Software
Houzz Logo Print
mbaldauf6112

Help Choosing Dining Light which leads to more.

9 years ago

Hello. I'm cross posting this on the recommendation of someone on another forum.

We are in the final stages on new construction. I've held up really good until now and the lighting has me overwhelmed and feeling stressed so I'm coming here for advice and ideas.

Here's a little about us and the house. We're relaxed and fairly casual and like to have family and friends over. I'd describe our style as a mix of farmhouse meets lake house with a simple, welcoming but classy style. Our kitchen, dining and living are all open. Cabinets will be white shaker with a trim detail on the inset edge to soften that hard edge. Island will be Colonial White with a greige and white background, specks of grey, black, taupe and a hint of pinks in the granite. Walls will be SW Sea Salt, white trim and satin nickel hardware.

Dining table is a long farmhouse and we haven't chosen chairs yet. (Any suggestions here?)

I saw this light at a Parade of Homes in our area and fell in love with the cool shadows from the lighting. We want a rectangular or more linear look so I found this amazing, perfect light BUT it's way over budget. Our budget is tight so I'm stretching it as far as possible. For dining I'd like to stay around $400. I can go up to $500 if I find something that's perfect!

Heres some pictures of the house. We're painting this week so we're actually further along but these show the rooms,etc.


Kitchen is next to dining area and across from living area. Ceilings are 9'. Oh, the island will be SW Tricorn black distressed.


This is looking at dining area in the far corner.


Cabinet detail.

This is not the best picture but our wall paint, granite, white shiny subway tile and cabinets and trim are SW Snowbound.

Here's are my inspiration lights.

First is from the Parade of Home but is round and we feel a linear light would be better.

Second is my favorite light! It made my heart skip a beat when I saw it. Now, each time I see it I like it more and more. It feels like home. But it's $1,200!


Below is a good alternative to my heart stopping light but it's a little busier than what I prefer. It was suggested on the kitchen forum. I DO like it and like the rope/jute detail and that it's unique. Not a typical big box store light. Also, much more affordable!

How would I mix the finishes? Would the other kitchen and living room lights need to be dark or could this be the only dark fixture because it's near the black island?

Help!!! I'm in total overload mode and my brain might short circuit soon!

Thank you all.

Sunny


Comments (16)

  • 9 years ago

    You've made a lot of decisions! Good for you! I do love your inspiration light, but I also like the one that you show in photo 1. It probably isn't quite right for your farmhouse table if your table is long and rectangular though. But I do appreciate needing some curvy lines. I'm very linear myself and the basics in our home show it, so I had to sort of force more curves into accessories or wherever I could soften the edges. I'm betting you (or some others who are better at this than I) can find something on Wayfair, Overstock or some other sites that will be very close to your inspiration fixture. I agree the 3rd one is a bit busy, probably with all the fine mesh wire involved.

    Since your DR is a bit away from the kitchen, I believe you can go with a slightly different finish, much like in your inspiration photo, a soft bronze or distressed finish.

    What finish is your farmhouse table? How many chairs will you need? Are you wanting to do something upholstered, wood, or a mix?

  • 9 years ago

    Outside Playing - thank you so much.

    When I saw the round light in a parade home I knew I'd want something similar so found the amazing rectangular one at way over budget. I agree that we need something rectangular or as the last one even an elongated oval.

    Our table is being built and is made from an old pew bench from my great grandfathers church. Plans are for medium stain on table top and white distressed legs. I'm meeting with someone today who is hopefully going to add something like this below the table.

    I haven't even started thinking about chairs, yet. We're open to ideas.

    Thanks again!

    Sunny

  • 9 years ago

    You MUST have that rectangular fixture that is similar to the round one! The "good alternative" really is not. THE rectangular, really beautiful one is THE ONE: $10/month x 12 years.

  • 9 years ago

    Sorry to say I agree with Delilah! If you love, love, love it, nothing else will compare. It is a statement piece and you will be looking at it all the time. Go for the real thing. Put off another purchase that isn't necessary right now to get what you really love.

  • 9 years ago

    Who makes the one that you're getting, and what is it's name? I ask because there may be companion pieces to go with it.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, there are other pieces in the collection but I didn't feel the others will work for us. There is a smaller drum just like the light we chose but it's large - I'm thinking it's 24" - and the vanity lights are heavy mercury glass and very cone shaped which i don't care for.

    So pendant search continues!!!

  • 9 years ago

    So I think I would do the pendants in another finish. The antique silver is really cool and I would let it stand alone in that finish. Do you know what you are going to do for hardware on the cabinets?

  • 9 years ago

    Beautiful home and light choice. Just out of curiosity, since I'm paint-obsessed currently, what color is the main wall paint swatch for?

  • 9 years ago

    Annette- I'm glad you suggest not matching the finish. I thought about matching but I didn't want too match-matchup so great thought!

    lolauren- thank you!! The paint swatch is SW Sea Salt. I have it to show the wall color. It looks pretty green there but that's what we're going with. Kind of scary and hope it's not overbearing.

    Thank you for such great help!

    Sunny

  • 9 years ago

    Here are several island pendant options. I'd like opinions on which ones might look best. I'll also need one over the sink but would consider a semi flush mount there.


    Option 1.

    Probably one of my top picks. Like the finish and simplicity.


    Option 2.

    I also like this. The slight curve in the shade seems like it would go with the oval dining light.

    Option 3.

    Simple yet looks nice to me. Not sure if I like the cone shape, though.


    Option 4.

    Seems like it might feel bulky but it's 8" wide. I could put 2 so not to feel too heavy. The island is 8 feet and black with white perimeter cabinets and light granite. Black piano across the room on the other side of living area so would this tie things together?


    Option 5. Clean look.



    Option 6.

    I like this one!! Simple and similar finish to dining light without being too matchy-matchy.


    I really need your help and I'm open to your feedback or other ideas.

    Thank you!!

    Sunny


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I like the first option you posted best. And I agree the finishes don't need to match. There is enough separation so you don't have to worry about it.

    edited to add, consider making sure you have enough wattage. I also prefer a down light for an island so there is plenty of task lighting. Also, meant to say I love your table.

  • 9 years ago

    I like 1,4 and 6.

  • 9 years ago

    Outside playing - Thank you for the reminder about down lights when in a task area. I had not put that into my thought process and now will.

    Annette and Outside.... I like the first one, also!!

    It's amazing that we have GW. I've been a Garden Webber for many years and feel so fortunate. When I tell people about it that have never heard of it they are always so surprised.

    I'm going to throw a curve ball. I realized there is a 15" light to match my dining light. Should I consider that over my kitchen sink/window?? If I did I'd have to then go with a less expensive island pendant.

    Or should I go with option 1 and add 2 over island and 1 over sink???

    On a totally different subject Lowes has option 5 on sale for $14.99!! The light I'm looking at is slightly different and from a local lighting store but I still think that's a great price!!!

    Today I can get pictures of the painted cabinets which I'll post.

    Thanks again for taking time to help me and others out.

    Sunny


  • 9 years ago

    Pendant...number 1 for sure. And good find on the dining light!

    I also love that ballard designs oval light but yours fits perfectly.