Software
Houzz Logo Print
ps6fsu_de_z7

Tulip Poplar in bad shape?

9 years ago

Posted another thread to ask for suggestions on what trees to plant in place of a Tulip Poplar that I thought needs to come down. But now i have gotten some conflicting opinions from some local tree crews and im not sure what to do. I would prefer to keep the tree but my only worry is that it is only about 15 ft from the house. Originally, I had an arborist come to the house after we moved in to give us a consultation on our trees. When he was here he recommended some work being done on the Pin Oak out front and the Red Maple in the back but made no mention of this Tulip Poplar in question. I then got another estimate from a local tree company to do the same work and while he was on site he said this Poplar is rotting and needs to come down eventually. My wife then got another tree company to come out (bc other two estimates were very high) and he said the same thing. This morning I was planning to call one of the companies I had out and schedule the work to be done when I noticed a neighbor having some work done on their yard from a different tree company. I went over and asked him to stop by when he was done to look at this Poplar. I was surprised to hear him say that he didn't really think it needed to come down. I am lost at this point and not sure what to do now. Any thoughts? The 2nd photo is a closeup of the first photo and the 4th photo is a closeup of the 3rd.

Comments (10)

  • 9 years ago

    have you had an isa certified tree surgeon there ...


    https://www.google.com/search?q=isa+certified+tree+surgeon&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8


    or are you relying on guys who have chainsaws they like to run??? ... and i am surprised you found a guy with a chainsaw .. who said he didnt want to run it ..


    can we have some pix of the tree as a whole... and how it sits in regard to the house ...


    you seem in a hurry ... there rarely is a hurry with trees


    if you reference a prior post.. it would make it easier.. if you linked to it ... hope im not contradicting myself.. lol...


    ken



  • 9 years ago

    HERE is a link to the thread i mentioned. There are some pics there that show the tree from further back. The first guy I had out is from a reputable tree company owned by Davey and his card says he is ISA certified. However, I tried to verify his credentials using the number on his card and it doesn't return any results. He made no mention of the tree. The 2nd guy I had out advertises that they have an ISA certified arborist but im not sure if he was actually the one who gave me the estimate. He said the tree needs to come down but no rush. The third company that has a certified (and verified) ISA arborist but not the particular person who inspected my property. The last guy (company the neighbor was using) im not sure of. I need to call the company and find out. Im not really in a hurry but if the tree needs to come down im not going to procrastinate.

  • 9 years ago

    It's incredibly hard to try to solve this except in person.


    In case you haven't noticed, agreents on horticultural matters aren't uncommon.


    The pics above...is there any fluid duscharge? is any part of that little knob soft and squishy? Poke a little. if the answer is no, it's not a proximal problem.


    Honestly, the other pics you showed concern me more. there's a couple of cuts up high on the tulip tree that a good look at would answer a lot of questions. also, it looks like an old tree compared to surroundings? is that right?

  • 9 years ago

    There doesn't seem to be any soft spots when poking at it. I don't know the age of the tree. We just moved on to this house in the summer. The home was built in 1959.

  • 9 years ago

    Two spots. The 2nd photo is a closeup of the first photo and the 4th photo is a closeup of the 3rd.

  • 9 years ago

    The tree and the house have lived together for a while. you say nothing that causes alarm in my mind, but then again...I haven't been there, and without eyes on, this is incredibly difficult.


    I'd keep some different folks coming out. maybe you can do it under the guise of an estimate, maybe you'll have to pay up a time or two for on site inspections.


    So you ask someone to come out and look at a tree. keep the language as open as possible, because as soon as you say, what about taking it down, you have self-selected the direction of the conversation.


    What you're looking for is someone you will answer your questions and you feel comfortable with. everyone comes into a conversation with an agenda...everyone. but if you're talking to a guy about a tree, knowing he makes money by taking it down, and if he says he really doesn't think it's necessary, he's advising he doesn't get paid. if he say yes it should be trimmed or removed, what's his reason? do other people agree with the reasoning?


    There's always certifications, more of those than I care to mention, insurance, various methods of checking out contractors. you're starting something a lot of people don't really know well, which is evaluating tree health. there's a lot of people who see a tree close to a house and the only thought they have is it has to come down.


    I assume the house is new to you? sorry if I missed that above. unless you see something that just scares the living bejessus out of you, i'd wait to see how things look once they leaf out. if nothing else, it'll give you a sense of how specific trees and the house relate to each other, and to the yard.


    P.S. zero-turn mower. you still need the lawn tractor for cleaning and working, but you'll love the zero-turn for mowing.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Wayne. Well said. I think i am going to look into paying an arborist (instead of free estimate) to come give me a real assessment. After all, if i keep the tree, that should be seen as recurring revenue for the tree company by means of trimming! I was really on the fence between zero turn and garden tractor to the point where my wife was annoyed by my stalling to make a decision. Ultimately I decided to go with the tractor so that I could pull a cart, use a dethatcher, and mount a plow to it for the winter. Its a bit oversized for my yard but the tractor I got has only a 5 degree turning radius so its almost the best of both worlds.

  • 9 years ago

    Update - Just had an arborist out who I really liked. He did a pretty thorough inspection of the tree and said he doesn't see the need to remove it. He suggested pruning some suckers and some thinning to allow wind to pass through but says overall the tree looks to be in good shape.

  • 9 years ago

    I have a silver maple beside my house with a HUGE hole in the trunk..... I really think it may fall. I wouldn't worry about that, from the pictures I don't see any big issues.