Software
Houzz Logo Print
jacquiw162

La Canche or Blue Star?

9 years ago

I thought we wanted a La Canche range but just went to Elgot in NYC and the salesman insisted that Bluestar was the best. Thoughts?

Comments (12)

  • 9 years ago

    In general salespeople push what gives them the most commissions and/or the least amount of problems. There's really no right answer to your question because what might be best for me might not work well for you.

    I read every relevant post on this and other forums. Watched every youtube video I could find and ordered a Bluestar electric wall oven and a Wolf induction cooktop. (Now if only the freight company would send it out on a truck that has a lift gate so it could be unloaded...)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Most appliance stores do not recommend Lacanche for the simple reason that they don't sell it, and that's understandable. Just like the Mercedes salesman won't tell you that "the other brand you are looking at" is better, even if it is.

    There are plenty of posts on both brands here, and fans of both also, I dont think you can go wrong either way. Just a different product for different needs / wishes.

    Good luck with your decision!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I can't speak about Blue Star, but I absolutely love my Lacanche! I wouldn't own another range.

  • 9 years ago

    Personally I was not a fan of the more industrial construction of the Blue Star - it seemed of lesser quality in build to me than the Lacanche, which is what we bought. The Lacanche was of course a lot more $$$ but we have been very happy both with the quality of the build and it's awesome functionality. My only concern initially was that the Bluestar had higher BTUs but I have been fully powered for my own cooking needs with our Lacanche Volnay. I would highly recommend a Lacanche.

  • 9 years ago

    I've never cooked on LaCanche, but I do love my BlueStar!

  • 9 years ago

    I don't have enough experience to tell you about living with them, but in general Blue Star is for people who love dragon's breath and want everything hot, and Lacanche is for people who love the elegance and features. I, personally, would choose the Lacanche. You can get power burners, induction, and anything else you fancy, but I'd want a big one. There's more similar to compare if you're talking 36" or under. Have you compared burner arrangements and power? Oven sizes? Accessories? Start there and see which matches your cooking needs better. Then make paper cutouts of what each would look like in your size/color choice and try it with your kitchen design. It should be pretty easy to choose once you've done those things...

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    These two could not be more different in every way. I would strongly suggest reading the various threads on this forum -- and there are many dating back quite some time -- on the two ranges. I think that will help make the decision.

  • 9 years ago

    Totally different machines, like comparing a 4x4 truck with a luxury sedan, neither is "better" than the other...

    BTW I have a Bluestar, ...and a four wheel drive truck ;)

  • 9 years ago

    LOL! They're ranges. Therefore they're much more similar than a range to a campfire. Like a luxury sedan and a 4x4 truck will both get you down the road with some people and some stuff, which is what most people mostly do with either. (Great analogy, Cookncarpenter!) It's only in the details that they differ. Those are the very details everybody is magnifying to point out the differences.

    The similarities I saw right off the bat was that these are the two production ranges that are easily obtained in colors. That's a HUGE similarity.

    But then you have to decide between luxury appurtenances and climbing an icy driveway....

  • 9 years ago

    It's like saying "what car is the best"? Someone might say "Bentley" but many people would be better served by a Toyota or Lexus. OP gave us no information and has not come back so we really don't know what "best" means to her.

  • 9 years ago

    Stan, there's a guy in the area who has a top of the line Rolls. He prefers driving his little Toyota, and uses the Rolls when he needs a bigger car.