Software
Houzz Logo Print
daniela_ballantyne

Torn between two counters - please help.

9 years ago

I am torn between two looks for my kitchen island - marble look quartz, or a warmer pattern with movement. At first I thought I wanted a marble look, and I fell in love with the Viatera Minuet. However, the quote I received for Viatera Minuet for my island was higher than the quote I had for Cambria by a few hundred dollars. Given that our addition is already over budget before we even get started, that makes a difference to my choice.

My question now is which pattern to go with from Cambria. I love Berwyn for the light grey and white pattern with some sparkle, but there is a darker vein that I am not sure about. Then there is Torquay, which gives me the marble look, but some pictures of Torquay seem quite white with very sparse veining, and others have more veining (which I like). I understand that you do not get to choose your slab with Cambria.

I am looking for advice from anyone who has either Torquay or Berwyn in their kitchen, or has used them. I appreciate any feedback.

Attached is a picture of the cabinet colours and door style (white cabinets on the perimeter, and dark cabinets on the island), the floor tile and white beveled subway tile back splash. In the photo is a sample of Berwyn with our choice for the main cabinets, Caesarstone Pebble Grey. Our style is Transitional. As you can see, most of the choices
are pretty muted, so the island could pull off a dramatic pop.


Comments (19)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thanks Flo Mangan. We did change the hardware from the ornate handle at the top to the one at the bottom, but I do see your point. I am guessing that I am also probably more traditional than I thought. Thanks.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    It is always useful to figure out what style you like. It helps keep you focused. Especially on a new build. Best of luck. Don't let the bumps along the way get to you. Turn them into opportunities as much as you can. And there will be problems. But if you are aware, it will be easier.
    Daniela thanked Flo Mangan
  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'd suggest an idea book created from Houzz before you finalize. Personally......I'd change that cabinet style which feels just a bit dated, to something a little cleaner. And I'd reconsider the very dark island as well. Also, what is the flooring in the REST of your home?

    Daniela thanked JAN MOYER
  • 9 years ago

    Flo Mangan - Thank you. I admit, I feel completely over whelmed. I have never been so indecisive.

    Jan Moyer - Thank you for your suggestions. Again, a little over whelming, and I agree I have to figure out my style so I can start making informed decisions. Right now our home has pine floors which we will be replacing with hardwood. The kitchen and most of the main floor tile will be replaced with the grey tile at the bottom of the photo.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Daniela - just to make you feel a bit better, I can make design decisions for other people in seconds, but when I'm doing something for my own home, not so much!! lol So, it happens to all of us, and you are not unusual! Hang in there. It is a "process".

    Daniela thanked Flo Mangan
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you Kathi Steele!!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I agree with everything that Flo said, and would add that your hardware choice is really inappropriate for those cabinets. The Berwyn looks awfully busy, but Cambria Torquay seems like a good choice. I think if you want to stick with those cabinets, make the island cabinets a painted gray instead of wood, and find a more "transitional" pull style. In this kitchen the perimeter cabinets are white and the peninsula is Farrow and Ball Mole's Breath. The peninsula counter is Neolith Calacatta.

    Upper West Side II · More Info

    Daniela thanked Weil Friedman Architects
  • 9 years ago

    If you want lots of movement, then go with Berwiyn. The Torquay does not have much movement. We have it in the basement for the bar area. I'll go take a picture to show you. We like it, but we wanted something calmer, so that might not be what you are going for

    Daniela thanked printesa
  • 9 years ago

    Here is a photo of the counter. The light is not good since we are still missing a few lights there, but you get an idea

    Daniela thanked printesa
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Hi Daniela. Thank you for your question and it's fun to see your moodboard of inspiration for your kitchen plans as well. Berwyn is great choice with the color palette you have and will create a more traditional feel to your space. Feel free to browse our other marble collections, if Torquay may not have quite the movement you are looking for. https://www.cambriausa.com/marble-collection/ Swanbridge is a new favorite with strong movement, but a similar marble style. Brittanicca and Ella are also customer favorites with strong movement and modern feel. Feel free to follow us on Instagram as well as we feature real kitchens daily for additional inspiration @CambriaQuartz.

    Daniela thanked Cambria
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you Cambria! I am actually planning to visit your Toronto Showroom to see full slabs of Brittanicca, Swanbridge and Torquay for the island, paired with either Carrick or Dunmore on the main body of cabinets. After having the Berwyn sample at home for a few days, though stunning, I think I want the marble look.

    Thank you Printesa for the photo, and Weil Friedman Architects for the advice. :o)

  • 9 years ago

    Daniela, I brought home ~8 different samples and had them over a week end before I chose Bellingham. Look at them in your lighting, in your kitchen and see what speaks to you. I have had our Bellingham for 18 months now and I still catch my breath every time I walk into my "new" kitchen!!!

    Daniela thanked Kathi Steele
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you Kathi Steele! It's amazing how bringing home a sample and looking at in in your space helps rule some out, and highlight other ones. Thanks for the encouragement. :o)

  • 9 years ago

    I also had my sister. She is able to read my mind and she really helped me find my voice in my kitchen remodel!!! My husband and son voiced their opinions, but, she solidified what I was feeling!! I hope you can find someone that will help you erase your doubts!!

    Daniela thanked Kathi Steele
  • 9 years ago

    Any chance you live near Toronto Kathi? lol Thanks again for all of your encouragement. It's great to know I am not the only one who lost sleep over this decision, and it is reassuring to know that you made it through this process with a kitchen you love.

  • 9 years ago

    I forgot to mention that you can go and look at the slab before you have it delivered. We saw ours before even though for us, it was not a problem since Torquay didn't have as many chances to have pools of resin

    Daniela thanked printesa
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Printesa, that is good to know. :o)