Software
Houzz Logo Print
dawn_marie88

New bud. . .do I NEED to remove it.

9 years ago


This is my first rose bud in 5 years!!! I am so excited! But it is on my brand new, potted last weekend, Old Town Novato. Would it hurt to let it bloom just this once and then remove buds so it grows stronger?

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago

    I always let at least the first bud open, if only to confirm identity. If the rose seems to want to grow like gangbusters, I don't bother disbudding. If the rose seems more intent on making blooms than growing, I'll disbud.


    :-)


    ~Christopher

  • 9 years ago

    What Christopher said.

    I am curious - why have you not had any other rose buds in 5 years?

    Jackie

  • 9 years ago

    Long story lol. First I went through a divorce and I no longer owned my own home. When I moved to Florida, I intended to grow some in pots but a few months after moving here, the car I was riding in was hit by a drunk driver. I was pregnant and they took him by emergency c-section because they didn't think I was going to make it. My shoulder was broken, my back in three places, my pelvis in 7 places and my lungs were mush (which is what almost killed me. I was on the vent longer than my baby!) The baby is perfect despite being 3 months premature. When I came home, I was still almost completely paralyzed from the waist down from the swelling, My left arm had to be completely immobile for months. Over the next year, I had to learn to walk again and adjust to some issues that I will always have. I'm not complaining, I have the most awesome man and we are going to get married on a pirate ship in St. Augustine this summer. I walk with a cane and have some balance issues, have permanent nerve problems with my hand and arm and probably will never be able to live without pain medication but I am grateful to be alive. So now I have Dave who is thrilled to help me and I can grow my roses again!

  • 9 years ago

    So glad that you're recovering. It sounds like you've really been through the ringer. And I'm even more glad you have such a good attitude. And roses can be great therapy, and a reason (excuse?!?!) to be out and about.

    I agree with Christopher; it depends entirely on the vigor of the rose and its propensity for setting blooms. I don't grow OTN, so I can't speak of it specifically. But if it's putting on a lot of growth, AND buds, I'd just let it do its thing. If it seems to be a slow grower...off with their heads! lol.

    John

  • 9 years ago

    I have a short season and could never bring myself to dis-bud any of my roses and they do just fine.

  • 9 years ago

    As you know all to well, life is short and anything can happen. Let it bloom! I'm glad that you and your baby both survived the accident and you sound like you have a great attitude and a good man, I wish you happiness and joy in your new marriage. Enjoy your roses!

  • 9 years ago

    Oh Dawn Marie, so sorry for your hard times, but I'm so glad you and your baby are well and happy! Your approach to life is beautiful and a real inspiration, and I am sure it will result in a stunning garden! I must confess, I have never, ever dis-budded a new rose. Or any rose, for that matter. I simply don't have the discipline, I can't help myself from wanting to enjoy every single bloom. As far as I can tell, they all do just fine. Maybe if I did dis-bud, they'd get bigger faster, but I fear I'll never find out, because I don't think I'll ever do it, lol! I guess, to me, it just feels like life's too short to miss out on any flowers. However I truly respect those who do have the self-control do dis-bud, and I'm sure it probably does have some good effects.

  • 9 years ago

    What a series of trials you have been through! I'm so glad things worked out well for you eventually.

    I am one who does disband young roses, more on some roses than on others. But like Christopher, I do let one bloom just to verify identity, and because I can't help it.

    Rosefolly

  • 9 years ago

    I'm with Seil..short season no way I'm disbudding anything

  • 9 years ago

    If you do need to disbud you need to do it as soon as you see the bud. I would call this "disblooming" and you sure don't want to do that!!!

    Susan