly appreciate. Got a nice big drainage hole that isn't clogged with roots! Hopefully they'll respond okay to the repot. Guess it wasn't a good idea to do on the shortest day of the year! Though, I think they needed it.

    Thanks everyone!